Preparing the Red Heifer in Purity: The Rabbis’ Polemic against the Sadducees

Several stories describe how the rabbis of the Second Temple period would force priests to prepare the ashes in the lower state of purity, tevul yom (immersed in water before sunset), and once even discarded ashes prepared in the stringent state of purity, meʿorav shemesh (after sunset), to demonstrate the law is not in accordance with the Sadducees. The Qumran halakhic text, 4QMMT, gives us the perspective of the other side of the debate.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Preparing the Red Heifer in Purity: The Rabbis’ Polemic against the Sadducees." TheTorah.com, July 7, 2022. https://www.thetorah.com/article/preparing-the-red-heifer-in-purity-the-rabbis-polemic-against-the-sadducees.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Preparing the Red Heifer in Purity: The Rabbis’ Polemic against the Sadducees" (2022, July 7). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/preparing-the-red-heifer-in-purity-the-rabbis-polemic-against-the-sadducees

Preparing the Red Heifer in Purity: The Rabbis’ Polemic against the Sadducees

Sacrificing the red heifer, Jan Luyken, 1683 (detail, adapted). Rijkmuseum

Categories:

Chukat

Published: July 7, 2022

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. Notably, the ritual contains a paradoxical effect, such that the pure person who prepares the concoction as well as the pure person who sprinkles it on the impure becomes impure himself, albeit only for a day. This effect brought about various speculations as to the reason behind this mysterious rule. See discussion in Ed Greenstein, “Is it Possible to Make Sense of a Biblical Ritual (Chok)?” TheTorah (2013).

  2. Some especially severe impurities require something more. Thus, contact with a dead body requires the sprinkling of the red heifer waters (Num 19) and someone who contracted tzaraʿat skin disease requires the complicated ritual involving sacrifices, shaving, and anointing in blood and oil (Lev 14).

  3. This was one among other issues that sparked profound controversy in Second Temple Jewish society. Some of these debates have been preserved in the Dead Sea Scrolls and Second Temple literature; others are attested in rabbinic literature.

  4. See discussion in, Hayah Katz, “Biblical Purification: Was It Immersion?” TheTorah (2014); Yonatan Adler, “On the Origins of Tevilah (Ritual Immersion),” TheTorah (2017).

  5. Hebrew text from, Menahem I. Kahana, ספרי במדבר: מהדורה מבוארת [Sifre on Numbers: An Annotated Edition] (Jerusalem: Magnes, 2015), 2.421]; b. Yoma 43b and parallels. The same derasha is offered on v. 9 in Sifrei Numbers §124 (Kahana ed., 2.400–41). See Kahana’s commentary on both passages in 5.1016–1018, 1069–1070.

  6. The text continues with a second midrashic proof, whose meaning is difficult to discern:

    ר[בי] אומ[ר]: "נא[מר] כן טהור ונאמ[ר] להלן טהור. מה טהור האמ[ור] להלן טמא לתרומה וטהור לחטאת, אף טהור האמ[ור] כן טמא לתרומה וטהור לחטאת.
    Rabbi [Judah HaNasi] says: “Here it uses the term ‘pure’ and there it uses the term ‘pure.’ Just as ‘pure’ over there refers to one who is impure for the purposes of eating terumah and pure for the purposes of the chatat (meaning the red heifer), so too, ‘pure’ here is one who is impure for the purposes of eating terumah, but pure for the purposes of a chatat.

    This same derasha appears in the name of Rabbi Nathan in Sifrei Numbers §124, as a gloss on verse 9. In both cases, it is unclear what the midrash means by “there.”

  7. Moreover, it leads to a paradox in rabbinic halakha: The water of purification is defiled even by the touch of holy and completely pure sacrifices and heave offerings, and these pure offerings are defiled by the touch of the tevul yom. In the purity hierarchy of the rabbinic system the higher the level of purity, the more vulnerable it is to impurity. The red cow's ashes and the water containing it (ḥattat) are at the pinnacle, followed by sacrifices, terumah (heave offering), the second tithe, and, at finally, pure, nonsacred food. Therefore, a person (or vessel) pure enough to eat sacrifices defiles the water of purification (ḥattat) on touching it, unless he specifically purified himself for handling the latter (m. Ḥag. 2:7; m. Neg. 14:3; m. Parah 10:1, 6; 11:2, 3). One of the disparities between the higher (sacrifices, terumah) and lower (second tithe, nonsacred food) levels of purity is that the former are forbidden to a tevul yom, whereas the latter are not defiled or disqualified by his touch (m. Parah 11:4; m. Zabim 5:12). This would imply that a tevul yom should be forbidden to touch the waters, and yet, the tevul yom’s status of partial purity, insufficient to allow him to touch terumah and holy offerings, is considered sufficient for handling the superior purity of the water of purification!

  8. The Hebrew text is from the Kaufmann MS.

  9. תוספתא פרה ג:ה ומטמאין היו הכהן השורף את הפרה מפני הצדוקין שלא יהו אומרים במעורבי השמש נעשית.
    t.Parah 3:7 And they would [deliberately] defile the priest who was to burn the cow, on account of the Sadducees, so that they should not say, “[only] by those on whom the sun has set was it [the cow] prepared.”
  10. The Vienna MS reads אחר.The printed text says אחד. A Genizah fragment (T-S E2.135), and R. Yehuda ben Klonimus (12th cent.) of Speyer’s ערכי תנאים ואמוראים s.v. יהושע בן גמלא as well as Rabbi Samson of Sens’ (ca.1150–ca.1230) commentary on the Mishnah (Parah 3:8) read אחת, like in the Mishnah.

  11. The Hebrew text follows the Vienna MS here.

  12. Zvi Stampfer, “ומטמאים היו את הכהן,” [They Would Defile the Kohen], Netuim 4 (1998): 33–51, at 46–47, suggests that the metaphorical meaning of this verb is 'to threaten', making the priest the subject of the sentence. The translation above assumes the meaning “to pull” for the verb צרם. Nevertheless, the verb can also mean “to tear,” which led R. Judah ben Kalonymus of Speyer (ערכי תנאים ואמוראים, Blau ed., 1.186) to suggest that Rabban Yoḥanan is the subject of the verb, and that he assaults the priest:

    לאחר שעלה צרם לו באזנו, פירוש עשאו בעל מום ובעל מום פסול בפרה...
    “After he came up he tore at his ear”—meaning, he made him someone with a blemish, for a [priest] with a blemish is disqualified from performing the red heifer sprinkling ritual…

    See discussion in, Saul Lieberman, תוספת ראשונים: פירוש [Tosefet Rishonim: A Commentary] [New York: Jewish Theological Seminary, 1939], 218; Kook, Collected Studies, 53–54.

  13. It is not clear whether the deliberate defiling of the priest was always practiced or only in cases in which he was suspected to be in the state of me'orav shemesh, a fully pure person on whom the sun has set. The story in the Tosefta may attest to the latter option (Kook, Collected Studies, 49–50). Stampfer ("They Would Defile the Kohen," 48–52) even submits that it happened only once that the High Priest was intentionally defiled, as described in the Tosefta, and that the Mishnah, following the Tosefta (rather than vice versa per Lieberman, Tosefet Rishonim, 218) described it post factum as a fixed custom.

  14. Elisha Qimron and John Strugnell (in consultation with Yaakov Sussmann and with contributions by Yaakov Sussmann and Ada Yardeni), Qumran Cave 4.V: Miqsat Ma’ase Ha-Torah, DJD 10 (Oxford: Clarendon, 1994); Elisha Qimron, מגילות מדבר יהודה: החיבורים העבריים [The Dead Sea Scrolls: The Hebrew Writings], (Jerusalem: Yad Ben-Zvi, 2013), 2.204–11; idem, The Qumran Texts: Composite Edition (Hebrew; Tel Aviv, 2020, https://zenodo.org/record/3737950#.XoXRs6gzaiM), 2:204–11; Reinhard G. Kratz, ed., Interpreting and Living God’s Law at Qumran: Miqṣat Maʻaśe Ha-Torah: Some of the Works of the Torah, SAPERE 37 (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2020). I am currently preparing a new edition with new readings and a comprehensive commentary; Vered Noam, “Some Precepts of the Torah”– An English Translation and Commentary of 4QMMT, Decipherment and Reconstruction by Eshbal Ratzon, The Oxford Commentary on the Dead Sea Scrolls (forthcoming). For a recent introduction to 4QMMT and rabbinic halakhah, see Vered Noam, "From 4QMMT to the Rabbinic Halakhah," in Kratz, Interpreting and Living, 137–159.

  15. 4QMMT is composed of three parts:

    1. A solar calendar (fragmentarily preserved) of a type familiar to us from other Qumran works;
    2. A sequence of polemically formulated legal statements;
    3. A section whose separatist speakers address another group and its leader, pleading with them to do “what is righteous and good in His eyes,” while referring to the blessings and curses due in the end-time.

    Part b of the scroll enables recovery of many of the issues fueling the intersectarian controversy of that day. For more on the framing of the text as a letter, see, Steve D. Fraade, “To Whom It May Concern: Miqsat Ma'ase Ha-Torah (4QMMT) and Its Addressee(s),” Revue de Qumran 19.4 (2000): 507–526.

  16. Letters that the Torah writes with a sin are often written with a samekh in Qumran as well as in rabbinic literature (e.g., שיד in Deuteronomy 27:2, 4 becomes סיד in Mishnah Sotah 7:5). See Qimron and Strugnell, Qumran Cave 4.V: Miqsat Ma’ase Ha-Torah, 69.

  17. This unusual phrase means It means "in order that" (comp. בְּשֶׁל אֲשֶׁר in Eccl 8:17). There are two additional occurrences in MMT. It appears in one of the Bar Kokhba letters. See Qimron and Strugnell, Qumran Cave 4.V: Miqsat Ma’ase Ha-Torah, 89–90.

  18. The reconstructed text is based on two fragments of Some Precepts of the Torah, 4Q394 3–7 I, 16–19; II, 1 and 4Q395 1:8–11; b 13-17; I underline text that comes from the second above. Letters with a dot on top are uncertain (empty dots reflect greater uncertainty).

  19. See also 4Q269 8 II, 3–6; 4Q271 frag. 2:10–13; 4Q276 frag. 1:1–9; 4Q277 1 I,1–2, II, 1–10. In treating additional impurities, other DSS sources also specify that purity is achieved only after sunset following immersion. See 4QMMT B:72; 11QT 45:9; 50:4, 15; 51:3, 5; 4Q266 6 II, 4; 4Q284 2 II, 4; frag. 3:2, frag. 6:2; 4Q512 48–50:5. See Yigael Yadin, ed., The Temple Scroll. (Jerusalem: Israel Exploration Society, 1983(, 1.340; Lawrence H. Schiffman, “Pharisaic and Sadducean Halakhah in Light of the Dead Sea Scrolls: The Case of Ṭevul Yom,” Dead Sea Discoveries 1 (1994): 287–299.

  20. Sussmann, "The History of Halakha and the Dead Sea Scrolls,” 28n74; 67n220. Menahem Kister of Hebrew University noted that the argument put forth in the Tosefta, which mentions the more lenient custom of “the former generations,” reflects the centrality of ancestral tradition for the Pharisees. Kister, “Studies in 4QMiqṣat Ma’aśe Ha-Torah and Related Texts,” 331.

  21. Joseph Baumgarten, “'The Pharisaic-Sadducean Controversies About Purity, and the Qumran Texts,” Journal of Jewish Studies 31 (1980): 157–170 [157–161], the quote is on p. 158.

  22. Baumgarten, “The Pharisaic-Sadducean Controversies About Purity, and the Qumran Texts,” 158, 160. See also Schiffman, “Pharisaic and Sadducean Halakhah in Light of the Dead Sea Scrolls,” 287–299. For a revised opinion, see Joseph M. Baumgarten, “The Red Cow Purification Rites in Qumran Texts,” Journal of Jewish Studies 46 (1995): 112–119 [p. 112].

  23. Qimron and Strugnell, 4QMMT, 153–154.

  24. Hanan Birenboim, “Tevul Yom and the Red Cow: Pharisaic and Sadducean Halakah,” Dead Sea Discoveries 16 (2009): 254–273.

  25. Werman, “The Price of Mediation.”

  26. This option was first briefly alluded to by Baumgarten, “The Red Cow Purification Rites in Qumran Texts,” 112.

  27. Jacob Milgrom, “The Paradox of the Red Cow (Num. XIX),” VT 31 (1990): 62–72.

  28. Joseph Baumgarten, “'The Pharisaic-Sadducean Controversies About Purity, and the Qumran Texts,” Journal of Jewish Studies 31 (1980): 157–170; Israel Knohl, “Post-Biblical Sectarianism and the Priestly Schools of the Pentateuch: The Issue of Popular Participation in the Temple Cult on Festivals,” in The Madrid Qumran Congress: Proceedings of the International Congress on the Dead Sea Scrolls, March 1991, ed. J. T. Barrera and L. V. Montaner (Leiden: Brill, 1992), 601–609; Daniel R. Schwartz, “Law and Truth: On Qumran-Sadducean and Rabbinic Views of Law,” in The Dead Sea Scrolls: Forty Years of Research, ed. D. Dimant and U. Rappaport (Leiden: Brill, 1992), 229–240, at 229–230; Yaakov Sussmann, “Appendix 1: The History of the Halakha and the Dead Sea Scrolls,” in Qimron and Strugnell, Miqsat Ma’ase Ha-Torah,” 192–196; Lawrence H. Schiffman, The Courtyards of the House of the Lord: Studies on the Temple Scroll, ed. F. Garcia Martinez (Leiden: Brill, 2008), xviii–xix; Aharon Shemesh, Halakhah in the Making: The Development of Jewish Law from Qumran to the Rabbis (Berkeley: University of California Press,‎ 2009), 15–19, 129–140.

  29. Knohl, “Post-Biblical Sectarianism,” 608.

  30. Several scholars even suggest that the roots of these rival traditions lie in the biblical era. Knohl, “Post-Biblical Sectarianism;”; idem, “Between Voice and Silence: The Relationship Between Prayer and Temple Cult,” JBL 115 (1996): 17–30; Israel Knohl and Shlomo Naeh, “מילואים וכיפורים” ]Milluim ve-Kippurim], Tarbiz 62 (1993): 17–44, at 35–38; for a slightly different view, see Eyal Regev, “Reconstructing Qumran and Rabbinic Worldviews: Dynamic Holiness vs. Static Holiness,” in Rabbinic Perspectives: Rabbinic Literature and the Dead Sea Scrolls, Proceedings of the Eighth International Symposium of the Orion Center, ed. S. D. Fraade et al., STDJ 62 (Leiden: Brill, 2006), 87–112, at 106.

  31. Menahem Kister, “עיונים במגילת מקצת מעשי התורה ועולמה: הלכה, תאולוגיה, לשון ולוח” [Studies in 4QMiqṣat Ma’aśe Ha-Torah and Related Texts: Law, Theology, Language and Calendar] Tarbiz 68 (1999): 317–371, at 325–330; Eyal Regev, הצדוקים והלכתם [The Sadducees and Their Halakhah] (Jerusalem: Yad Ben-Zvi, 2005), 209–215, 416–418.

  32. The DSS frequently mention the priests, “sons of Zadok,” as “preservers of the Covenant” (1QS 5:9), and its legal texts mostly treat the priestly realms of purity, temple, and sacrifice. Schwartz, “Law and Truth”; Cana Werman, “The Price of Mediation: The Role of Priests in the Priestly Halakhah,” in Dead Sea Scrolls and Contemporary Culture: Proceedings of the International Conference Held at the Israel Museum, Jerusalem (July 6–8, 2008), ed. A. D. Roitman, L. H. Schiffman, and S. Tzoref (Leiden: Brill, 2011), 377–409.

  33. Birenboim, “Tevul Yom and the Red Cow,” 270

  34. Werman, "The Price of Mediation," 403.

  35. See also, 4Q276 frag. 1:3–4, 9; 4 Q277 1 II, 3, 4, 6.

  36. See also, M. Parah 5:4, 12:10, t. Parah 4:1, 11; Sifre Num. 123 (Kahana ed., 391); 124 (399); 129 (420).

  37. Maimonides, Code, “The Red Heifer,” 1:13, 10:5; Shaul Hanna Kook, עיונים ומחקרים [Collected Studies] (Jerusalem: Mosad Harav Kook, 1959), 1.50–51; Ya'akov Sussmann, "חקר תולדות ההלכה ומגילות מדבר-יהודה: הרהורים תלמודיים ראשונים לאור מגילת 'מקצת מעשי התורה” [The History of Halakha and the Dead Sea Scrolls — Preliminary Observations on Miqṣat Ma'ase Ha-Torah (4QMMT)], Tarbiz 59 (1990): 11–76ת at 28n74; Qimron and Strugnell, 4QMMT, 153.

  38. Kister, “Studies in 4QMiqṣat Ma’aśe Ha-Torah and Related Texts,” 334–335. The Babylonian Talmud (b. Yoma 2a) was already aware of this discrepancy.

  39. Kister, “Studies in 4QMiqṣat Ma’aśe Ha-Torah and Related Texts,” 332–335; Vered Noam, "Pharisaic Halakha as Emerging from 4QMMT," in The Pharisees, ed. J. Sievers and A. J. Levine (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2021), 55–79.