Judah and Tamar, school of Rembrandt van Rijn, ca. 1640-1650. Rijksmuseum
Judah Meets Tamar “On the Road to Timnah”
Samson also meets a woman of questionable status in Timnah. Why do sexual encounters with foreign women take place in Timna?
Published: December 7, 2020
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Walter Brueggemann comments, “This peculiar chapter stands alone, without connection to its context. It is isolated in every way and is most enigmatic” in Genesis, Interpretation (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1982), 307. On the development and function of this independent unit within the Joseph story, see David M. Carr, Reading the Fractures of Genesis: Historical and Literary Approaches (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1996) 249–253. Carr argues that this story has a prehistory in legends related to the settlement of Israel’s ancestors (p. 250). On the indispensability of Genesis 38 within the surrounding narrative, see Robert Alter, The Art of Biblical Narrative (Revised and Updated; New York: Basic Books, 2011) 1 – 24. The story also has links with the David narrative in 2 Samuel. See the discussion in Mark Leuchter, “Genesis 38 in Social and Historical Perspective,” JBL 132.2 (2013): 209–227.
The ideas in this piece are based on the following forthcoming essays by Mahri Leonard-Fleckman: “Women as (De)constructions of Social Landscape,” in Forget Not God(s) Benefits (Ps. 103:2), ed. Barbara Reid, CBQMS (Washington: Catholic Biblical Association, 2021 [forthcoming]); “Binding Samson to Yhwh: from Social Ambiguity to Order in the Samson Cycle,” in Divinity in the Deuteronomistic History, eds. John McLaughlin and Corrine Carvalho (CBQMS; Washington: Catholic Biblical Association), forthcoming 2021; and “Betwixt and Between: The Elusiveness of Israel’s Iron Age Timnah,” In At the Margins: Interconnections of Power and Identity in the Ancient Near East, eds. Christian Casey, Sara Mohr and Shane Thompson (Boulder: University of Colorado Press), forthcoming 2021. On the term “entanglement,” particularly when it comes to identities that seem not to belong clearly to one social-political group or another, see Aren M. Maier and Louise A. Hitchcock, “The Appearance, Formation and Transformation of Philistine Culture: New Perspective and New Finds,” in The Sea Peoples Up-To-Date: New Research on the Migration of Peoples in the 12th Century BCE, eds. Peter M. Fischer and Teresa Bürge (Denkschrift Der Gesamtakademie: Contributions to the Chronology of the Eastern Mediterranean 81; Vienna: Austrian Academy of Sciences, 2017), 149–62; also Philipp W. Stockhammer, “Entangled Pottery: Phenomena of Appropriation in the Late Bronze Age Eastern Mediterranean,” in Materiality and Social Practice: Transformative Capacities of Intercultural Encounters, eds. Joseph Maran and Philipp W. Stockhammer (Oxford: Oxbow, 2012), 89–103.
See Joshua 15:35.
Verse 4 says that Shelah was born in Chezib, possibly related to the site Achzib (mentioned in Joshua 15:44 and Micah 1:14), southwest of Adullam. Aaron Demsky suggests it is in the vicinity of Mareshah in the shephelah (Judean lowlands). See Aaron Demsky, “Who Was Shelah Son of Judah and What Happened to Him?” TheTorah (2016). On the link between the otherwise-unattested Chezib and the biblical Achzib, see, e.g., Gerhard von Rad, Genesis (trans. John Marks; OTL; Philadelphia: Westminster, 1973), 353; and Nahum M. Sarna, Genesis: The JPS Torah Commentary (Philadelphia; New York; The Jewish Publication Society, 1989), 265.
On Tamar’s identity, see The Torah: A Women’s Commentary, Women of Reform Judaism, eds. Tamara Cohn Eskenazi and Andrea L. Weiss (New York: URJ, 2008), 216.
This would have been his duty as a levirate husband (cf. Deut 25:5).
For fuller discussions of Genesis 38 as a whole, and the character Tamar, see Pamela Barmash, “Tamar’s Extraordinary Risk: A Narrative—not a Law—of Yibbum,” TheTorah (2016); Jacqueline Vayntrub, “‘Her Name Was Tamar’: Invasive, Destructive, Redemptive,” TheTorah (2017).
The ending may thus be making a political claim, tying David’s lineage to Judah and Tamar, with Peretz coming out before Zerah (a different clan). Moreover, the story provides the Genesis material of the Joseph story with a southern perspective that is otherwise missing in the end of the book; it is a story about Judah and takes place in the territory of Judah. Mark Leuchter, “Genesis 38 in its Social and Historical Perspective,” 214–18, 223, argues that Genesis 38 reflects a Judahite agrarian lifestyle during Hezekiah’s urbanization project of 705–701 B.C.E., when rural Judahites were uprooted from their land.
The exceptions are Joshua 15:10, 57 and 2 Chronicles 28:18. Other attestations to Timnah that include the locative heh include Judges 14:1 (2x), 2, and 5 (2x); and Joshua 18:43. Greek witnesses sometimes preserve the directional he as part of the place name itself, so Timnah becomes Thamnatha, but not in Genesis 38:12-14, where Timnah is attested as Thamna.
They meet at a place called Einaim, an unknown toponym that can be translated as “eyes.”
Ultimately, the geography in Genesis 38, including Timnah, reflects a scribal obsession with geography and space as essential to Israel’s history. Credit goes to John Berquist for the expression, “the Bible is obsessed with space.” See “Critical Spatiality and the Construction of the Ancient World,” in ‘Imagining’ Biblical Worlds: Studies in Spatial, Social and Historical Constructs in Honor of James W. Flanagan, eds. David M. Gunn and Paula M. McNutt, JSOTSup 359 (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 2002), 14–29 [p. 25]. Places are key ingredients to narrative plotlines and to history writing, and characters embody and represent these places. When talking about the ancestors of Jacob (Israel) and the tribes of Israel, many readers of the Bible recognize the scribal preoccupation with land and its link with particular people. Yet it can be easy to forget the centrality of geography and characters who embody that geography when dealing with sites that seem less important to us, or somehow less vital to remembering Israel’s ancestors and their claims to land.
Perhaps Timnah is akin to what Michel Foucault would describe as a “heterotopia” (as opposed to “utopia” or a fundamentally unreal place): a real site that simultaneously functions as a “counter site,” in which place is contested, represented in various ways, and inverted to function as spaces for crisis or for deviant characters. See Michel Foucault, “Des Espaces Autres,” Conférence au Cercle d’études architecturales, March 14, 1967, published in Architecture, Mouvement, Continuité 5 (1984) : 46-49.
In the opening verses, she is described as a Philistine woman:
שופטים יד:א וַיֵּרֶד שִׁמְשׁוֹן תִּמְנָתָה וַיַּרְא אִשָּׁה בְּתִמְנָתָה מִבְּנוֹת פְּלִשְׁתִּים. יד:ב וַיַּעַל וַיַּגֵּד לְאָבִיו וּלְאִמּוֹ וַיֹּאמֶר אִשָּׁה רָאִיתִי בְתִמְנָתָה מִבְּנוֹת פְּלִשְׁתִּים וְעַתָּה קְחוּ אוֹתָהּ לִּי לְאִשָּׁה.
Judg 14:1 Once Samson went down towards Timnah; and while in Timnah, he noticed a girl among the Philistine women. 14:2 On his return, he told his father and mother, “I noticed one of the Philistine women in Timnah; please get her for me as a wife.”
This identification, however, appears only in the opening verses which Marc Brettler has argued is an editorial bridge. See Marc Z. Brettler, The Book of Judges (London; New York: Routledge, 2002), 43.
While the archaeological evidence is suggestive, no clear consensus exists on the relationship between the archaeological evidence and cultural reality, specifically how to reconstruct or label people in this region from the evidence—largely pottery and faunal remains—and the evidence varies over time and based on the site. For a sampling of the debates, see the articles in eds. Oded Lipschits and Aren M. Maeir, The Shephelah During the Iron Age: Recent Archaeological Studies (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 2017). For further discussion, see Mahri Leonard-Fleckman, “Tamar, Delilah and a Nameless Timnite.”
According to the director Amihai Mazar, the basis for linking biblical Timnah with the Tel Batash is the perceived connection between Timnah in Joshua 15:10 and Genesis 38; see Amihai Mazar, Timnah (Tel Batash) I: Stratigraphy and Architecture, Text (Qedem 37; Jerusalem: The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 1997), 3–4. This site is also mentioned in Judges 14–15 (discussed above) and 2 Chronicles 28:18. Another Timnah, attested only once in Joshua 15:35, is in the area southwest of Hebron, near Adullam. While this Timnah may be a good candidate for the Timnah of Gen 38, the literary connection to Judges suggest that the site in the Shephelah is the more likely candidate.
Editor’s note: For a discussion of Philistines in general, see Shirly Ben-Dor Evian, “The Philistines: Ancient Records, Archaeological Remains, and Biblical Traditions,” TheTorah (2015).
Amihai Mazar, “Concluding Remarks,” in Timnah (Tel Batash) III: The Finds from the Second Millennium BCE, eds. Amihai Mazar and Nava Panitz-Cohen (Qedem 45; Jerusalem: Institute of Archaeology, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 2006), 323–30.
Amihai Mazar has proposed that the 10th century occupation was “Israelite” and the 8th century “Judahite”; see Mazar, Timnah (Tel Batash) I, 249 – 63. See the arguments against Mazar’s interpretations in Shlomo Bunimovitz and Zvi Lederman, “The Early Israelite Monarchy in the Sorek Valley: Tel Beth-Shemesh and Tel Batash (Timnah) in the 10th and 9th Centuries BCE,” in I Will Speak the Riddles of Ancient Times: Archaeological and Historical Studies in Honor of Amihai Mazar on the Occasion of His Sixtieth Birthday (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 2006), 407 – 27. See also the discussion of the area in a broader sense in Maeir and Hitchcock, “The Appearance, Formation and Transformation of Philistine Culture.”
Amihai Mazar and Nava Panitz-Cohen, Timnah (Tel Batash) II: The Finds from the First Millennium BCE (Qedem 42; Jerusalem: Institute of Archaeology, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 2001), 282.