The Religious Value of Biblical Criticism: My Modern Orthodox Journey

I went from dismissing biblical criticism to embracing its truth, and having to rebuild my religious identity. Five aspects of my religious life have been profoundly enhanced.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Religious Value of Biblical Criticism: My Modern Orthodox Journey." TheTorah.com, February 13, 2023. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-religious-value-of-biblical-criticism-my-modern-orthodox-journey.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Religious Value of Biblical Criticism: My Modern Orthodox Journey" (2023, February 13). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-religious-value-of-biblical-criticism-my-modern-orthodox-journey

The Religious Value of Biblical Criticism: My Modern Orthodox Journey

Studying Talmud and Jewish law ©

Categories:

Modern Faith

Published: February 13, 2023

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. I would like to thank the many friends, rabbis, teachers, and scholars who have helped me navigate this journey. In particular, I am profoundly indebted to Professor Baruch Schwartz, who has been there for me, from the beginning until today, as a patient and dedicated teacher, guide, and intellectual/spiritual mentor in charting a course forward. Many of the ideas herein are the direct or indirect product of countless hours and conversations we have shared (though I take sole responsibility for any errors or imprecise formulations). I thank you for your teaching and for your friendship.

  2. Editor’s note: For some discussions of the 8th principle, see Samuel Fleischacker, “Making Sense of the Revelation at Sinai - Revisiting Maimonides’ Eighth Principle of Faith,” TheTorah (2014); David Bigman, “I Shall Fear God Alone and Not Show Favor in Torah” TheTorah (2014); Haim Kreisel, “Were Maimonides and Some of His Followers Orthoprax?” TheTorah (2017); Charles Manekin, “Is the Divine Origin of the Torah Really Incompatible with Maimonides’ Philosophical Principles?” TheTorah (2019).

  3. See Tamar Ross, “Orthodox Solutions Thus Far,” in the series “Orthodoxy and the Challenge of Biblical Criticism,” TheTorah (2014).

  4. I am not speaking of the question of the divine role, whatever it might be, in the process of composition—a question not subject to empirical evidence, and therefore ultimately in the realm of religion and faith (more on that later). I speak now of the actual text that we have in our hands, which like any other text or physical object in existence, is indeed subject to empirical analysis.

  5. Editor’s note: For similar sentiments, see Irving (Yitz) Greenberg, “Meeting the Challenge of Critical Scholarship with Leviticus,” TheTorah (2016); Isaac S.D. Sassoon, “Source Criticism Enhances Our Acceptance of the Torah,” TheTorah (2018).  

  6. The Hebrew text follows the Sheilat edition.

  7. Editor’s note: For discussion of the moral issues with Torah legislation, see Nathan Lopes Cardozo, “The Deliberately Flawed Divine Torah” TheTorah (2016); Norman Solomon, “Relating Truthfully to Morally Problematic Torah Texts,” TheTorah (2017); Zev Farber, “Can the Torah Be a Moral Authority in Modern Times?” TheTorah (2021); Eliezer Finkelman, “Can We Pass Moral Judgment on Torah?” TheTorah (2022).  

  8. Translation of these passages comes from, Aryeh Sklar, “‘Lovers of Humanity’: Rav Kook, Christianity, and the Ongoing Censorship of His Writings,” Kol Hamevaser (2015).   

  9. Editor’s note: For more on this point, see Jacob L. Wright, “The Origins of Torah Study,” TheTorah (2015).

  10. For some discussion of the phenomenology of traditional Torah study and the contrasts to academic study, see Samuel Heilman, “Lernen, Davenen, and Identifying Orthodox,” TheTorah (2018); Zev Farber, “Traditional Torah Study versus Scientific Analysis,” TheTorah (2018).

  11. For a nice presentation of this idea, see Benjamin Sommer, Revelation and Authority: Sinai in Jewish Scripture and Tradition, The Anchor Yale Bible Reference Library (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2015). See also the symposium on Sommer’s thesis, “The Revelation and Authority of a Participatory Torah,” TheTorah (2019).

  12. Maimonides explains this in his Guide (2:48):

    It is clear that everything produced must have an immediate cause which produced it; that cause again a cause, and so on, till the First Cause, viz., the will and decree of God is reached. The prophets therefore omit sometimes the intermediate causes, and ascribe the production of an individual thing directly to God, saying that God has made it….As regards the immediate causes of things produced, it makes no difference whether these causes consist in substances, physical properties, freewill, or chance--by freewill I mean that of man--or even in the will of another living being. The prophets [omit them and] ascribe the production directly to God and use such phrases as, God has done it, commanded it, or said it: in all such cases the verbs “to say,” “to speak,” “to command,” “to call,” and “to send” are employed.

    Thus, when prophets assert that their message is divinely “commanded” - it is in the sense that they trace their perceptions back to the First Cause. See also Baruch J. Schwartz, “‘The LORD Spoke to Moses’—Does God Speak?” TheTorah (2014).   

  13. Editor’s note: For more on this, see Benjamin Sommer, “The Centrality of Law,” TheTorah (2014).

  14. Editor’s note: For a similar approach, see Zev Farber, “‘Torah Is from Heaven!’ What Do We Really Mean?” TheTorah (2019).