Morality and Prepositions: On Taking a Mother on Her Young

Using the martial idiom “taking a mother on her young,” Deuteronomy forbids taking eggs and chicks without first shooing the mother bird. Is the concern cruelty to animals?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Morality and Prepositions: On Taking a Mother on Her Young." TheTorah.com, September 12, 2016. https://www.thetorah.com/article/morality-and-prepositions-on-taking-a-mother-on-her-young.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Morality and Prepositions: On Taking a Mother on Her Young" (2016, September 12). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/morality-and-prepositions-on-taking-a-mother-on-her-young

Morality and Prepositions: On Taking a Mother on Her Young

California High Desert Mourning Dove and Squabs in Cactus Protected Nest. Jessie Eastland / Wikimedia 

Categories:

Ki Teitzei

Published: September 12, 2016

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. In rabbinic literature, as early as the Mishnah (m. Hul. 12:1), the commandment is called שילוח הקן.  This term is puzzling, for while the word שילוח is the nominal form of the piel verb תשלח in Deut 22:7, the object of the verb in the verse is האם “the mother,” not הקן “the nest.”  The commandment ought therefore to be called שילוח האם.  Perhaps שילוח האם was excluded because this term would have called to mind divorce, another context in which שלח is employed in the piel (Deut 24:1).  Cf. the liturgical use of the phrase קן ציפור “the bird’s nest” in m. Ber. 5:3, quoted below.

  2. The preliminary vocative, “My people, children of Israel,” is a characteristic feature of Aramaic translation practice (targum) in Palestine—see, e.g., the translations of the Decalogue, wherein the vocative precedes each commandment—and presumably reflects a synagogue Sitz im Leben.  Cf. Tanhuma (Warsaw) va-yese 8, which characteristically reverses the pedagogical hierarchy by having God learn mercy from humans.  God tells Leah: את רחמנית ואף אני מרחם עליה , “You are a merciful person [in your concern for Rachel], and I too will have mercy upon her.” 

  3. The quotation is from Talmud Yerushalmi: According to Ms. Or. 4720 (Scal. 3) of the Leiden University Library with Restorations and Corrections (Jerusalem: Academy of the Hebrew Langauge, 2001), 47.  On the Yerushalmi passage and related texts see Eliezer Segal, “Justice, Mercy and a Bird’s Nest,” JJS 42 (1991), 176-95. The Aramaic translation critiqued by R. Yose son of R. Bun so assimilates Lev 22:28 to Deut 22:6-7 that the male animals of Lev 22:28 become, in the translation, females.

  4. It is notable that the only other case, to my knowledge, where God’s mercy is set in contrast with his “measures” is the passage in b. Ber. 7a about the prayer that God himself recites, and that Ishmael b. Elisha recited before God when he entered into the Holy of Holies and saw God sitting on his throne.  This prayer calls for God’s mercy to be “rolled” (?; cf. Gen 43:18; b. Pesah. 87a) upon his (other?) “measures,” i.e., that it be God’s dominant attribute.  Could R. Yose in fact be rejecting the formulation, “Upon the bird’s nest does your mercy extend” because it is too evocative of quasi-mystical prayers of the sort put forward in b. Ber. 7a?

  5. According to Maimonides, in his Guide for the Perplexed, iii.48, the commandment’s concern is specifically to spare the feelings of the mother bird.  This position conveniently supports the distinction that Maimonides makes throughout his philosophical work between an astringently rational intellectual faculty, specific to human beings, and an inferior, imaginative faculty, which underlies emotional expressions and moral judgments, and is also the province of animals.  Nahmanides, in his commentary ad Deut 22:6, argues that the Bible is not concerned with the mother bird’s emotional pain but with the human actor’s character.  Nahmanides also offers a different explanation for the commandment, rooted in considerations not of mercy but of conservation: “Scripture does not permit us to slaughter in such a way as to uproot the species, even though slaughter of that species is permitted.”

  6. The link between the phrase האם על הבנים in Deut 22:6 and the usage exemplified in Gen 32:12 and Hos 10:14 was well known to ancient exegetes; see, e.g., Gen. Rab. 76:6.

  7. I have modified the NJPS’s rendering to clarify the points of contact among the verses.

  8. On the martial allusions in Deut 22:6-7 see, with caution, Calum M. Carmichael, “On Deuteronomic Legislation – Sparing the Mother Bird, ”Law and History Review 2 (1984), 298-99. 

  9. Cf. Num 31:8 ואת מלכי מדין הרגו על חלליהם, rendered thus by the NJPS: “Along with their other victims, they slew the kings of Midian.”  The NJPS apparently takes the antecedent of the prepositional suffix –הם to be Israel, but as or even more likely, the antecedent is the kings of Midian, and the point of the suffix, in conjunction with the preposition, is to indicate that Israel executes the kings of Midian together with, or even specifically after, or even upon, their slaughtered armies.

  10. For the opposition between רחמים and אכזרי see Prov 12:10; Sifre Deut.323.

  11. See also Prov 11:17.

  12. By the same token, traditional sources recognize that it is specifically those distant from the experience of raising children who are characteristically cruel.  See in particular the baraita in b. Sanh. 36a: “It was taught: We do not appoint to the Sanhedrin an old man, or a eunuch, or one who has no children.  R. Judah adds: Also a cruel person.”  R. Judah’s addendum in fact exposes the rationale of the other three exclusions: The old man, the eunuch, and the childless man may not judge a crime because, having either never had or long forgotten (per Rashi ad loc.) the experience of, rearing a child, they incline toward cruelty.  On “young angels” who are “cruel angels” (מלאכים נערים .. מלאכים אכזרים), see Mek. R. Ish. be-shsalah 6; Mek. R. Sh. ad Ex 14:27.  (The text is certain, even though Sifre Deut. 357 worrisomely speaks of “evil angels, … cruel angels” [מלאכים רעים … מלאכים אכזריים].)  It is possible that the פרחי כהונה “budding priests,” the priestly ephebes (cf. 2 Macc 4:14) who, according to the rabbis, dispensed violent justice to the wicked in the temple, among other tasks—see t. Sot. 1:7; t. Me‘il. 1:16, and especially m. Sanh. 9:6, and see also Sifre Num. 161—represent the earthly analogues of, or the model for, these cruel, young angels.

  13. See n. 5 above, on Maimonides’ imaginative faculty and its relationship to moral judgments.  On the long-standing question of the relationship between ethics and aesthetics; see, e.g., Jerrold Levinson, ed., Ethics and Aesthetics: Essays at the Intersection (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001).