Mahane Yehudah market in Jerusalem, Israel. 123rf
Tithes: Supporting the Priests vs. Sustaining the Poor
Using source criticism to disentangle a moral problem in the Torah
Published: June 17, 2015
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Am ha-aretz is a pejorative term that the haberim – a group of people distinguished by their commitment to meticulous observance of ritual purity and tithing –applied to those who were lax about ritual purity and tithing (see M. Demai 2:2-3).
Another discussion of tithes in the Torah, found at the end of Leviticus (27:30-33), is not discussed in the baraita about John Hyrcanus, so will be ignored here.
The reason for this interpretive leap is unclear and will have to be explored in a different essay.
See b. San. 83a; b. Yev. 86a; j. Bik. 2:1; Sifra, Emor 6:9.
Rambam formulates the rabbinic understanding of the law clearly in his Yad (Mishneh Torah, Ma’akhaloth Asuroth 10:19):
והאוכל כזית מן הטבל קודם שיפריש ממנו תרומה גדולה ותרומת מעשר חייב מיתה בידי שמים שנאמר ולא יחללו את קדשי בני ישראל וגו’ והשיאו אותם עון אשמה.
Issura usually denotes ritual law as contrasted with civil law; the latter often designated mamona. However, to complicate matters, at b. Chul. 134a Rashi defines issura as ‘a transgression that incurs death’.
See also b. Chul. 134a. According to R. Shimon Szkop:
The principle that says: “regarding mamona err on the side of leniency” calls for explanation. Why go easier on theft than on other Torah prohibitions when we have a general rule that questions involving any Torah prohibition must be decided strictly? (Sha‘arei Yosher, sha‘ar [=section] 5:1).
B. Chul. 134a and Rashi ibid.; cf. b. Ket. 73b.
Although the Priestly legislation can be divided into two discrete sources, P and H, for the purposes of this essay, all Priestly legislation is being lumped together in comparison with the Deuteronomic legislation (D).
The Levites to whom a tithe is allocated at Num 18:21 are no longer the disenfranchised hierodules of the Deuteronomic age, but belong to a fraternity that serves in the Tent of Meeting.
For an analysis of how these verses function in H, and some speculation about why they were added again by the Holiness School into the rules about holiday sacrifices (Lev 23:22), see Uzi Weingarten, “Not Signing off on Sacrifices,” TheTorah (2015).