Envisaging the Exodus Story: Meet the Egyptians

Symposium

Envisaging the Exodus Story: Meet the Egyptians

The Egyptian “Magicians”

Is the Bible’s portrayal of the magicians (Ḥarṭummīm) in accord with Egyptian literature and ritual practice? How did the Israelite writers obtain this knowledge?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Egyptian “Magicians”." TheTorah.com, March 30, 2017. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-egyptian-magicians.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Egyptian “Magicians”" (2017, March 30). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-egyptian-magicians

The Egyptian “Magicians”

Fig. 1. Lector-priest with kilt and sash performing the Opening of the Mouth ceremony on the deceased. Tomb of Menna at Thebes (ca. 14th c. BCE). © Ted Grudowski

Categories:

Va’era

Published: March 30, 2017

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. See, e.g., Abraham S. Yahuda, The Languages of the Pentateuch in Its Relation to Egyptian (London: Oxford University Press, 1933); T. O. Lambdin, “Egyptian Loan Words in the Old Testament,” Journal of the American Oriental Society 73 (1953), pp. 144-155; James K. Hoffmeier, “The Arm of God Versus the Arm of Pharaoh in the Exodus Narrative,” Biblica67 (1986), pp. 378-387; John D. Currid, Ancient Egypt and the Old Testament (Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Books, 1997); Gary A. Rendsburg, “Moses the Magician,” in Thomas E. Levy, Thomas Schneider, and William H. C. Propp, eds., Israel’s Exodus in Transdisciplinary Perspective: Text, Archaeology, Culture, and Geoscience (Quantitative Methods in the Humanities and Social Sciences, 2; New York: Springer, 2015), pp. 243-258.

  2. Ziony Zevit, “Three Ways to Look at the Ten Plagues,” Bible Review 6 (1990), pp. 16-23. See also Gary Rendsburg, “The Egyptian Sun-God Ra in the Pentateuch,” Henoch 10 (1988), pp. 3-15; “The Plagues in their Ancient Egyptian Context,” TheTorah.com (2014); and“YHWH’s War against the Egyptian Sun God Ra,” TheTorah.com (2015).

  3. Scott B. Noegel, Nocturnal Ciphers: The Punning Language of Dreams in the Ancient Near East (American Oriental Series, 89; New Haven, CT, 2007), pp. 128-140.

  4. John D. Currid, “Stalking Pharaoh’s Heart: The Egyptian Background to the Hardening of Pharaoh’s Heart in the Book of Exodus,” Bible Review 9 (1993), pp. 46-51. Emily Teeter, The Presentation of Maat: Ritual and Legitimacy in Ancient Egypt (Studies in Ancient Oriental Civilization, 57; Chicago, IL: Oriental Institute, 1997). Editor’s note: For more on ma’at and the pharaoh’s role in maintaining it, see Jan Assmann, “Pharaoh’s Role in Maintaining Ma’at,” TheTorah.com (2016).

  5. See Jan Quaeqebeur, “On the Egyptian Equivalent of Biblical Ḥarṭummîm,” in Sarah Israelit-Groll, ed., Pharaonic Egypt: the Bible, and Christianity (Jerusalem: Magnes Press, 1985), pp. 162-172, who also discusses the complex history of the term’s relation to the titleḥry-tp “chief.” It is possible that the Israelites did not consider the term ḥarṭummīm an Egyptian loanword any more than we today consider the word “magic” a loanword from Greek (or ultimately from Persian). Indeed, contrary to some interpreters, there is nothing foreign or pejorative about the term ḥarṭummīm in the Bible, even if it does appear in polemical contexts. Note, for example, that the ḥarṭummīm who battle Moses in Exod 7:11, and whom translators usually render as “magicians” or “dream interpreters” (e.g., Gen 41:8), are explicitly qualified as being “Egyptian,” suggesting that the word ḥarṭummīm by itself does not distinguish foreignness. Similarly, a passage of later date in Dan 4:6 gives Daniel the Aramaic title rab ḥarṭumayyāʾ, “chief of the ḥarṭummīm.” It is difficult to think that the biblical text would attribute to Daniel such a title if it denoted foreignness or illicitness.

  6. See Robert Kriech Ritner, The Mechanics of Ancient Egyptian Magical Practice (Studies in Ancient Oriental Civilization, 54; Chicago, IL: Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago, 1993); Geraldine Pinch, Magic in Ancient Egypt (Austin, TX: University of Texas Press, 1995).

  7. See David Frankfurter, “Ritual Expertise in Roman Egypt and the Problem of the Category ‘Magician,’” in Peter Schäfer and Hans G. Kippenberg, eds., Envisioning Magic: A Princeton Seminar and Symposium (Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1997), pp. 115-135.

  8. The Septuagint twice translates ḥarṭummīm with ἐξηγητής “interpreter of oracles, dreams, omens” (Gen 41:8, 41:24). Elsewhere it employs ἐπαοίδός “enchanter” (e.g., Exod 7:11, 7:22, 8:18, 8:19, Dan 1:20, 2:2, 2:27, 4:4, 4:6, 5:11). In Dan 1:20, we find σοφιστής “expert of diviners,” and in Dan 2:10, we read σοφός “learned, wise.” Only in Exod 9:11 does it translate with φάρμακος “sorcerer” (but in Exod 7:11 it is used to translate mekašpīm [i.e., מְכַשְּׁפִים], the usual word for “sorcerers,” itself likely a loanword from Akkadian). As Ritner, The Mechanics of Ancient Egyptian Magical Practice, pp. 14-15, points out, later Coptic scribes used forms of the word ḥeka to translate φάρμακος in Deut 8:10, ἐπαοίδός in Dan 4:4, and μαγεία in Acts 8:9. Of course, these represent early Christian views. On the early Jewish view of Egypt as a den of sorcery, see b. Qiddushin 49b.

  9. Because of his knowledge of sacred lore, only the lector-priest could serve in temples and officiate in ceremonies for the dead. Some appear to have served the village community as well, composing spells and making medicines. See Serge Sauneron, The Priests of Ancient Egypt. David Lorton transl. (Ithaca, NY/London: Cornell University, 2000), pp. 61-64, 108, 158, 163-164. For a collection of learned spells, see J. F. Burghouts, Ancient Egyptian Magical Texts (Nisaba, 9; E. J. Leiden: Brill, 1978). On the duties of the lector-priest, see Emily Teeter, Religion and Ritual in Ancient Egypt (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2011), pp. 16-38.

  10. The reader can look elsewhere for more complete treatments. See Scott B. Noegel, “Moses and Magic: Notes on the Book of Exodus,” Journal of the Ancient Near Eastern Society 24 (1996), pp. 45-59; Currid, Ancient Egypt and the Old Testament, pp. 83-120; Rendsburg, “Moses the Magician,” in Israel’s Exodus in Transdisciplinary Perspective.

  11. The text does not explain how they were able to do so when apparently there was no water left to transform. Yahweh already had bloodied the Nile, its streams, canals, ponds, reservoirs, and even the water contained in vessels (Exod 7:19-21).

  12. P. Leiden 344, Recto: ỉw ms ỉtrw m snfw swrỉ tw ỉm=f nyw tw m rmṯ ỉb tw mw… pḏtyw rwt ỉỉt=tỉ n kmt. The word for “foreign tribes” (pḏtyw, lit. bowmen) often refers to the Semitic peoples of southern Canaan. For an English translation, see Nili Shupak, “The Admonitions of an Egyptian Sage: The Admonitions of Ipuwer,” in William W. Hallo and K. Lawson Younger, Jr., eds., The Context of Scripture: Canonical Compositions, Monumental Inscriptions and Archival Documents from the Biblical World. Vol. 1 (Leiden: Brill, 2003), pp. 93-98.

  13. There is another possible analogue, though it is not as exact and rather late. The Tale of Setne II (BM P. 604) relates how a Nubian expert of ḥeka told his mother that her drinking water (and the sky) would turn to the color of blood if the Egyptians defeated him while performing sorcery. The extant text dates to the 7th year of Claudius (46-47 CE).

  14. ỉmỉdỉ ḥʿ pỉ ỉr [dšr]. See Jürgen Osing, Hieratische Papyri aus Tebtunis I (Carsten Niebuhr Institute of Ancient Near Eastern Studies, 17; Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum Press, 1998), p. 253.

  15. Thomas Schneider, “Modern Scholarship Versus the Demon of Passover: An Outlook on Exodus Research and Egyptology through the Lens of Exodus 12,” in Israel’s Exodus in Transdisciplinary Perspective, pp. 537-553, see p. 546, n. 32.

  16. The text is found with some variation in the tombs of Tutankhamun (on a shrine), Seti I, Ramesses II, III, VI, on a wall fragment at the Musée Lapidaire in Avignon, and on two hieratic papyri from the Egyptian Museum of Turin. See Erik Hornung, Der ägyptische Mythos von der Himmelskuh: Eine Ätiologie des Unvollkommenen. 2nd edition (Orbis Biblicus et Orientalis, 46; Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1991). For an English translation of the relevant portion of the text, see Miriam Lichtheim, “The Destruction of Mankind,” in The Context of Scripture, pp. 36-37.

  17. P. Westcar = P. Berlin 3033. For an English translation, see Miriam Lichtheim, Ancient Egyptian Literature. Vol. 1 (Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 1973), pp. 215-222.

  18. The Hebrew employs the verb השׁליך (hašlīk) “cast down.” Egyptian phrase is sḫr m “cast down.” See Ritner, The Mechanics of Ancient Egyptian Magical Practice, p. 48, n 232.

  19. Unlike with Aaron, in an earlier story, when Yahweh gives Moses miraculous signs he can use to convince the Israelites that Yahweh sent him, Moses’ staff turns into a נחש not a תנין, see Exodus 4:3, 7:15. It is fitting that the biblical author chose a term with cosmological import when confronting the Egyptian magicians before Pharaoh.

  20. In Egyptian belief, disruptions in the Nile’s flooding and color represented a lack of royal attention to Maat (mꜣʿt), the goddess and force of truth and equilibrium who/that guaranteed the movement of the sun and stars, the flow of the Nile, social harmony, and the stability of the dynasty. See Douglas J. Brewer and Emily Teeter, Egypt and the Egyptians(Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999), p. 86.

  21. See A. Egberts, In Quest for Meaning: A Study of the Ancient Egyptian Rites of Consecrating the Meret-Chests and Driving the Calves. Vols. 1-2 (Egyptologische Uitgaven 8:1-2; Leiden: Nederlands Instituut voor het Nabije Oosten, 1995), p. 285. The ritual text makes specific reference to the breaking of the serpent staff. An inscription accompanying one of these scenes at Karnak identifies the king’s use of the serpent staff with driving the grain-eating worms out of the harvest:

    mds=n=ỉ dm ws wꜣḥtỉt wp=ỉ sw m gs.wy ḫfʿ=n=ỉ tp=f m wnmy ỉkn[=ỉ] sd=f ḥnʿ swš I cut up the binder-snake/worm, which destroys the grain, I split it in two. I grasp its head in my right
    hand, I grip its tail (in my left)
    together with the ropes.
  22. Since artisans, and not priests, produced these items, one might gather that they were not perceived as possessing performative powers unless handled by experts in ḥeka. On the other hand, as the stela of the chief artist Iritisen makes clear (ca. 2000 BCE, Louvre Museum C 14), the making of artistic items such as amulets, statues, and wall reliefs was regarded a secret knowledge that required knowledge of ḥeka.

  23. ḥfꜣ m ʿ=ỉ n (p)sḥ wỉ. See Adriaan de Buck, eds., The Egyptian Coffin Texts. VII. Texts of Spells 787-1185 (Oriental Institute Publications, 87; Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1961), p. 97. For an English translation of the texts, see Raymond O. Faulkner, The Ancient Egyptian Coffin Texts (Oxford: Aris & Philips, 2015).

  24. Currid, Ancient Egypt and the Old Testament, p. 95.

  25. See already E. W. Hengstenberg, Egypt and the Book of Moses (Edinburgh: Thomas Clark, 1845), pp. 98-99.

  26. wnỉs pỉ wnm rmṯ ʿnḫ m nṯrw… wnỉs pỉ wnm ḥkꜣ=sn ỉʿm ꜣḫw=sn. See James P. Allen, A New Concordance of the Pyramid Texts. Vol. III PT 247-421 (Brown University, 2013), §23, §33. For an English translation of the texts, see James P. Allen, The Ancient Egyptian Pyramid Texts (Writings from the Ancient World, 38; Atlanta, GA: SBL Press, 2015).

  27. ʿm=n=ỉ ỉʿrt 7 (spell 612) and ỉw wnm=n=ỉ mꜣʿt ỉw wnm=n=ỉ ḥkꜣ (spell 1017). See Adriaan de Buck, ed., The Egyptian Coffin Texts. VI. Texts of Spells 472-786 (Oriental Institute Publications, 81; Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press, 1956), p. 225k; de Buck, ed., The Egyptian Coffin Texts. VI. Texts of Spells 787-1185, p. 238d-e.

  28. ꜣwỉ tw grt r nw ḥkꜣ.w rḫw rw=sn mk ḥkꜣ ỉm ḏs=f mk ỉr ʿm sw mk w(ỉ). Here the Egyptian word ʿm means both “swallow” and “know.” Hornung, Der ägyptische Mythos von der Himmelskuh, p. 20.

  29. Note that the Reed Sea “swallows” the Egyptians in Exod 15:12.

  30. Ritner, The Mechanics of Ancient Egyptian Magical Practice, p. 128, n. 583.

  31. See also Hoffmeier, “The Arm of God Versus the Arm of Pharaoh in the Exodus Narrative.”

  32. Yahuda, The Languages of the Pentateuch in Its Relation to Egyptian, pp. 66-67. The Hebrew expression appears elsewhere only in reference to Yahweh inscribing the tablets of the law (Exod 31:18, Deut 9:10). Of course, chief Egyptian lector-priests also were master scribes, and Thoth was the patron god of scribes. I thank my graduate student, Corinna Nichols, for drawing my attention also to Luke 11:20, in which Jesus uses the same expression (i.e., δακτύλῳ θεοῦ) for exorcising demons.

  33. Ritner, The Mechanics of Ancient Egyptian Magical Practice, pp. 225-231.

  34. On the Song of the Sea and execration motifs, see Noegel, “Moses and Magic,” pp. 55-57.

  35. The lector-priests also bore the title ḥri sšt3 “Keeper of Secrets.” An inscription in the mastaba of the lector-priest Khentika (ca. 2300 BCE) records:

    [s]štꜣ n mdw nṯr n ḥmt ẖrỉ-ḥbt ỉnk… [sš]tꜣ nb r=(ỉ) m sš nb n pr mḏꜣt nṯr ỉnk ḥrỉ sštꜣ… gr rḫ=k(wỉ) iḫt nb rḫ ꜣḫ nb ỉḳr ḫpp… ʿꜣ nb ỉmn(t) ỉw gr rḫ=k(wỉ) wꜣt nb… [ib]s=k(wỉ) ḥr sštꜣ nb n pr mḏꜣt nṯr ntỉ snw The secrets of the god’s words of the craft of the lector-priest. [There is nothing] kept secret from me in the writings of the house of the god’s books as I am Keeper of Secrets… I know everything that an excellent akh-spirit knows, who journeys to the West… the Great [God], lord of the West. Now I know every way… I am initiated into all the secrets of the god’s books of the palace (ll. 5-9).

    See T. G. H. James, The Mastaba of Khentika Called Ikhekhi (London: Egypt Exploration Society, 1953), pp. 36-37.

  36. See Noegel, “Moses and Magic”; Schneider, “Modern Scholarship Versus the Demon of Passover,” in Israel’s Exodus in Transdisciplinary Perspective, p. 544.

  37. The aforementioned stories in P. Westcar demonstrate this well. Written during the Middle Kingdom, they report fictitious events that took place during the reign of a pharaoh who ruled more than 500 years earlier. Thus, the text legitimizes the ritual professionals of the Middle Kingdom by lending them a distinguished and long-lived pedigree steeped in rituals of extraordinary performative power.

  38. On this view, see Richard Elliott Friedman, (“The Historical Exodus,” TheTorah.com(2015). Though some characterize this group as non-Israelites living in Egypt, as opposed to Egyptians, Egyptian identity was not based on ethnicity, but was attributed to anyone who could speak the language and participate in ordinary Egyptian life. A group of non-Israelites living in Egypt, who possessed the sort of close knowledge of Egyptian ritual and literary texts discussed herein, likely would have been indistinguishable from native Egyptians other than through their bilingualism and possibly their attire.

  39. See Scott B. Noegel, “The Egyptian Origin of the Ark of the Covenant,” in Israel’s Exodus in Transdisciplinary Perspective, pp. 223-242.

  40. On other reconstructions, see by Mark Leuchter, “Who Were The Levites,”TheTorah.com (2017), who opines that the etymology of the name Levite, derives from the root ל–ו–ה “connect, attach,” thus bespeaking their “attachment” to local Israelite cult centers. Elsewhere, I have suggested that the names Levite and Leviathan derive from the same root ל–ו–ה, but meaning “twist, undulate”), and that the connection has its roots in the Egyptian cultic practice of paralyzing the serpent of chaos. Thus, the early Levites were handlers of Leviathan. See Noegel, “The Egyptian Origin of the Ark of the Covenant,” in Israel’s Exodus in Transdisciplinary Perspective, p. 238, n. 76. Might we also consider the possibility of deriving the name Levite from the Egyptian root ꜣwỉ = “handle, outstretch (the hand or arm)”? Cf. Exod 7:19, 8:1-2, 8:12-13, 9:22-23, 10:12-13, 10:21-22, 14:16, 14:21, 14:26-27, 15:12.