Bar Kochba, Arthur Szyk 1927. Wikimedia
Persecuting Circumcision
Samson, Saul, Jonathan, and David insult the Philistines for being uncircumcised. Antiochus IV prohibited circumcision, while Mattathias and later John Hyrcanus forced others to circumcise. In Roman times too, Emperor Hadrian forbade circumcision, and Bar Kochba circumcised Jews by force. Was circumcision a cause of the revolt?
Published: December 7, 2023
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Avraham Faust, “The Bible, Archaeology, and the Practice of Circumcision in Israelite and Philistine Societies,” JBL 134:2 (2015): 273-290. Many of Israel’s neighbors, such as the Egyptians, and probably many others (see Jer 9:25-26) practiced circumcision, so the Philistines would have stood out as different.
For a discussion of this story and its possible meanings, see David Frankel, “Joshua Circumcises Israel in Response to Egypt’s Scorn,” TheTorah (2018); idem, “Why Didn’t the Israelites Circumcise in the Wilderness?” TheTorah (2021).
The meaning of this punishment is uncertain. See discussion in, Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16, Anchor Bible 3A (New York: Doubleday, 1991), 457–460, who understands this as a divine penalty, either about lack of descendants or afterlife. This is the rabbinic interpretation as well, though many modern scholars see it as a human penalty, perhaps banishment.
The Greek Celsus, writing during the reign of Tiberius (14-37 CE), describes two such operations in De medicina (7.25.1).
That Antiochus instituted restrictive religious measures as a response to rising tensions, not, as Jewish tradition and 1 Maccabees suggest, that the revolt followed the persecutions, was first suggested by Victor Tcherikover, Hellenistic Civilization and the Jews (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1959), 191, and has now become a consensus position.
See also 2 Macc 6:10.
The manuscript traditions differ on whether those boys circumcised were “in the boundary/borders of Israel,” which would include Gentiles, or only those who were among “the sons of Israel.” The latter is the reading of Isaac T. Soon, “‘In strength’ not ‘by force’: Re-reading the circumcision of the uncircumcised ἐν ἰσχύι in 1 Macc 2:46,” Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha 29:3 (2020): 158-159.
See also the forced circumcision of the Itureans in Ant. 13.318 and the possible refusal of circumcision at Pella in Ant. 13.397. See also LXX Esther 8:17, which notes that after the Jews' victory over Haman, "many of the Gentiles were circumcised, and became Jews, for fear of the Jews." This again suggests that in times of conflict between Jews and non-Jews, circumcision played a pivotal role in aligning oneself with the whomever was more powerful.
We can contrast these examples of forced or attempted circumcisions with the more freely chosen desire to be circumcised in Josephus’ story of the conversion of the Adiabene royal house in the first century C.E. He relates how the Prince Izates wants to be circumcised, because this is the only way to become an Ioudaios, a Jew (Ant. 20.38–39). See discussion in Malka Z. Simkovich, “Queen Helena of Adiabene and Her Sons in Midrash and History,” TheTorah (2018).
Werner Eck, “The Bar Kochba Revolt: The Roman Point of View,” Journal of Roman Studies 89 (1999): 78.
The text reads:
Circumcidere Iudaeis filios suos tantum rescripto divi Pii permit - titur ; in non eiusdem nationis qui hoc fecerit , castrantis poena ir – rogatur.
Rabbinic midrash presents the two as having been friends and often in discussion of Torah topics. Whether the midrash is envisioning Antoninus himself or his philosopher son, Marcus Aurelius (r. 161–180 C.E.), or some amalgamation of the two is unclear.
The story appears in the standard printing, edited by Hanokh Albeck, (ch. 22 verse 2, pp. 86–87), and is also discussed in Samuel Krauss, “La légende de la naissance de Rabbi,” Revue des études Juives 58 (1909): 65–74 [72–73]; Alexander Guttmann “The Patriarch Judah I — His Birth and His Death: A Glimpse into the Chronology of the Talmudic Period” HUCA 25 (1954): 239–261 [244–245].
The text here has Rabban Gamliel (III), Rabbi Judah HaNasi’s son, and father of Rabbi Judah Nesiah, which Albeck accepts, but Krauss corrects this as a mistake, following the Menorat HaMeor’s text of Rabban Simon ben Gamaliel. While this would make a serious difference historically, it makes little difference in capturing the flavor of a medieval legend.
That Rufus functions in the Talmud as the agent of Hadrian’s evil-doing even after the suppression of the revolt (see b. Ta’anit 29a)—though historically speaking, we do not have evidence of Rufus as governor after the revolt—makes it uncertain if Bereshit Rabbati is claiming that this was a cause or an effect of the revolt.
When during his rule it took place is less clear. According to b. Sanhedrin 68a, Rabbi Eliezer died before the revolt and so this passage seemingly corroborates a pre-Bar Kochba revolt ban. A baraita in b. Shabbat 130a, however, attributes the statement to R. Judah bar Ila’i, active in the period after the revolt, but still in the name of R. Eliezer.
The Greek reads:
Barnabas 9:4 οὐκοῦν περιέτεμεν ἡμῶν τὰς ἀκοάς, ἵνα ⸂ἀκούσαντες λόγον⸃ πιστεύσωμεν ἡμεῖς. Ἀλλὰ καὶ ἡ περιτομὴ ἐφ’ ᾗ πεποίθασιν κατήργηται, περιτομὴν γὰρ εἴρηκεν οὐ σαρκὸς γενηθῆναι. ἀλλὰ παρέβησαν, ὅτι ἄγγελος πονηρὸς ἐσόφιζεν αὐτούς.
Text and translation from Michael W. Holmes, ed., The Apostolic Fathers: Greek Texts and English Translations, 3rd ed. (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2007), 406–407. The reference to an evil angel follows the pervasive angelology of Second Temple Judaism, which sees angels as conduits of revelation (e.g., Jubilees 2:1) as well as the existence of evil angels (e.g. Philo, De Gig. 16:22, The Testament of the Twelve Patriarchs). The reference to an evil angel who deceives the Jews about circumcision is meant to convey the wrongness of this practice. See J. N. B. Carleton Paget, “Barnabas 9:4: A Peculiar Verse on Circumcision," Vigiliae Christianae 45:3 (1991): 242-254.
E. Mary Smallwood, “The Legislation of Hadrian and Antoninus Pius against Circumcision,” Latomus 18.2 (1959): 334–347 [p. 337]. See also, eadem, “The Legislation of Hadrian and Antoninus Pius against Circumcision: Addendum,” Latomus 20.1 (1961): 93–96.
The Latin reads:
et eatempestate Judæi bellum quod vetabantur mutilare genetalia.
This text is often attributed to Aelius Spartianus, and this is how Smallwood refers to it in her article.
The clearest example of this is Cassius Dio’s Roman History 69, 12:1-14:3. While no archaeological evidence exists for the building of a Roman temple to Jupiter, numismatic evidence confirms the existence of the Roman city Aelia Capitolina. It is unclear, however, if its existence predates or postdates the revolt. For example, Eusebius of Caesarea, a bishop living between 260-340 C.E., places the creation of Aelia after the revolt when Jerusalem was emptied of Jews (History of the Church 4, 6:1-4). See Yoram Tsafrir, “Numismatics and the Foundation of Aelia Capitolina,” in The Bar Kochba War Reconsidered, ed. Peter Schäfer (Germany: Mohr Siebeck, 2003), 31-36.
See, for example, Bereshit Rabbah 64:10. To read more, see, for example, Moshe David Herr, “סיבותיו של מרד בר-כוכבא” [The Causes of the Bar Kokhba War], Zion 43 (1978): 1–11; Mordechai Gichon, “New Insight into the Bar Kokhba War and a Reappraisal of Dio Cassius 69.12-13,” The Jewish Quarterly Review 72 (1986): 15-43; Peter Schäfer, “Hadrian’s Policy in Judaea and the Bar Kochba Revolt: A Reassessment,” in A Tribute to Geza Vermes: Essays on Jewish and Christian Literature and History, ed. by Philip R. Davies and Richard T. White (England: JSOT Press, 1990), 280-303; idem, “The Bar Kokhba Revolt and Circumcision: Historical Evidence and Modern Apologetics,” in Jüdische Geschichte in hellenistisch-römischer Zeit: Wege der Forschung: von alten zumneuen Schürer, ed. Aharon Oppenheimer (München: Oldenbourg Wissenschaftsverlag, 1999), 119-132.
Ra’anan Abusch, “Negotiating Difference: Genital Mutilation in Roman Slave Law and the History of the Bar Kokhba Revolt,” in The Bar Kochba War Reconsidered, ed. Peter Schäfer (Germany: Mohr Siebeck, 2003), 75-76.
Even so, it is unlikely that circumcision could have been confused with castration. If Hadrian had wanted to prohibit circumcision, then we can assume that he would have explicitly listed it. A separate word for circumcision (circumcidere) existed in the Latin of second century C.E., which no doubt would have been used if Hadrian intended to legislate against circumcision. (Abusch, “Negotiating Difference,” 77–78.)
See discussion in, Aharon Oppenheimer, “The Ban on Circumcision as a Cause of the Revolt: A Reconsideration,” in The Bar Kochba War Reconsidered, ed. Peter Schäfer (Germany: Mohr Siebeck, 2003), 55; Menachem Mor, “Are There any New Factors Concerning the Bar-Kokhba Revolt?” Studia Antiqua et Archaeologica 18 (2012): 161–193; and Herbert W. Benario, A Commentary on the Vita Hadriani in the Historia Augusta (Chico: Scholars Press, 1980), 10.
See discussion in Joshua Hammer, “Anti-Semitism and Germany's Movement Against Circumcision,” The Atlantic (Jan 7, 2013).
For a survey of the various attempts at banning circumcision, see “Circumcision and Law,” Wikipedia.