The Kennicott Bible, 1476. Wikimedia
Sinai, Tabernacle, Golden Calf, and More Tabernacle: Compiling Exodus
Was the Tabernacle constructed only in response to the golden calf? Rashi and Nachmanides’s disagreement on this fundamental question highlights the structural problem in the second half of the book of Exodus, created when the compiler of the Torah interwove the E and P sources.
Published: March 14, 2023
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Biblical translations follow CJPS, with modifications.
Editor’s note: For more on this principle, see Isaac Gottlieb, “Highlighting Juxtaposition in the Torah,” TheTorah (2015).
In his comment to Exodus 31:18, Rashi (drawing on Midrash Tanchuma, Ki Tissa §31 [Warsaw ed.]) outlines the prevailing Rabbinic timeline that the tablets were broken on the 17th of Tammuz, and precisely 80 days later, on the 10th of Tishrei (Yom Kippur), YHWH became reconciled with Israel. The next day, donations commenced for the building of the Tabernacle. The instructions for building the Tabernacle preceded the donations but came after the infraction with the Golden Calf. This timeline is reiterated also in Rashi’s comments to Exodus 18:13 and 33:11.
Additional midrashic treatments of the Tabernacle (or parts thereof) as atonement for the Golden Calf are explicated in Rachel Adelman’s article, “Atoning for the Golden Calf with the Kapporet,” TheTorah (2019).
Perhaps the strongest proponent for the view that the Tabernacle was a concession is Moses Maimonides. See discussion in, Kenneth Seeskin, “The Tabernacle: A Concession to Human Religious Needs?” TheTorah (2020); Menachem Kellner, “Tabernacle, Sacrifices, and Judaism: Maimonides vs. Nahmanides,” TheTorah (2020).
Though I will not address the J source in detail here, J’s Sinai event is combined with E’s account of those events. For a closer look at the compiler’s work on the Revelation at Sinai, see Baruch J. Schwartz, “What Really Happened at Mount Sinai?” TheTorah (2013); first published under the same title in Bible Review 13.5 (October 1997): 20–30, 46.
Jeffrey Stackert, A Prophet Like Moses: Prophecy, Law, and Israelite Religion (New York: Oxford University Press, 2014), 171:
P imagines the Israelite world as fundamentally oriented toward its cult and the rules that strictly govern it. As P imagines them, these rules make it possible for YHWH to reside in Israel’s midst and for Israel to enjoy the tangible benefits that the deity’s presence confers. It is with these goals in view that P shapes its account, including its depiction of Moses and its imagination of prophecy.
See discussion in Naftali Cohn, “The Tabernacle, the Creation, and the Ideal of an Orderly World,” TheTorah (2015).
See Jeremy Schipper and Jeffrey Stackert, “Blemishes, Camouflage, and Sanctuary Service: The Priestly Deity and His Attendants” in Hebrew Bible and Ancient Religion 2.4 (2013): 458–487 (at 469):
[God] chooses to rehabilitate the created world – a world that has gone amok, become “marred” (נשחתה, Gen 6:12a), and no longer functions according to its design – precisely because he once enjoyed it and would like to do so again. As many have observed, God’s command following the Flood to be fruitful, multiply, and fill the earth (Gen 9:1, 7) recalls his initial charge to his creatures (Gen 1:28; cp. 1:22). In the Flood, God seeks to restore his creation in its goodness, a fundamental part of which is his delight in it.
In P, YHWH does not reveal the divine name before the encounter with Moses (Exod 6:2), yet it is the same deity throughout.
Indeed, some European scholars have argued that the core of P ends with the consecration of the Tabernacle. Others have argued that it ends with establishment of the Tabernacle in Shilo in Joshua. See the discussion and relevant bibliography in “The End of the Priestly Writing,” in Jakob Wöhrle, “The Priestly Writing(s): Scope and Nature,” in The Oxford Handbook of the Pentateuch, ed. Joel S. Baden and Jeffrey Stackert, Oxford Handbooks (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2021).
My source divisions follow Joel Baden’s analysis in The Composition of the Pentateuch: Renewing the Documentary Hypothesis (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2012).
See also Exodus 19:8 and 24:7.
I am simplifying here, since the Yahwist (J) also has a revelation account which is also included in the complication here, but it is not relevant to the specific issue in this article.
“Neo-documentarians” like Baruch Schwartz, Joel Baden, and Jeffrey Stackert preserve the basic hypothesis made famous by Julius Wellhausen more than a century ago. They argue that the Torah is the result of “four sources and one compiler” (Joel Baden, “The Re-Emergence of Source Criticism: The Neo-Documentary Hypothesis,” The Bible and Interpretation, May 2012). Each of the Pentateuch’s constituent sources—the Yahwist (J), the Elohist (E), the Priestly source (P), and the Deuteronomic source (D)—was for the most part coherent and complete prior to its compilation. Embellishments, lacunae, and inconsistencies within each source can be attributed to the editorial process and the inevitable impact of the passage of time while the bulk of each “document” remains largely, perhaps even surprisingly, intact and recoverable through close and careful reading.
Baden, “The Re-Emergence of Source Criticism.”
I refer to the compiler as “he” based only on the presumption that literacy was more widespread in ancient world among men than women. Lacking evidence about the compiler’s identity, though, it is impossible to speculate fruitfully about any personal details.
In other words, the P passages explicated above could be moved to after Exodus 34:28. The introduction to P’s Sinai story would then flow immediately into chapters 25–31 and the pericope would end, as P originally did, with 31:18aβ, followed by 34:29ff. This would have required a re-rendering of the opening of 34:29 to include something like 32:15’s וַיֵּרֶד מֹשֶׁה מִן הָהָר, “…and Moses went down from the mountain.” With this layout, the Tabernacle would more unambiguously be understood as a response to or consequence of the resolution of the Golden Calf incident. In this ordering, after YHWH gives the Decalogue, Israel immediately betrays YHWH with the golden calf (E). Moses then successfully intervenes (from the J source), YHWH gives the instructions for the Tabernacle as a sign of reparation (P), and the Tabernacle is immediately built. Editor’s note: Arguing that the law violated in the golden calf story is not the Decalogue’s commandment to worship YHWH exclusively, but the Covenant Collection’s prohibition against making idols of YHWH, see Joel Baden, “What Was the Sin of the Golden Calf?” TheTorah (2017).
This approach would place all of P’s material from Exodus 19–31 before the E (and J) stories of Exodus 19–24 and 32–34, with the building of the Tabernacle (ch. 35) following these accounts. Theoretically, the E (and J) material could have been located after the completion of the Tabernacle, though this would require an even more glaring temporal discontinuity, returning Moses to Sinai long after descending in (the current) Exodus 34:29. Such a reordering could have been prompted by a strong intention to thoroughly promote P’s theology.
This is the reading of Nachmanides, who writes in his comment to Leviticus 8:2:
ועל דרך הישר נצטוה משה במלאכת המשכן קודם למעשה העגל וכשנתרצה לו הקב"ה והבטיחו שישרה שכינתו בתוכם ידע מעצמו שמצות המשכן במקומה עומדת וצוה לישראל עליה כמו שפירשתי בפרשת ויקהל (שם לה א).
Moses was commanded concerning the Tabernacle before the incident of the Calf. And when the Holy One was reconciled to him and promised him that he would cause his presence to dwell among them, Moses knew on his own that the commandment of the Tabernacle remained valid and commanded Israel about it.
According to Jeffrey Stackert, “P advances a fundamentally positive anthropology: YHWH’s expectation – and that of the P authors – is that, under normal circumstances, humans will heed the deity’s commands.” See “Political Allegory in the Priestly Source: The Destruction of Jerusalem, the Exile and their Alternatives,” in The Fall of Jerusalem and the Rise of the Torah, ed. Peter Dubovský, Dominik Markl, and Jean-Pierre Sonnet (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2016), 211–226 (at 217). See also Stackert, A Prophet Like Moses, 180n22.