Sukkot’s Seventy Bulls

The Torah’s adaptation of a polytheistic ancient West-Semitic custom of sacrificing to seventy gods.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Sukkot’s Seventy Bulls." TheTorah.com, October 14, 2016. https://www.thetorah.com/article/sukkots-seventy-bulls.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Sukkot’s Seventy Bulls" (2016, October 14). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/sukkots-seventy-bulls

Sukkot’s Seventy Bulls

‘Bull’ is a suite of eleven lithographs by Pablo Picasso, that have become a master class in how to develop an artwork from a realistic image to an abstract form.

Categories:

Pinchas

Published: October 14, 2016

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. This piece is an adaptation of my academic article, which also includes fuller references and further discussion of certain points. Noga Ayali-Darshan, “The Seventy Bulls Sacrificed at Sukkot (Num 29:12-34) in Light of a Ritual Text from Emar (Emar 6, 373),” Vetus Testamentum 65 (2015): 1-11. I would like to thank TheTorah.com’s editors for helping me recast the piece to fit this forum.

  2. Cf. M. Noth, Numbers: A Commentary (OTL; trans. J.D. Martin; London, 1968), p. 223; H. Ulfgard, The Story of Sukkot: The Setting, Shaping, and Sequel of the Biblical Feast of Tabernacles (Tübingen, 1998), p. 90; A. Rofé, Introduction to the Literature of the Hebrew Bible (trans. H.N. Bock; Jerusalem, 2009), p. 475.

  3. In 1908, the Irish archaeologist R. A. Stuart Macalister, in his excavations of the city of Gezer, discovered what appears to be a Canaanite calendar likely dating to the 10th century BCE. The purpose of this calendar is unknown but it lists eight distinct periods during the year of either one or two months, based on the agricultural activities of the period. The calendar begins with (two) gathering/harvest months (ירחו אסף) and ends with the month of the summer fruit (ירח קץ).

  4. G.B. Gray, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Numbers (ICC; Edinburgh, 1903), pp. 406-407. Cf. C. Nihan, “Israel’s Festival Calendars in Leviticus 23, Numbers 28-29 and the Formation of ‘Priestly’ Literature,” in The Books of Leviticus and Numbers (ed. Thomas Römer; Leuven, 2008), pp. 185-186.

  5. Jacob Licht, A Commentary on the Book of Numbers [XXII-XXXVI] (ed. Shmuel Aḥituv; Jerusalem, 1995), pp. 82-83 (Hebrew). For a survey of Sukkot in Deutero-Zechariah and the antiquity of rain-making rituals in the autumnal festival, see J. Rubenstein, The History of Sukkot in the Second Temple and Rabbinic Periods (Atlanta: SBL, 1995), pp. 45-50 and n. 38. See also the discussion of Sukkot as a rain making festival in Rabbinic Tradition in, Zev Farber, “Water Libation (ניסוך המים): A Sukkot Rain-Making Ritual,” TheTorah (2015).

  6. J. Milgrom, Numbers (Philadelphia, 1990), p. 247; cf. Ulfgard, The Story of Sukkot, p. 90.

  7. For more on Emar, see M.W. Chavalas (ed.), Emar: The History, Religion, and Culture of a Syrian Town in the Late Bronze Age (Bethesda, 1996). The Akkadian cultic texts discovered in the city were first published in the 1980s by Daniel Arnaud with French translation. Daniel Fleming later republished some of these texts with an English translation, clarifying their content and West Semitic context. See D.E. Fleming, Time at Emar: The Cultic Calendar and the Rituals from the Diviner’s Archive (Winona Lake, IN, 2000).

  8. Fleming, Time at Emar, pp. 234-257.

  9. For the Mari tablet see J.-M. Durand, FM 7: Le Culte d’Addu d’Alep et l’affaire d’Alahtum, (Mémoires de NABU 3; Paris, 2002, no. 39 (A.1121+A.2731), ll. 3-12.

  10. The text was written in Akkadian, integrating Sumerian logograms that would have been read as Akkadian words. Assyriologists use capital letters to distinguish logograms from Akkadian signs in Akkadian texts. The phrase SAG.MU should be read in Akkadian as rēš šattim. However, we don’t know how the Emarite people themselves called this month in their West Semitic language.

  11. Editor’s note: For more on full-moon holidays in biblical times, see: Jacob Wright, “Shabbat of the Full Moon,” TheTorah (2015); “How and When the Seventh Day Became Shabbat,” TheTorah (2015).

  12. [12] For the textual and archaeological sikkānu-stones in the Syrian cultures, see T.N.D. Mettinger, “No Graven Image?”: Israelite Aniconism in its Ancient Near Eastern Context (OTS 42; Stockholm, 1995), pp. 115-134.

  13. For a detailed discussion of the seven-year cycle zukru-festival, see Fleming, Time at Emar, pp. 48-140. For the annual version (Emar 6, 375), see ibid. Cf also P. Altman, Festive Meals in Ancient Israel: Deuteronomy’s Identity Politics in Their Ancient Near Eastern Context (BZAW 424; Göttingen, 2011), pp. 136-147.

  14. Therefore Arnaud suggested that the larger number includes the consorts of the seventy. D. Arnaud, “Les texts suméro-accadiens de Meskéné (Syrie) et l’Ancien Testament,” Revue de l’histoire des religions 197 (1980), 117. However, this proposal does not match the evidence.

  15. Fleming, Time at Emar, pp. 290-291; cf. p. 194, n. 235.

  16. šbʿm bn Aʾṯrt (שבעם בנ את’רת; KTU3 1.4 VI 46).

  17. CTH 345.I.3:3-19; cf. V. Haas, Die hethitische Literatur: Texte, Stilistik, Motive (Berlin, 2006), p. 167; N. Ayali-Darshan, “The Role of Aštabi in the Song of Ullikummi and the ‘Failed God’ Stories Prevalent in the East Mediterranean”, JNES 73 (2014), pp. 95-103.

  18. 70 DINGIRMEŠ .

  19. D. E. Fleming, The Installayion of Baal’s High Priestess at Emar (HSS 42; Atlanta, 1992), p. 73.

  20. see E. Otto, “šeḇa´”, TDOT 14:350; M. Haran “The Graded Numerical Sequence and the Phenomenon of “Autonatism” in Biblical Poetry”, in Congress Volume, Uppsala 1971 (VTSupp 22; Leiden, 1972), pp. 238-267.

  21. This subject has received extensive treatment: see, for example, U. Cassuto, A Commentary on the Book of Genesis (trans. I. Abrahams; Jerusalem, 1961-1964), 175-177; F.C. Fensham, “The Numeral Seventy in the Old Testament and the Family of Jerubbaal, Ahab, Panammuwa and Athirat”, PEQ 109 (1977), 113-115;

  22. Thus the MT. The LXX and two Qumran fragments read 75. For more on this, see: Marc Zvi Brettler “The Opening of Exodus in the Dead Sea Scrolls,” TheTorah (2015). For a discussion of how 75 became 70, see: Itamar Kislev, “Jacob’s Descendants who go to Egypt: MT Versus LXX,” TheTorah (2015).

  23. [23] Cf. Cassuto, A Commentary on the Book of Genesis, pp. 175-177.

  24. Cf. m. Soṭ. 7:5; t. Soṭ. 8:5; b. Šabb. 88b; b. Sanh. 17a; b. Meg 13b; b. Soṭ. 36b; b. Men.65a; Exod. Rab. 5:9; Tanh. Shmot 25; Tanh. Dev. 2; Ps.-Clem. Hom. 18.4. For other occurrences see L. Ginzberg, The Legends of the Jews, V (Philadelphia, 1947), pp. 194-195. The same idea is found in the notion that the Torah has “seventy faces”—i.e., entire modes of expounding it: cf. Num. Rab. 13:15.

  25. Cf. Noth’s note (Numbers, p. 223): “Why … the sacrifice is diminished by one each day can no longer be explained with any certainty”; Ashley (Numbers, p. 571): “Scholars have attempted several explanations of this phenomenon, none of them convincing”. Late Jewish midrashim interpret the decrease as a symbol of the nations’ vanishing from the world: cf. Mid. Agg. (ed. Buber), Num. 28, p. 156; Pesikta Zutreta Phinehas (Venice, 1546), p. 61b.

  26. See A. Rofé, Deuteronomy: Issues and Interpretation (London, 2002), pp. 47-54 and the bibliography cited therein.

  27. Cf. H.L. Ginsberg, “A Strand in the Cord of Hebraic Hymnody”, EI 9 (1969), pp. 45-46.

  28. Cf. I.L. Seeligmann, “Researches into the Criticism of the Masoretic Text of the Bible”, Tarbiz 25 (1956), pp. 136-137 (Hebrew).

  29. Henotheism means loyalty to one particular deity without denying the existence of other deities.