Memorial of Moses on Mount Nebo Siyagha. Steven Damron – Flickr
The Unknown Yet Known Place of Moses’ Burial
On a mountain, in a valley, no one knows – the three traditions about where Moses is buried in Deuteronomy 34 stem from three different sources.
Published: October 4, 2015
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
The same midrash appears in the Babylonian Talmud (Sotah 13b-14a):
ויקבר אותו בגיא בארץ מואב מול בית פעור – א”ר ברכיה: סימן בתוך סימן, ואפ”ה ולא ידע איש את קבורתו. וכבר שלחה מלכות הרשעה אצל תלמוד גסטרא של בית פעור: הראנו היכן משה קבור? עמדו למעלה נדמה להם למטה, למטה – נדמה להם למעלה, נחלקו לשתי כיתות, אותן שעומדים למעלה נדמה להן למטה, למטה – נדמה להן למעלה, לקיים מה שנאמר: ולא ידע איש את קבורתו.
h[3] He seems to imply that the Israelites called the place “The Valley” to avoid using a pagan god’s name.
B. MacDonald, “East of the Jordan” (Boston, 2000), 78.
For more on this inscription, see, here. For the complete text in Hebrew, see, here.
Alexander Rofé, “Moses’ Blessing, the Sanctuary at Nebo, and the Origin of the Levites,” in: Y. Avishur and J. Blau (eds.), Studies in Bible and the Ancient Near East: Presented to Samuel E. Lowenstamm on His Seventieth Birthday, pp. 409–424, Jerusalem 1978.
B. MacDonald, East of the Jordan, Boston 2000, pp. 137–138.
Biblical writers identified geographical elements either by their geographical name or by the name of the closest city. These names would be updated by later scribes as the toponyms changed over time. Thus, the name “Nebo” was added to an older layer of P, which used Abarim.
That entire section (27:15–23) mentions Elazar the priest multiple times, and the whole Israelite community (העדה), all of which is typical to P. For more on Elazar as typical to P and the Priestly nature of the appointment of Joshua text, see Zev Farber’s TABS essay, “Joshua is Appointed Leader Three Times: But is He in Charge?”
One glaring example is the reference to Sihon, which, as I discussed in a different TABS essay, is part of the E storyline, “War at Yahatz: The Torah versus the Mesha Stele.” In addition, Moses brings two reasons for the transfer of authority to Joshua in this speech.
- God told to him not to cross the Jordan (31:2b).
- His advanced age – 120 years (31:2a).
As D takes most of his historical data from J and E, and as the first reason comes from J, the other reason probably comes from E.
Joel S. Baden, The Promise to the Patriarchs (Oxford 2013), p. 101.
For a documentary analysis of these stories, see the TABS essay, “Unscrambling the Scout Story with the Documentary Hypothesis.”
As scholars have noted, D never uses P, and E has no Scouts Story; thus, the unfamiliar details in D’s retelling probably reflect missing pieces from the J story, that were cut by the compiler of the Torah.