Man Who Blasphemes God's Name Is Stoned, Abraham de Blois, after Gerard Hoet (I), ca. 1720-1728 (adapted). Rijksmuseum.nl
The Import of Lex Talionis in the Story of the Blasphemer
Published: May 19, 2019
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
This juridical principle appears in three different legal collections contained within the Torah: the Covenant Collection of Exodus 20:19-23:33 (talion is found in Exod 21:23-25); the Deuteronomic Law Collection of Deuteronomy 12-26 (talion in Deut 19:19-21); and the Holiness Collection of Leviticus 17-26 (talion in Lev 24:19-21).
Exod 21:26, however, states that if a man injures a slave’s eye, tooth, or bone, he has to set that slave free.
The point of this story seems to be summarized in Lev 10:10, in which God tells Aaron that the task of the priest is to distinguish between the holy and the secular, between the impure and the pure. By burning incense that had not been commanded, Aaron’s sons had somehow blurred the lines and polluted the holy.
For another approach to the problem of the connection of the lex talionis to the story of the blasphemer, see Serge Frolov,“The Embarrassing Case of the Blasphemer,” TheTorah (2014).
[5] For more on this see, Ed Greenstein, “An Inner-Biblical Elaboration of the Decalogue,” TheTorah (2016), and Uzi Weingarten, “Not Signing Off on Sacrifices,” TheTorah (2015).
[6] See Jonathan Klawans, “Concepts of Purity in the Bible” in The Jewish Study Bible, 2nd ed., (eds. Adele Berlin and Marc Zvi Brettler; Oxford University Press, 2014), 2041-2047.
Lev 19 likewise begins with an address to all the bnei Yisrael and lists a variety of laws. Toward the end of these laws, we read: “When a stranger who resides with you shall be to you as one of your citizens, you shall love him as yourself, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt” (Lev 19:33-34). While there is no indication at the end of this chapter’s laws that non-Israelites are obligated to follow the laws in Lev 19, the text explicitly admonishes Israelites to treat strangers as citizens at least in a positive way, leaving unclear the question of whether non-Israelites are bound to the other laws here. By analogy with the previous sections of the HC, a general obligation for non-Israelites living on the land to follow Israelite law might be inferred, although it is not clearly stated. In Lev 20, strangers are included in the law against passing one’s children to Molech.
The text points out explicitly that his Israelite lineage is through his mother in a time when Israelite status was determined patrilineally; even this marginal amount of Israelite-hood meant that the blasphemer was of equal status before the law.
HC does not refer to enslaved Israelites as slaves, and requires their redemption. See Marvin Sweeney, “The Bible’s Evolving Effort to Humanize Debt-Slavery,” TheTorah (2016), as well as Zev Farber, “The Law of the Hebrew Slave: Exodus, Leviticus, and Deuteronomy,” TheTorah (2015).
Baruch Schwartz notes (The Jewish Study Bible 2nd ed, commentary on Lev 16:29-34a), p. 234 that that the ger is neither required to worship Israel’s God, nor to observe the performative commandments; however, he must comply with all prohibitions.