Teaching Biblical Scholarship in a Modern Orthodox High School
The personal and educational challenges I faced teaching an introductory course on biblical scholarship to Modern Orthodox high school seniors: What I learned, what my students took home, and some suggestions on how to move forward.
Published: June 11, 2018
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Teens are sometimes looking for an excuse to exit, but as far as I can tell, they did not use biblical criticism in this way. The students who did drop Orthodoxy left for social and moral reasons, such as feminism and homosexuality; theological problems did not play a role in their religious trajectory. As one student wrote, “No one is going to be non-religious from biblical criticism in this class. If someone isn’t religious, they weren’t going to be, but now they have a better reason for not being. They just sound smarter. And if someone believes in it [Orthodox dogma], then this won’t matter.”
These four students each attended well-known and highly regarded Modern Orthodox high schools in North America.
99% of my students were happy they took this course. One student echoed a common refrain,
I am proud of my school that they are willing to go beyond the standard and expose us to all that is there to learn. All in all, I feel like this course has had a real positive impact on me as a learner and as a Jew.
Another student studying in Israel wrote,
When I compared my education to the people around me [in seminary], I felt like they were not challenging anything they had learned…I saw I had a more rational and less emotional approach.
Editor’s note: For an overview of Breuer’s and other approaches see “Current Approaches to Revelation and Torah,” TheTorah.com (2013).