Vision of Judah Maccabee (adapted), Julius Schnorr von Carolsfeld. Pitts Theology Library
The Hasmoneans Usurped the High Priesthood from the Oniads
The family of Onias long controlled the high priesthood before the persecution of Antiochus IV and the Hasmoneans’ (“Maccabees’”) rebellion. When the dust settled, the Hasmoneans found themselves in charge of the priesthood and the Oniads had relocated to Egypt. 1 Maccabees, a pro-Hasmonean work, defends the legitimacy of the Hasmonean accession to the high priesthood, and the fact that it went to the family of Judah Maccabee’s brother, Simon.
Published: December 6, 2023
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Translations of 1 Maccabees come from Daniel R. Schwartz, 1 Maccabees: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, Anchor Yale Bible 41b (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2022). “John” is the English version of “Yoḥanan,” with the usual transformation of Y into J and ḥ into h.
If today we would expect a nickname that builds on its first syllable, “Yoḥi,” this ancient nickname for Yoḥanan built, instead, on the consonants in its second and third syllable.
In rabbinic literature, he is known as Yoḥanan the High Priest.
According to the Seleucid era, i.e., 140 B.C.E.
The meaning of this term, which states where the assembly took place, is not clear.
Editor’s note: For a discussion of Simon’s accession, which is dated by 1 Macc 13:41–42 to the year 170 of the Seleucid era, see Rotem Avneri Meir, “The Hasmonean Calendar Begins with the Rule of Simon the High Priest, 142 B.C.E.,” TheTorah (2023).
Indeed, if their dynastic history is any indication, the Hasmoneans claimed nothing about their immediate ancestors.
Editor’s note: For more on this book, see Michael L. Satlow, “The Wisdom of Ben Sira: How Jewish?” TheTorah (2015).
This is echoed in Ch. 51. Editor’s note: For a discussion of this section of Ben Sira, see Dalia Marx, “Mareh Kohen: Ben Sira’s Description of Simon the High Priest,” TheTorah (2021).
See esp. Meron Piotrkowski, Priests in Exile: The History of the Temple of Onias and Its Community in the Hellenistic Period (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2019).
See m. Menachot 13:10; t. Menachot 13:3, 12–14; b. Megillah 10a; b. Abodah Zarah 52b; b. Menachot 109a–b.
Editor’s note: The date 164 B.C.E. refers to the story of how Judah reclaimed the Temple and cleansed it, which forms the basis of the story of Chanukah. For the argument that this is not a historical occurrence, and that Judah only reclaimed control the Temple for the Judeans three years later (161 B.C.E.) on Yom Nicanor, see Zev Farber, “Chanukah: Not Judah Maccabee’s Holiday,” TheTorah (2022).
It lasted even down to the early seventies of the first century C.E. (Josephus, War 7.420–435).
A lack of an entitling pedigree was a problem in the ancient world, including the ancient Judean world, which treated status and positions of authority, including monarchy and priesthood, as the prerogatives of certain dynasties. In this world, Hellenistic kings descended from the founders of Hellenistic kingdoms and Jewish kings—in the heroic past and the hoped-for future—were Davidides.
A suggestive parallel to the Oniad anti-Hasmonean polemic is how Jewish opponents of Herod, the king who supplanted the Hasmoneans, never tired of pointing to his Idumean descent, which meant he was only a “half-Jew” (Josephus, Ant. 14.403). This criticism brought Herod to fabricate a pure Jewish ancestry for himself, as Josephus complains (Ant. 14.8–9). 1 Maccabees’ effort to present its heroes as sons of Phinehas (see below) can be understood as their version of the same tactic. Editor’s note: For more on Herod and his Jewishness, see Evie Gassner, “How Jewish Was Herod?” TheTorah (2019); Jeffrey Rubenstein, “Herod’s Renovation of the Temple – The Talmudic Version,” TheGemara (2017).
The Hebrew text can be found on bensira.org.
Editor’s note: For more on the sons of Zadok and their place in the priesthood, see Mark Leuchter, “How All Kohanim Became Sons of Aaron,” TheTorah (2019); Ely Levine, “The Historical Circumstances that Inspired the Korah Narrative,” TheTorah (2015).
On Damascus Document 3:18–4:19, where language from 1 Sam 2 (on Eli’s wicked sons) is used to explain Ezek 44:15 (on the sons of Zadok who would replace them), see Daniel R. Schwartz, “‘To Join Oneself to the House of Judah’ (Damascus Document IV,11),” Revue de Qumran 10 (1979–1981): 435–446. In general, on the Dead Sea Scrolls on the Hasmoneans, see Hanan Eshel, The Dead Sea Scrolls and the Hasmonean State, trans. David Louvish and Aryeh Amihay, Studies in the Dead Sea Scrolls and Related Literature [SDSS] (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2008); trans. of מגילות קומראן והמדינה החשמונאית (Jerusalem: Yad Ben-Zvi, 2004).
For the basic difference between 1 Maccabees and 2 Maccabees, see Daniel R. Schwartz, “Judea versus Judaism: Between 1 and 2 Maccabees,” TheTorah (2021).
It states:
2 Macc 4:7 When Seleucus passed away and the kingdom was taken over by Antiochus surnamed Epiphanes, Onias’ brother Jason corruptly usurped the high-priesthood 4:8 by promising the king, in a petition, 360 talents as well as another 80 talents of other revenue.
Translations come from Daniel R. Schwartz, 2 Maccabees, Commentaries on Early Jewish Literature [CEJL] (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2008).
It states:
2 Macc 4:23 In the third year thereafter Jason sent Menelaus, the brother of the aforementioned Simon, to bring the money to the king and to take care of memoranda concerning pressing governmental matters. 4:24 But he, upon being presented to the king and evincing respect for him in the manner of a person of authority, shifted the high priesthood to himself by outbidding Jason by 300 talents of silver.
As is recorded by Josephus at Ant. 12.138–146 and by 2 Macc 3:1–3.
Editor’s note: For discussion of how 1 Maccabees uses the Phinehas theme, see Katell Berthelot, “The Maccabean Victory Explained: Between 1 and 2 Maccabees,” TheTorah (2022).
In his discussion of Phinehas, Ben-Sira (43:24) underlined all of those elements, demonstrating that what made Phinehas worthy to inherit the priesthood was alive and well in the second century B.C.E., only a few years before the Maccabean revolt.
It begins:
1 Macc 14:29 Whereas when wars frequently occurred in the country, Simon, son of Mattathias, a son of the sons of Jehoiarib, and his brothers, undertook the danger upon themselves and stood up against the opponents of our people, so that their Temple and the Law were put on a firm footing, and they glorified our people with great glory…