Taharat HaNiddah—Purification of a Menstruant. Image adapted from Unsplash.com.
The Purification of a Niddah: The Torah Requirement
Jewish law requires a menstruant woman to purify herself by immersing in water. A schematic look at Leviticus 15 actually implies this is not a Torah requirement.
Published: April 3, 2014
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
[1] The halakha technically mandates a seven-day niddah period from the onset of menses. Nevertheless, in practice, most observant women go much later, around 12 days after the onset of their periods. This is due to two 1700-year-old customs/enactments (takkanah de-Rabbi be-sadot and minhag benot Yisreal/minhag de-Rabbi Zeira), which conflate the rules of niddah (menstruation) with the rules of zivah (abnormal bloody discharges)—an explanation of which would take us too far afield.
I use the term “immerse in water” instead of mikvah when discussing the biblical text because, as pointed out by Hayah Katz, “Biblical Purification: Was it Immersion?” TheTorah (2014) and Yonatan Adler, “On the Origins of Tevilah (Ritual Immersion),” TheTorah (2017), mikvaot are a Second Temple period invention. See also, Yonatan
I thank my teacher and colleague Bill Gilders for reminding me of this point.
It remains unclear whether according to Qumran halakha women would immerse after zavah/niddah or not. Due to the fragmentary nature of the documents that discuss the question (4Q270, 4Q274), it is unclear whether the references to washing are to the niddah and zavah themselves (unlike Leviticus) or to people who come in contact with them or things they touched (like Leviticus). See discussion in Ian C. Werret, Ritual Purity in the Dead Sea Scrolls (Leiden: Brill, 2007), 54, 274. I thank my colleague Shani Tzoref for this reference.
The text of the Sifra is a little different, since it assumes that even the elders believed that she would be washing anyway. In the Sifra’s version, the difference between R. Akiva and the elders is not whether she washes but that the elders took this for granted and R. Akiva felt it needed to be proven from the text. In both versions, R. Akiva’s use of this phrase to ground the practice of immersion undermines the elders’ reading that it was meant to be “anti-makeup.”
‘והדוה בנדתה’ זקינים הראשונים היו אומרים: “תהא בנדתה – לא תכחול ולא תפקוס עד שתבוא במים,” עד שבא רבי עקיבא ולימד: “נכנס הדבר לידי איבה (והדוה) והוא מבקש לגרשה! הא מה אני מקיים ‘והדוה בנידתה’? תהא בנידתה עד שתבוא במים” (כתב יד רומי, אססמני 66, דף 335).
[6] R. Baruch Epstein is so bothered by this possibility that he creates a new midrash based on the use of the word taher and on viewing Na’aman’s immersion in the Jordan as paradigmatic (2 Kings 5:13-14). He argues that this must have been the way that the elders knew this halakha, since the alternative, that they did not believe that a niddah or zavah must immerse in a mikvah, did not bear consideration. See: Torah Temimah, Lev. 15:33, n. 139.
A number of important medieval halakhists, like R. Isaac of Dampierre (Tosafot,Yebamot 47b, s.v. “be-makom she-niddah tovelet”) and R. Moshe of Coucy (Semag, Prohibitions 111) believe this derasha to be the authoritative proof for a Torah requirement for a niddah or zavah to immerse in the mikvah.
When I first digested this text—I had seen it before when I read through Tractate Shabbat in “bekius seder” years before—and I understood what this text takes for granted, that the Torah never says a niddah must immerse, I was taken aback. It was my first year in rabbinical school, and I ran to get a Chumash to read over the chapter. Sure enough, it wasn’t there. At the time, I took the above referenced radical stance and believed that R. Akiva invented the whole thing. Now, a decade plus later, having studied the development of ritual as part of my Ph.D., I lean more toward the alternative possibility, that R. Akiva was working with and reinforcing and existing practice/interpretation.
This seems more intuitive than the suggestion of the Talmud, and one wonders why it took so long for someone to suggest it. I should point out that this would only lead to a requirement of washing/immersion, which is our practice, but not to a requirement of “living water” as a zav is required. Nevertheless, some rabbinic authorities did suggest the possibility that a zavah should require “living water” since her state is parallel to the male zav state. See discussion in Responsa of Rashi, 69.
See Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16, Anchor Bible 3 (Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1991), 935. For more discussion on this question, see Michael A Daise, “Ritual Density in Qumran Practice: Ablutions in the Serekh Ha-Yachad,” in New Perspectives on Old Texts: Proceedings of the Tenth Annual Symposium of the Orion Center for the study of the Dead Sea Scrolls and associated Literature, 9-11 January, 2005, ed. Esther Chazon and Betsy Halpern-Amuru with Ruth A. Clements (Leiden: Brill, 2010), 51-66. The paper is also available online here. For a more skeptical reaction to Milgrom’s argument, see: Jonathan David Lawrence, Washing in Water: Trajectories of Ritual Bathing in the Hebrew Bible and Second Temple Literature, (Society of Biblical Literature Academia Biblica, 2006), 100-101.
R. Bachya ben Asher, in his comment on Lev. 15:19, refers to this position as Geonic. Many of the commentaries on Mishneh Torah call this the position of the Sifra, but it does not appear in the Sifra and, as described earlier, the Sifra has a different midrash for this. See: R. Chaim Kanievsky’s comments on this halakha (Kiryat Melech on the Mishneh Torah,ad loc.), where he makes this point.
There is still a practice of tevillat keilim (immersing newly acquired pots and silverware) and many men go to the mikvah as a custom, whether in the morning before prayers (Chasidic practice) or once a year before Yom Kippur.