Moses’ Father-in-Law: Kenite or Midianite?

In the ancient world, genealogy was not about family relations but about political alliances.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Moses’ Father-in-Law: Kenite or Midianite?." TheTorah.com, June 1, 2015. https://www.thetorah.com/article/moses-father-in-law-kenite-or-midianite.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Moses’ Father-in-Law: Kenite or Midianite?" (2015, June 1). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/moses-father-in-law-kenite-or-midianite

Moses’ Father-in-Law: Kenite or Midianite?

Jethro and Moses, James Tissot, c. 1896-1900. Wikimedia

Published: June 1, 2015

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Hovav ben Reuel is referred to as Moses’ חֹתֵן. Although this is almost certainly meant to say that Hovav is Moses’ father-in-law, some commentators, to solve the contradiction with Exodus 2 in which Reuel is the father-in-law, assume that the word חֹתֵן here modifies Reuel and not Hovav. Although this is theoretically possible, Judges 4:11 belies this reading, since it refers to Hovav as Moses’ חֹתֵן, but does not include the patronymic “son of Reuel.”

  2. This is one reason that traditional commentators suggest that Exod 18 is out of place; they wish to identify the two stories as reflecting one occurrence, thus solving the problem of the sudden appearance of Moses’ father-in-law in the camp. Even allowing the change of names, this approach is problematic since Moses’ father-in-law leaves at the end of ch. 18, so how do we then explain what his clan is doing in Israel according to Judges and Samuel? It seems clear to me that the confusion derives from the existence of multiple traditions about Moses’ father-in-law, what his name was, from what clan he derived, and what he did for Israel in the wilderness.

  3. The Torah does call Hovav’s father Reuel, presumably the same person identified as Moses’ father-in-law in Exodus 2. But this would make Hovav Moses’ brother-in-law, which is not the plain meaning of the verse and contradicts Judges 4:11. To solve these problems, some traditional commentators identify Hovav with Jethro (Rashi); others identify Jethro with Reuel and say Hovav is Moses’ brother-in-law (ibn Ezra); others make all three the same person (midrash). None of the approaches really solves all the problems.

  4. He was called Kenite because he purchased (קנה) the world-to-come (see Mekhilta deRashbi 18:10, Sifrei Bemidbar, “Behaalotecha” 78). Although this works as midrash, this is not why the Kenites are called Keni in the biblical text; but rather because they are descended from Kain.

  5. This may be a reference to the same personage Cain who is described in the Torah as the son of Adam and first murderer. If so, it brings up the interesting question of how a small clan from biblical times came to have their lineage traced to a primordial figure like Kain.

  6. “Prophecies against the gentiles” is a genre in prophetic literature, in which the prophet curses the non-Israelite nations and predicts their demise.

  7. I imagine that this is because they are the clan of Moses’ father-in-law. Although the Hever text quoted above cuts both ways, I believe it also implies that the Israelites and the Kenites were allies. In this text, Hever—a descendant of Moses’ father-in-law Hovav, breaks off from the rest of his clan and moves near Kedesh of Naftali, becoming an ally of Jabin, king of Hazor. Although the text doesn’t say specifically, this verse could have been meant as an accusation against Hever that by making peace with Jabin King of Hazor, Hever is betraying his primary allegiance to Israel, thus forcing his wife Yael to take matters into her own hands and correct her husband’s bad behavior by killing Sisera herself. Presumably, the origins of this primary allegiance is based on the ancient relationship Hovav the Kenite and Moses, which the verse goes out of its way to mention.

  8. In theory, this could be a reference to Hovav functioning as a guide as Moses requests in Numbers 10:31.

  9. There may have been a popular story about how Moses, when wandering in the wilderness, married a woman from a foreign tribe. This could have begun simply as a popular Egyptian-style literary trope, as we see the same contours in the story of Sinuhe. More on the relationship between the Tale of Sinuhe and the Moses story would take us too far afield.

  10. A similar point was made in TABS Editors, “Our Stepmother Keturah,” TheTorah (2013).

  11. For a book length treatment of this topic, see: Amanda Podany, Brotherhood of Kings: How International Relations Shaped the Middle East (Oxford University Press, 2010). For an application of this idea to the passage about the Transjordanian tribes, see Jacob L. Wright, “Redacting the Relationship to the Transjordanian Tribes,” TheTorah (2014).

  12. Translation from: Keith Hamilton and Richard Langhorne, The Practice of Diplomacy: Its Evolution, Theory, and Administration (Taylor and Francis, 2011), 9.

  13. Whether Israel was ever in a hostile relationship with the Kenites is not discussed in the Bible, but the inclusion of this group with the Canaanite natives as well as the account of Balaam’s curse implies that, at one time, the Israelites considered them to be enemies. With the Midianites, the case is more clear cut, since they are explicitly referenced as enemies in the account of Gideon (Judg 6-8), in Psalms (83:10), and even in the Torah itself in the account of Baʿal Peʿor (Num 25:16-18; 31).