Lot and his daughters take refuge in a cave and begin their debauch; outside, his wife, now a pillar of salt, faces the furnace of Sodom. Engraving. Wellcome Library, London
Lot and His Daughters’ Motives for Their Incestuous Union
Genesis Rabbah surprisingly portrays Lot’s daughters and their choices in a decidedly positive light, while exacerbating Lot’s culpability.
Published: November 6, 2014
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
In scholarly analyses of the women in Gen 19, the daughters of Lot are given short shrift, since the emphasis is on their mother who is turned into salt in Gen 19:26. For a brief overview and an analysis of the extensive secondary literature on Lot’s wife, see T. J. Schneider, Mothers of Promise, 183–185.
In terms of a mythic explanation, etiology explains why things are the way they are—in this case, how the nations of Moab and Ammon received their names/came into being. The jab is that they came into being through an incestuous union.
For more on puncta extraordinaria, see Emanuel Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible 2nd rev. ed. (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2001), 55-57.
Editor’s note: This could be a play on Lot’s name, Lot was lahut (lustful). MZB
“The fact that the commentary in Genesis Rabba revolves around certain selected details of the biblical narrative confirms that its primary intention is not to explicate evenly all the words of the text, but to accomplish a broader cultural explication of scripture for contemporary generations” (E. M. Menn, Judah and Tamar (Genesis 38) in Ancient Jewish Exegesis: Studies in Literary Form and Hermeneutics [Leiden: Brill, 1997], 295 n14). This explication, according to Menn, includes the “broader program of recasting [certain] biblical characters associated with Israel’s history in an unambiguously positive light” (350).