“Torah Is from Heaven!” What Do We Really Mean?

Statements that express our feelings are often confused with factual assertions.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"“Torah Is from Heaven!” What Do We Really Mean?." TheTorah.com, June 4, 2019. https://www.thetorah.com/article/torah-is-from-heaven-what-do-we-really-mean.

APA Style

Click to copy

"“Torah Is from Heaven!” What Do We Really Mean?" (2019, June 4). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/torah-is-from-heaven-what-do-we-really-mean

“Torah Is from Heaven!” What Do We Really Mean?

Rabbi Jay holds the Torah Credit Josh Evnin – Flickr

Categories:

Modern Faith

Published: June 4, 2019

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. I learned a lot from the many responses I received to my“Avraham Avinu is My Father” essay and even more from the subsequent essays written for TheTorah.com by other authors grappling with similar questions, all of which helped me refine my position, which I present in this new essay. I was also privileged to have been invited by Dr. R. Nathan Lopez Cardozo to present an early version of this essay as a talk for the David Cardozo Academy, and to have received feedback from the scholars who are fellows there.

  2. In contrast, the title a boxer carries as “champion of the world” makes the implicit—if tentative claim—that this boxer is, in fact, the greatest living boxer in the world and thus, is actually better than other boxers.

  3. Other interpretations are possible.

  4. A related question is whether classical Torah study is an attempt to discover truth or a ritual exercise in connecting to the text. For a discussion of yeshiva study versus academic study, see my, “Traditional Torah Study Versus Scientific Analysis,” TheTorah (2018).

  5. See discussion in Marc Brettler, "Basing Judaism on Truth: Does the Torah Lie?" TheTorah (2015).

  6. See my brief overview of this in Part 3 of my “Avraham Avinu is My Father,” TheTorah (2013).

  7. See discussion in Norman Solomon, “Relating Truthfully to Morally Problematic Texts,” TheTorah (2017); Nathan Lopez Cardozo, “The Deliberately Flawed Divine Torah,”TheTorah (2018). For treatments of some specific problems, see Zev Farber, “Marrying Your Daughter to Her Rapist,” TheTorah (2014); Isaac Sassoon, “Did Israel Celebrate Their Freedom While Owning Slaves?”TheTorah (2015); Athalya Brenner-Idan, “The Decalogue: Are Female Readers Included?” TheTorah (2016). See also“Violent Fantasies on the Rivers of Babylon: A Symposium on Psalm 137:9,” TheTorah (2016).

  8. For some similar approaches to what I outline below, see Eliezer Finkelman, “Torah From Heaven: A Question of Evidence or Loyalty?” TheTorah (2013); Jeremy Rosen,“Torah Mi-Sinai and Biblical Criticism: Rising to the Full Challenge,” TheTorah (2013); Tamar Ross, “Orthodoxy and the Challenge of Biblical Criticism,” TheTorah (2014); Norman Solomon, Torah from Heaven: The Reconstruction of Faith (Oxford: Littman, 2012).

  9. Marc Brettler has pointed out to me that a related term, relationship theology, was coined in 2012 in a blogpost titled“What Is Relationship Theology?” on a blog called Splat’s Musings. The difference is that this author is speaking about a direct relationship to God while I am speaking about a relationship to a religious tradition, which includes God, Torah, Israel, mitzvot, etc.

  10. I am using the term Torah from Heaven as opposed to Torah from Sinai, since the former is about revelation and the second, until modern times, referred to something else. See discussion in Yoseif Bloch, “Trusting in the Process of Torah Mi-Sinai,” TheTorah (2016).

  11. א”ר חנינא: גדול המצווה ועושה יותר ממי שאינו מצווה ועושה; b. Baba Kama 38a, 87a; b. Avodah Zarah 3a.

  12. A colleague who lives in a religious moshav (an Israeli collective settlement) once told me that whereas some limited violation of actual halakhot outside the moshav is generally tolerated and will not result in a person’s ouster, walking around without a kippah would inevitably end in the person’s being ostracized and pushed out of the moshav, even though wearing a kippah is not a mitzvah.

  13. Of course, other traditions can put forward the same claim. I do not dispute that, only, as I am not part of these religious traditions and do not connect to them personally, I do not see perpetuating these other traditions as my responsibility. One important reason for this is likely the accident of birth; I was born and raised an observant Jew and feel connected to this tradition. If I were born into a different tradition, it is almost certain my feelings would be different.

  14. A related question is whether these issues should be taught to children or hidden until a later age. I advocate the former, and discuss this in my, “Can Orthodox Education Survive Biblical Criticism?” TheTorah (2015).

  15. Admittedly, one can make the circular argument that moral laws are part of religiosity and thus, bad people are not religious. I have two objections to this. First, socially speaking, we related to people who keep ritual laws as religious. To say that a sex abuser is not religious because sex abuse is a sin feels like a cheap way out of the problem that religious people can behave badly. Second, some religious precepts are themselves bad. Technically, the Torah does not prohibit owning slaves or marrying minors, but I would argue that someone who does this is behaving badly.