Judaism Without Sinai?

The Sinai theophany is virtually absent from the Bible outside of the Torah and the very late book of Nehemiah. This absence reflects an alternative tradition that sees Israel’s laws as deriving from multiple small revelations from prophets throughout history. 

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Judaism Without Sinai?." TheTorah.com, February 5, 2015. https://www.thetorah.com/article/judaism-without-sinai.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Judaism Without Sinai?" (2015, February 5). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/judaism-without-sinai

Judaism Without Sinai?

Mount Sinai. David Roberts 1839

Published: February 5, 2015

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1.   Of course, the Torah does not present all of the laws as delivered to Moses on the mountaintop. He continues to receives laws at the foot of the mountain, from the Mishkan/Ohel Moed, above the cherubs, that was set up at Sinai (see Lev. 1:1; 7:37–38; 26:46; 27:34). The laws at the end of Numbers are given at the Plains of Moab, but also from the Ohel Moed  (the Tent of Meeting). Since the very construction of the Mishkan was carried out on the basis of laws of construction given at Sinai, and since the cloud that hovered above it was the cloud that engulfed Mt. Sinai, the authority of the laws given at the Mishkan clearly derives from Sinai theophany even when the Mishkan moves. Thus, from the perspective of the Torah as a whole, the concepts of “Sinai theophany” and “Moses the lawgiver” are intertwined, and form the core of what would later be dubbed “Torah mi-Sinai.” 

  2. Deuteronomy speaks of “Horeb” rather than “Sinai” with reference to the same tradition of theophany and lawgiving in the wilderness.

  3. For another perspective on this point, see Pamela Barmash’s TABS essay, “The Omission of the Sinai Theophany in the Bikkurim Ritual Declaration.”

  4. Horeb is mentioned in 106:19, and Sinai in 68:9, 18, but the giving of the Torah is absent from both contexts. Moreover, Psalms never references Moses as lawgiver or mentions him giving a Torah or as uniquely above other prophets—all matters that the Sinai or Horeb revelation is meant to establish. Most significant in this context is the exceptional reference to Moses together with Aaron and Samuel in Psalm 99, 6—7:

    “Moses and Aaron were among his priests, Samuel also was among those who called on his name. They cried to the Lord, and he answered them. He spoke to them in the pillar of cloud; they kept his decrees, and the statutes that he gave them.”

    All three figures are apparently thought of as priests. Again, no mention of Sinai or Horeb is found, but the text may reflect Moses, Aaron and Samuel as givers of divine law. One may wonder if the reference to God as speaking to them from a cloud may not refer to the cloud associated with the ark (see Lev. 16:2). In any event, this text may well reflect the conception of which I speak below: prophets or priests in successive generations each offering their new contributions to the law. Since all of these prophets or priests are apparently thought of as equal in status it seems possible that later ones could not only add do divine law but also subtract.

  5. The Tradition of the Exodus in its Development, Jerusalem 1987, p. 12.

  6. The idea that the giving of the Torah is an act of divine grace is also expressed in the Dayeinu hymn of the Pesach Haggadah.

  7. See, e.g., Deut. 4:6, 8; 6:24—25;10:13; 27:18—19.

  8. While I think it is  possible that the whole Sinai Torah giving story is late, I believe that we must be cautious. We certainly cannot reliably date a story to the first explicit external reference to it.  Perhaps earlier texts referred to it and we just don’t have those texts. And I don’t see any clear signs of very late authorship in the contents of Exodus 19-24. For example, the fact that there is no stipulation for a human king in the law material, only a Nasi (Exod. 22:27), and the fact that the theophany parts imply that God is the king, could fit well with the early Israelite theology of the time of the Judges that rejected the legitimacy of human kingship.  Also, even if the story is late that does not necessarily mean that there wasn’t a tradition of lawgiving at Sinai that it is based upon. 

  9. For more on this, see Norman Solomon’s TABS essay, “Shavuot: How the Festival of Harvest Grew;” Evan Hoffman’s TABS essay, “Ezekiel’s Failure to Mention Shavuot,” and David Steinberg’s TABS essay, “Why Doesn’t the Torah Celebrate the Revelation on Mt. Sinai?”

  10. This is not to say that the biblical books are not concerned to underscore the divine authority of the prophet. See, for example, Joshua 3:7; 4:14 or 1 Sam. 12:17—18. This authorization, however, is accomplished by general signs or wonders that the prophet performs before the people and not by a divine act of pronouncing laws in the people’s hearing. Furthermore, the wonders authenticate the prophet’s authority in general and not specifically his authority to legislate divine laws. This is shown by the fact that the reports of prophetic wonders do not appear within the context of the stories of their lawgiving.

  11.  This concern also stands behind the late editorial comment at the end of the book of Malachi, the last book of the corpus of Prophecy: “ Remember the teaching of my servant Moses, the statutes and ordinances that I commanded him at Horeb for all Israel.” This late addition comes to affirm the authority of the Mosaic law specifically at the end of the prophetic writings, so that it be clear that prophecy cannot dislodge Mosaic law.

  12.  Note, in particular, the late attempt to ground prophetic authority specifically in the Sinai event in Deut. 18:16—22.