How the Prohibition of Male Homosexual Intercourse Altered the Laws of Incest

Originally Leviticus 18 prohibited homosexual incest with a man’s father (v. 7) and his uncle (v. 14). When the prohibition of male homosexual intercourse was added, the Torah modified the aforementioned laws and consequently changed the meaning of לגלות ערוה “to uncover nakedness.”

SBL Style

Click to copy

"How the Prohibition of Male Homosexual Intercourse Altered the Laws of Incest." TheTorah.com, April 25, 2018. https://www.thetorah.com/article/how-the-prohibition-of-male-homosexual-intercourse-altered-the-laws-of-incest.

APA Style

Click to copy

"How the Prohibition of Male Homosexual Intercourse Altered the Laws of Incest" (2018, April 25). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/how-the-prohibition-of-male-homosexual-intercourse-altered-the-laws-of-incest

Published: April 25, 2018

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. This article is an adaption of Idan Dershowitz, “Revealing Nakedness and Concealing Homosexual Intercourse: Legal and Lexical Evolution in Leviticus 18,” Hebrew Bible and Ancient Israel 6:4 (2017).

  2. The only exception within the unit is v. 16, where X itself refers to two relatives: a woman and her daughter.

  3. Whether the preface is original to the core list or part of an editorial expansion is hard to say.

  4. These verses forbid intercourse with sisters (v. 18), menstruants (v. 19), married women (v. 20), males (v. 22), and beasts (v. 23). Verse 21 forbids offering a child to the god, Molech, which seems unconnected to the theme of this chapter.

  5. S. D. Luzzatto, Il Pentateuco, volgarizzato e commentato da Samuel Davide Luzzatto, Vol. III — Levitico (F. Sacchetto: Padua, 1874), 137. My translation. “Sex” may not fully capture the nuance of the biblical text. גלה ערוה has an inherent directionality with an active (גלה) and a passive (ערוה) participant; the phrase “sexual penetration” better reflects this asymmetry.

  6. Several manuscripts have a reconciling conjunction between the two halves of the last verse, suggesting that there are two prohibited individuals here: paternal uncle, and wife of paternal uncle (see SP, LXX, Neofiti, Pseudo-Jonathan, Vulgate, Syriac, inter alia).

  7. The possibility that this prohibits a son from intercourse with his father was nevertheless considered in b. San. 54a. Cf. Sifra, Qedoshim 9:12; j. Sanhedrin 7:8, 24d. Maimonides lists intercourse between a male and his father, and between a male and his paternal uncle, among the Pentateuchal prohibitions. (Sefer Hamitzvot, negative commandments 351 and 352.) Among more recent scholars, Daube is noteworthy for preferring the simple reading of 7a at the expense of 7b: “Verse 7 forbids intercourse with father or mother.” See D. Daube, Studies in Biblical Law (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1947), 81.

  8. My translation.

  9. Sarah J. Melcher, “The Holiness Code and Human Sexuality,” in Biblical Ethics and Homosexuality (ed. R. L. Brawley; Louisville: Westminster–John Knox Press, 1996), 87–102, here 94.

  10. Leviticus 17–22, 1537. Emphasis and parentheticals mine.

  11. Luzzatto, Il Pentateuco, 137. My translation. This view has been adopted by some modern scholars, including Gordon J. Wenham, The Book of Leviticus (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1979), 255.

  12. Howard Eilberg-Schwartz, The Savage in Judaism (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1990), 170–171.

  13. J. Roy Porter, Leviticus, 143.

  14. Several scholars have, in fact, suggested that the elaborations in this unit are late. Separately, some have argued that “the nakedness of your father” is an interpolation, leaving only the mother in the proposed original version of v. 7. See, especially, K. Elliger “Das Gesetz Leviticus 18,” ZAW 67 (1955): 1–24, here 1–2. See also M. Noth, Das Dritte Buch Mose, Leviticus (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1962), 116–117; J. Roy Porter, Leviticus(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1976), 145–146.

  15. Harry A. Hoffner, “Hittite Laws,” CoS 2.19:118. “Unpermitted sexual pairing” corresponds to the Hittite term ḫurkel.

  16. Like “begging the question,” whose colloquial sense differs significantly from the formal one, “the exception proves the rule” is often used to mean “the counterexample (counterintuitively) supports the argument,” rather than “the exception indicates the existence of an implicit rule.”

  17. For example, a sign that reads “OFFICE CLOSED ON WEEKENDS” can be reasonably taken to indicate that said office is open on weekdays. I. Sassoon employs this same principle in his analysis of the Deuteronomic law of the kadesh. See Isaac Sassoon, “What Does Deuteronomy Say about Homosexuality?” TheTorah.com (2017).

  18. Harry A. Hoffner, “Incest, Sodomy and Bestiality in the Ancient Near East,” in Orient and Occident: Essays Presented to Cyrus H. Gordon on the Occasion of his Sixty-Fifth Birthday (ed., Harry A. Hoffner, Jr.; AOAT 22; Neukirchen-Vluyn: Neukirchener Verlag, 1973), 81–90. Similarly, Olyan states: “Paragraph 189 of the Hittite Laws states that a man may not have sexual relations with his mother, daughter, or son. The context suggests that kinship is the issue in the case of the son, not his sex.” (“‘And with a Male,’” 192.)

  19. Editor’s note: For discussion on the meaning of this verse, see Shawna Dolansky,“Regarding Azazel and Homosexuals in the same Parasha,” TheTorah.com (2015); David Frankel, “Male Homosexual Intercourse Is Prohibited: In One Part of the Torah,”TheTorah.com (2017).