The Book of Amos: A Retrospect on the Fall of Israel

Written as a commentary on the social injustice in the kingdom of Israel at a high point of its wealth and power, the book of Amos explains to exiled Israelites why they were punished and warns Judahites not to fall into the same trap.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Book of Amos: A Retrospect on the Fall of Israel." TheTorah.com, April 22, 2021. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-book-of-amos-a-retrospect-on-the-fall-of-israel.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Book of Amos: A Retrospect on the Fall of Israel" (2021, April 22). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-book-of-amos-a-retrospect-on-the-fall-of-israel

Categories:

Acharei Mot

Published: April 22, 2021

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Amos’s economic critiques are discussed by Marvin Sweeney in “The Bible’s Evolving Effort to Humanize Debt Slavery,” TheTorah (2016), although I do not share his historical conclusions.

  2. All translations of the biblical text follow the NJPS version, with modifications.

  3. The Haftarah in the Sephardi tradition is Ezekiel 20:2–20.

  4. On these verses in Leviticus, see John. J. Collins, “Love Your Neighbor: How It Became the Golden Rule,” TheTorah (2020); Richard Elliott Friedman, “The Exodus, the Alien, and the Neighbor,” TheTorah (2017).

  5. Jeroboam II also appears in Amos 7:10–11.

  6. See Ido Koch, “Assyrian Deportation and Resettlement: The Story of Samaria,” TheTorah (2019).

  7. The reference here to plundered fortresses indicates that the “enemy” (צר) here is military.

  8. Indeed, the book of Amos predicts other disasters, sometimes of a stereotypical nature. Some of these are portrayed as warning signs that have already occurred, such as the series of crises in Amos 4:6–11, but in anticipation of the larger disaster yet to come. Other depictions of disaster in the book are vague, or on the spiritual level, such as the absence of YHWH’s word in Amos 8:11, described as a famine not of food but of divine communication. Nonetheless, the overall portrayal of the coming material disaster is one of military invasion and exile. Conquest and exile are also predicted in Amos 7:11, 17, but as these verses are part of the “Amaziah narrative” of Amos 7:10-17 which is probably a later addition to the book, the exile references in that narrative are probably not relevant to the question of the date of the book’s initial composition.

  9. For the full argument for the dating and purpose of the initial composition of the book of Amos as presented here, see Jason Radine, The Book of Amos in Emergent Judah, FAT II:45 (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2010).

  10. Calneh and Hamath appear together also in Isaiah 10:9 (here Calneh is called “Calno”), in a context that more clearly indicates that they were conquered by Assyria:

    ישׁעיה י:ט הֲלֹא כְּכַרְכְּמִישׁ כַּלְנוֹ אִם לֹא כְאַרְפַּד חֲמָת אִם לֹא כְדַמֶּשֶׂק שֹׁמְרוֹן.
    Isa 10:9 Was Calno any different from Carchemish, or Hamath from Arpad, or Samaria from Damascus?

    See this passage all the back to Isaiah 10:5 to see that these cities were victims of Assyria.

  11. The common emendation to “or is your territory larger than theirs?” is probably correct, as this makes better sense of the passage. The sense then is: are you, Israel, stronger than these other nations?

  12. See Radine, Book of Amos, 56, for full references to these records.

  13. Removing Amos 6:2 from its literary context as a later addition disrupts the poetic structure of Amos 6 as a whole. Cf. Radine, Book of Amos, 31–36. Aren Maeir attributes the historical reference of Philistine Gath in Amos 6:2 to the ninth century on the basis of evidence of a major military engagement from that time at Tell es-Sâfī, the site identified as Gath. See Aren Maeir, “The Historical Background and Dating of Amos VI 2: An Archaeological Perspective from Tell es-Sâfī- Gath,” Vetus Testamentum 54.3: 319–334. (Maeir has written many more recent works on the site, of which he is the excavator, but this cited article directly addresses Amos 6:2.) However, the pairing of Calneh and Hamath in Amos 6:2, along with their pairing in Isaiah 10:9 and in the Assyrian records, suggests that Amos 6:2 is referring to the Assyrian campaign of 738 B.C.E. This historical context should probably guide how to read the Gath reference, not the remains of what was likely a different incident than what is referred to in Amos 6:2. What looks most dramatic in the material remains at the site now does not necessarily correspond to what was of interest to the author of a work from a century after the incident that left those remains. I have explored some possibilities for the Gath reference of Amos 6:2 in a Society of Biblical Literature Annual Meeting paper in 2017 entitled “The Historical and Archaeological Background of the Book of Amos Revisited” that I plan to publish in the future.

  14. “Ashimah” here is sometimes read as “guilt,” as the NJPS translation does, but this is unlikely.

  15. For a similar condemnation of foreign astral worship in Zephaniah, see Jason Radine, “The ‘Idolatrous Priests’ in the Book of Zephaniah” in Priests and Cults in the Book of the Twelve, ed. Lena-Sofia Tiemeyer, Ancient Near Eastern Monographs 14 (Atlanta: SBL, 2016), 131–148.

  16. For example, when the prophet Samuel is asked to locate Saul’s lost donkeys (1 Sam 9) and when Samuel, Nathan, Gad and other prophets advise the kings of Israel. For an analysis of one biblical story about court prophecy, see James A. Diamond, “Discerning False Prophecy: The Story of Ahab and the Lying Spirit,” TheTorah (2020). Elijah and Elisha as miracle-working prophets are a different phenomenon from either a mantic diviner or a supposed “writing prophet.” For a discussion of prophecy in the ancient Near East and the Bible, see Jonathan Stökl, “Ancient Israelite Divination: Urim ve-Tummim, Ephod, and Prophecy,” TheTorah (2018).

  17. There were prophecies critical of rulers in Near Eastern prophetic records outside of the Bible (particularly in the documents from Mari) even occasionally on social justice issues, but these are short statements addressed to rulers and not the far lengthier and more developed, socially-critical works directed to a public audience, typical of biblical prophetic literature.

  18. Since the biblical prophetic books show evidence of significant after-the-fact expansion, if not whole-cloth composition after the events which they anticipate, it seems reasonable to take this further and say that some may be entirely or mostly the product of scribes.

  19. Term coined by Maria DeJong Ellis, “Observations on Mesopotamian Oracles and Prophetic Texts: Literary and Historiographic Considerations,” Journal of Cuneiform Studies 41.2 (1989):127–186.

  20. Tania Notarius, in “Amos’ Puns in the Northern (Israelite) Dialect” (TheTorah 2016), effectively demonstrates how the use of language in the book of Amos shows how the book had Israelite refugees among its audience. She rightly avoids the assignment of the book to a northern provenance that linguistic Israelisms could suggest. She also rightly argues that the use of Israelian puns is most effective when there was still a distinct difference in dialect between the Hebrew of north and south, although where she thus dates the core of the book prior to 722/1, I date it to the near aftermath of that period, but still close enough in time that the dialects would have remained distinctive. For my argument that the books of Micah and Hosea present northern Israelite refugees as a danger to Judahite religion and survival (and for references to the debate on the existence of northern refugees in Judah), see Jason Radine, “Urban Change and the Designation ‘Israel’ in the Books of Micah and Hosea,” in Die Stadt in der Zwölfprophetenbuch, ed. Aaron Schart and Jutta Krispenz, BZAW 428 (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2012), 287–310.

  21. Typical of biblical literature, the book of Amos was expanded over time. Amos 1:3–2:5 portrays a regional destruction that did not occur until the Babylonian invasions of the early sixth century B.C.E., and Amos 2:4 condemns Judah for not following torah, a standard of Judahite behavior that begins around the time of the Babylonian exile. As stated above, the Amaziah narrative of Amos 7:10-17 is probably a later addition. The paradisiacal renewal in Amos 9:11–15 is commonly and rightly seen as a later addition to the book; its prediction of the restored “fallen sukkah of David” in verse 11 most likely points to the rebuilt Jerusalem temple, suggesting a date no earlier than the late sixth century B.C.E., if not later still.

Related Topics:Amos