Menstruant as Zavah: How the Laws of Niddah Developed

Leviticus 15 describes two types of impure bleeding for women: menstruation (niddah), and bleeding that is “not during her menstrual period (zavah).” The Rabbis attempt to define the difference in an abstract manner, and in so doing, elide the two.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Menstruant as Zavah: How the Laws of Niddah Developed." TheTorah.com, April 18, 2018. https://www.thetorah.com/article/menstruant-as-zavah-how-the-laws-of-niddah-developed.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Menstruant as Zavah: How the Laws of Niddah Developed" (2018, April 18). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/menstruant-as-zavah-how-the-laws-of-niddah-developed

Menstruant as Zavah: How the Laws of Niddah Developed

Tractate Niddah 1897 Vilna Printing 

Categories:

Metzora

Published: April 18, 2018

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The text goes on to explain in more detail what it means by flow:

    ויקרא טו:ג וְזֹאת תִּהְיֶה טֻמְאָתוֹ בְּזוֹבוֹ רָר בְּשָׂרוֹ אֶת זוֹבוֹ אוֹ הֶחְתִּים בְּשָׂרוֹ מִזּוֹבוֹ טֻמְאָתוֹ הִוא.
    Lev 15:3 The impurity from his discharge shall mean the following — whether his member runs with the discharge or is stopped up so that there is no discharge, this is his impurity.
  2. ויקרא טו:יג וְכִי יִטְהַר הַזָּב מִזּוֹבוֹ וְסָפַר לוֹ שִׁבְעַת יָמִים לְטָהֳרָתוֹ וְכִבֶּס בְּגָדָיו וְרָחַץ בְּשָׂרוֹ בְּמַיִם חַיִּים וְטָהֵר
    Lev 15:13 When one with a discharge becomes clean of his discharge, he shall count off seven days for his cleansing, wash his clothes, and bathe his body in fresh (or “running”) water; then he shall be clean.
  3. The language of the Torah assumes blood as the representative female genital fluid also for the non-menstrual flow (15:25).

  4. In the Amoraic period, this receives the name “small zavah” (זבה קטנה) while zavah gets called “great zavah” (זבה גדולה). Tannaitic sources do not use this terminology. 

  5. The rabbis also include a woman who gives birth in the niddah category for this purpose.

  6. Biblically speaking, no ritual of washing or purification is listed for either of these women, but for various reasons, the rabbis assume that she must immerse in a mikvah. See discussion in my, “Niddah (Menstruation): From Torah to Rabbinic Law,” TheTorah.com, (2018). See also Zev Farber, “The Purification of a Niddah: The Torah Requirement,” TheTorah.com(2014); Yitzhaq Feder, “The Purification of a Niddah: The Legal Responsibility of a Reader,”TheTorah.com (2014); Isaac Sassoon, “The Purification of a Niddah: When Silence Matters,”TheTorah.com (2014). 

  7. When the Mishnah says (Niddah 4:7) that “during the entire eleven days she is presumed to be pure,” it projects that it is known what these eleven days refer to. 

  8. The Jerusalem Talmud says this in the name of Bar Kappara (j. Berakhot 5:1). The Sifraand the Babylonian Talmud cite it in the name of Rabbi Eleazar ben Azariah quoting Rabbi Akiva (Sifra, Tzav, 6:11.6; b. Niddah 72b, b. Menachot 81a).

  9.  Editor’s note: For a discussion of this and other “from Sinai” claims in rabbinic literature, see Yoseif Bloch, “Trusting in the Process of Torah Mi-Sinai,” TheTorah.com (2016).

  10. This problem was noted explicitly by Rashbash (R. Solomon ben Simon Duran, 1400-1467), who argues in a responsum (#513b) that the length of women’s cycles must have changed over the years, since in his days, the zivah period should be 14 days not 11. Biologically speaking, this shifting of cycle lengths must be considered a fanciful suggestion, but it underscores the empirical problem: as a rule, women do not have 18-day cycles. One elegant solution suggested by David Steinberg (personal communication) might be that it is based on the simple mistake of confusing eleven and twenty-one, but that seems unlikely, since no manuscript and no text in the halakhic literature ever offers this possibility.

  11. This was not how Maimonides understood the niddah/zivah cycle in his earlier years (see his commentary on the Mishnah, Niddah 4:7). Apparently, his view changed when he came in contact with Geonic responsa (such as that of Rav Sherira) on this topic which advocated for the rigid 7-11 cycle (see Joseph Kapih’s commentary on the Mishnah Torah, ad loc.). 

  12. And I am not even taking into account the interruption of birth and pre- and post-partum bleeding, or the question about what kind of discharge counts as blood – all of which complicate the calendar even further.

  13. The reference to these days of not bleeding as “clean days” appears for the first time in the talmudic discussions only, adding a connotation of hygiene to what until then was articulated in ritual terms. This unfortunately becomes much more pronounced in medieval halakhic literature. Another locution that appears (only once) in the Babylonian Talmud isyemei libun, the days of whitening. It is found in the pietistic story of the pious scholar who died young, because as it turns out he shared his bed with his wife during the days following her actual yemei niddah. Rashi interprets it to mean that she is wearing white (b. Shabbat13b, with Rashi ad loc.)

  14. Maimonides writes that “in the days of the gemara this matter of blood-flows became ridden with doubts, and the menstrual periods (vastot) disarranged.” Mishneh Torah,Hilkhot Issurei Bi’ah 11:3. In his view it is because of human limitations, not only the women’s, but the rabbinic sages’ also, who had a difficult time to distinguish different kinds of bleeding when consulted, that the practice changed. The rabbinic sages themselves also became subject to confusion by the account of the Talmud itself, because not all sages understand how to properly distinguish between different kinds of genital bleeding, some which may or may not be subject to the impurity of niddah.

  15. Also cited on b. Berachot 31a-b, b. Megillah 28b and elsewhere in rabbinic literature. In the Yerushalmi, this is formulated as a rule attributed to Rav Huna, rather than as a shift in women’s practice (j. Berakhot 5:1, 8d).

  16. There are so few practices whose origin is attributed to women in the Talmud that every time they are, one must at least wonder why this would be the case, especially as the practice is reported by one of the talmudic scholars themselves. Some feminist scholars have suggested that the talmudic sages here may have attributed the shift in practice to women in order to make it more persuasive to them, e.g., Judith Hauptman, Rereading the Rabbis: A Woman’s Voice (Boulder: Westview Press, 1998), 158. Others have suggested that the phrase benot yisrael is predominantly used in the context of ritual innovation, allowing us to consider women as ritual agents, rather than mere recipients of the halakhic process, e.g., Mika Ahuvia and Sarit Kattan Gribetz, “‘The Daughters of Israel’: An Analysis of the Term in Late Ancient Jewish Sources,” Jewish Quarterly Review 108:1 (Winter 2018): 20.

  17. Maimonides writes that “everyone, in every place where are Jews, observes this minhag (custom).” (Hilkhot Issurei Bi’ah, 11:3).

  18. This refers to women who ovulate after the seven-day period is over but during their seven “clean” days, before they go to the mikvah.

  19. See, Daniel Rosenak, To Restore Purity to Its Former Splendor (Tel Aviv: Yedioth Ahronoth, 2011 [Hebrew]), and even earlier, Blu Greenberg, On Women and Judaism: A View from Tradition (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1981), 121. See also the responsa in the Conservative Movement, pushing to abolish treating niddah as zivah: Susan Grossman, “Mikvah and the Sanctity of Being Human,” CJLS (2006); Avram Israel Reisner,“Observing Niddah in Our Day,” CJLS (2006); Miriam Berkovitz, “Reshaping the Laws of Family Purity for the Modern World,” CJLS (2006).

  20. Indeed, by insisting on ritual purification of any type, they are mixing Leviticus 15, concerning sanctuary impurity, with the sexual prohibitions of chapters 18 and 20.