Shaming Women Suspected of Adultery - What About Men?

The Mishnah adds further humiliation to the biblical sotah ritual for a suspected adulteress. Other rabbinic texts from the same period critique this expansion, as well as the gender inequality inherent in the ritual itself.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Shaming Women Suspected of Adultery - What About Men?." TheTorah.com, June 3, 2020. https://www.thetorah.com/article/shaming-women-suspected-of-adultery-what-about-men.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Shaming Women Suspected of Adultery - What About Men?" (2020, June 3). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/shaming-women-suspected-of-adultery-what-about-men

Shaming Women Suspected of Adultery - What About Men?

Ceremony of the Suspected Adulteress (colorized), Matthijs Pool, 1686 - 1727

Categories:

Nasso

Published: June 3, 2020

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Traditional and modern commentators debate the exact meaning of this expression, whether it refers to removing some kind of head covering or unravel the woman’s done-up hair (see e.g. Sifrei Numbers 11). In ancient times, women would not appear in public with free-flowing long hair, which is why this act is considered a humiliation of sorts, since she is forced to appear before God and the priest with her hair undone or exposed.

  2. As the place she is standing is before the Holy of Holies, it is still “before God,” yet, in the Mishnah’s staging, her back is to the Temple and she is facing courtyard. As such, the ritual is transformed into a public spectacle.

  3. The text continues:

    ר׳ יְהוּדָה אוֹ׳ אִם הָיָה לִיבָּהּ נָאֶה לֹא הָיָה מְגַלֵּיהוּ וְאִם הָיָה סְעָרָהּ נָאֶה לֹא הָיָה סוֹתְרוֹ׃

    1. Judah says: “If her bosom was lovely, he would not expose it. If her hair was lovely, he would not loosen it.”
  4. Translation is mine, from the forthcoming Oxford Mishna: A New Annotated Translation of the Mishnah (edited by Shaye Cohen and Hayim Lapin).

  5. Elsewhere, I have dealt in detail with the Mishnaic ritual and its possible sources Ishay Rosen-Zvi, The Mishnaic Sotah Ritual: Temple, Gender and Midrash (Leiden: Brill, 2012).

  6. The Sifrei cites a Mishnah here which is similar but not identical to our Mishnah (cited above). The Midrash may be citing the Mishnah of R. Ishmael, the head of the school to which Sifrei Numbers belongs. See further Menachem Kahana’s Commentary to Sifrei Numbers (Jerusalem 2015) ad loc.

  7. See m. Yebam 6:6; Bab Qam 10:2; Bab Bat 8:5.

  8. These scholars even use this to reconstruct rabbinic discomfort with the harsh manner women are treated in this tractate. See, e.g. Judith R. Wegner, Chattel or Person? The Status of Women in the Mishna (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1988), 54; Tal Ilan, Jewish Women in Greco–Roman Palestine, 2nd ed. (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2006), 137; Moshe Halbertal, מהפכות פרשניות בהתהוותן: ערכים כשיקולים פרשניים במדרשי הלכה [Interpretive Revolutions in the Making: Values as Hermeneutic Considerations in the Halakhic Midrashim] (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1997), 105.

  9. This is, indeed, the function of all the other prooftexts brought in this chapter, to serve as proofs of the annulments or deaths described (thus repeatedly using negation -- "לא" and "אין", without addressing the reasons for these changes):

    משרבו הנואפים פסקו המים המאררים [...] שנ' לא אפקוד על בנותיכם [...]
    When adulterers abounded the water of bitterness ceased […] for Scripture says (Hos 4:14) “I shall not punish your daughters…”
    משמת יוסה [...] בטלו האשכולות, שנ' אין אשכול לאכול וגו'.
    When Yose died […] “clusters” ceased, for Scripture says (Mic 7:1) “there is no cluster to eat…”
    משבטלה סנהדרין בטל השיר מבית המישתיות, שנ' בשיר לא ישתו יין וגו'.
    When the Sanhedrin ceased, singing ceased at wedding feasts for it is written (Isa 24:9) “They shall not drink wine with a song…”
    משחרב בית המקדש [...] ופסקו אנשי אמנה [...] שנ' הושיעה ה' כי גמר חסיד כי פסו אמונים מבני אדם.
    When the Temple was destroyed […] the faithful men came to an end […] For it is written (Ps 12:2) “Help God for virtuous men are no longer; for the faithful have vanished from among the sons of men.”
  10. The two sources share the same nuclear formulation, and we may safely assume that this is the wording of the source behind both the Mishnah and the Tosefta. To this nucleus, each made various additions: the Mishnah brings a prooftext while the Tosefta adds explanations which establish that both rituals are only performed in cases of doubt. The Tosefta is manifestly more tight-knit, and it seems that the Mishnah extracted this paragraph from its critical context and set it in the context of lament. Note also that in both sources the tradition is connected to Rabban Yohanan ben Zakkai, but it is not clear how, as it appears in two different ways in the Mishnah and the Tosefta: The former attributes the annulment itself to him, while the latter presents him as but the reciter of the tradition.

  11. The Palestinian Talmud discussing our Mishnah makes this very point (Sotah 9:9, 24a):

    והיתה האשה לאלה בקרב עמה – בזמן שעמה שלום, לא בזמן שעמה פרוצים.
    “And the woman shall become an execration among her people” (Num 5:27) – when her people is in peace, not when her people is corrupt.

    Sifrei Deuteronomy (205) makes the same argument regarding the heifer ritual:

    'כי ימצא, ולא בשעה שמצוי'
    “if one finds” (Deut 21:1) – but not when it is ubiquitous

    Again, we see from this that the rabbis connect these two rituals and see them as functioning only when such acts are infrequent. When murder and adultery are no longer unusual, at a time when murder is "ubiquitous" or the "people is corrupt," there is no more room for such rituals. This gives us an important backdrop to any interpretation about what the rabbis are trying to communicate in their claim that the ritual had to be cancelled.

  12. On this passage see Ishay Rosen-Zvi, "מי יגלה עפר מעיניך משנת סוטה פרק ה' ומדרשו של ר' עקיבא" [Mishna Sotah Chapter 5 and the Midrash of Rabbi Akiva], Tarbiz 70 (2006): 95–128.

  13. ר' עקיבה אומר בא הכתוב ללמדך שסוף זה למות וצבתה בטנה ונפלה ירכה.
    R. Akiva says, “Scripture teaches she is destined to die [in such a way that] her belly shall swell, and her thigh shall fall away.”
  14. For a discussion of this verse in context, see Hanna Liss, “The Sotah Ritual: Permitting a Jealous Husband to Remain with His Wife,” TheTorah (2019). For an alternative reading see Jacob Milgrom, Numbers, JPS Torah Commentary (Philadelphia: JPS, 1990), 349–350.

  15. This is probably the earliest use of the metaphor in biblical literature. See discussion in Carl Ehrlich, “Hosea: Loving God Erotically,” TheTorah (2016). Israel Knohl, מחלוקת המשיח: למי מחכים היהודים? [The Messiah Controversy: Who Are the Jews Waiting For?] (Tel-Aviv: Kinneret-Zmora/Dvir, 2019), chap. 1, argues that this is a substitute for the kingship metaphor which Hosea rejects, as part of his rejection of kingship is general.

  16. For this reading of the verse, see Mayer I. Gruber, Hosea: A Textual Commentary (T&T Clark, 2017), 212–227, and discussion of other options there. Whether or not this is the plain meaning of Hosea, it is a reasonable realization of the verse, and thus used by those sages who wish to criticize the ritual.

  17. Editor’s note: For another discussion of discomfort with aspects of the ritual in biblical and rabbinic texts, see Idan Dershowitz, “The Guilt of the Slanderer and the Sotah: From Certainty to Uncertainty,” TheTorah (2015).

Related Topics:SotahAdulteryGender