Job’s Tormentors, William Blake, 1793. Wikimedia
Lamenting with Job: The Karaite Version of the Fasts for Jerusalem
In keeping with the verses, Karaite Jews fast on the 9th of Tammuz, beginning the five weeks of mourning, which culminates with the dual fasts on the 7th and 10th of Av.
Published: August 12, 2016
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
I write this article in memory of Hakham Yehoshua Firrouz Z”TL of Be’er Sheva Israel, with whom I attended my first Karaite fast services. May his memory be a blessing.
This practice parallels the rabbinic custom of reading a special haftarah describing the punishment of Israel, called תלתא דפורענותא, on each of the Shabbatot of the three weeks. For more on this practice, see Elsie Stern’s TABS essay, “Lamentations in Seasonal Context.”
“A person may read from the Kinot (probably Lamentations), Job, and the negative passages in Jeremiah (וקורא בקינות, באיוב ובדברים הרעים שבירמיה).”
See Hakham Shlomo Ben Afidah HaKohen’s Yeriot Shlomo(1860 CE), Part 1 Yeriah 9:
תתחייב קראית ספר איוב כולו … ובעת הצהרים קראית הנחמות בהקדמת סדר זכור תחילה ובשביל זה נקרא יום נחמה.
A reading of the entire book of Job is required […] and in the afternoon [one should do] the readings of the consolations with the introductory prayer zachor (“Remember,” – the fifth chapter of Lamentations read daily during this period) and for this reason [the tenth of Av] is called the day of consolation (yom nechama).
Ezekiel 40:1 records a prophecy received “In the twenty-fifth year of our exile in the beginning of the year in the tenth day of the month in the fourteenth year after the city was smitten, on that selfsame day” (Ezekiel 40:1). The “twenty fifth year of our exile” refers to the exile of King Jehoiakim when many important Jews, including Ezekiel, were exiled in 597, a prelude to the exile of 586, when the First Temple was destroyed. (The exile of King Jehoiakim is used repeatedly to date events in the book of Ezekiel.) The Karaite sages understood “the beginning of the year in the tenth day of the month in the fourteenth year after the city was smitten, on that selfsame day” to refer to the 10th of Av – 14 years to the day since the burning of the temple marked the destruction of the city on the 10th of Av (Jeremiah 52:12). This dating makes sense in part because the “the beginning of the year in the tenth day of the month” cannot refer to the calendar year that begins on either the first of Nissan or the first of Tishrei. It also serves to explain what the verse means by “after the city was smitten, on that selfsame day” – the verse is emphasizing that it has been exactly 14 years to the day since the burning of the temple.
For a discussion about dating Ezekiel’s prophecy from a classical Karaite source, see Adderet Eliyahu (1530 CE) “Yom Hakippurim” Ch. 4 Pg. 46b Col 1:
ואמנם נהגו ומקבלים נחמה בעשירי לחדש החמישי מפני שההבטחה בבנין הבית היתה בו ככתוב בעשרים וחמש שנה לגלותינו בראש השנה בעשרה לחדש בארבע עשרה שנה אחר אשר הוכתה העיר ואלה השנים מעת אל עת.
However, we accept consolation on the tenth of the fifth month (ie: the month of Av) because the promise to [re]build the temple was on that [day] as it is written “in the 25th year of our exile at the start of the year on the tenth of the month in the fourteenth year after the city was smitten”, and these years are from time point to time point [as opposed to calendar years].
For a classical source for the Karaite fast dates, See the list of fast dates in Adderet Eliyahu “Yom HaKippurim” Ch. 4 Pg. 46a Col 2.
Gan Eden (1354 CE), Inyan Yom HaKippurim Ch. 5 Pg. 63b Col 2:
ונראה שבשביעי התחילו באשר סביבו ויום העשירי התחילו בבית עצמו
And it seems that on the 7th they began [burning] what was around it [i.e., the House of God] and on the tenth they burned the house itself.
Karaites believe Gedaliah died on the 24th of the 7th month, and that this event is commemorated by the fast mentioned in Nehemiah 9:1.