Waheb in Suphah, the Forgotten “Town in the Stream”
Describing the Israelites crossing the Arnon Stream into Amorite territory, the Torah quotes the Book of YHWH’s Battles that speaks of “Waheb in Suphah,” a phrase that appears nowhere else in the Bible. Many creative explanations have been given, but based on a survey on the ground we can identify it as the “Town in the Stream,” an ancient biblical town whose name had long been forgotten.
Published: July 2, 2020
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
This paper is based on the latter half of my article: David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “'והב בסופה' ו'שבת ער': הערות למסלול מסע בני ישראל במואב” ['Waheb in Suphah' and 'The Settled Country of Ar': Comments on the Route of the Israelites in Moab], Cathedra 95 (2000): 7–24.
I am discussing here only the itinerary as it appears in E. For a division of the itineraries in this chapter into their respective sources and narrative strands (E, J, and P), see my, “Ironing Out Israel’s Itinerary through the Transjordan,” TheTorah (2015).
For more on this battle, see my “War at Yahatz: The Torah Versus the Mesha Stela,” TheTorah (2015).
To further emphasize the point that Israel did not take territory away from Moab, the text tells us how it was Sihon who took this territory away from Moab:
במדבר כא:כו כִּי חֶשְׁבּוֹן עִיר סִיחֹן מֶלֶךְ הָאֱמֹרִי הִוא וְהוּא נִלְחַם בְּמֶלֶךְ מוֹאָב הָרִאשׁוֹן וַיִּקַּח אֶת כָּל אַרְצוֹ מִיָּדוֹ עַד אַרְנֹן.
Num 21:26 Now Heshbon was the city of Sihon king of the Amorites, who had fought against a former king of Moab and taken all his land from him as far as the Arnon.
Some scholars have argued that Sihon and his Amorite kingdom are an entirely fictional creation, invented so that Israelites can claim that they did not conquer Moabite territory in the Transjordan, even if they did. See Rachel Havrelock, “Inventing the Mythic Amorite Kingdom of Sihon,” TheTorah (2015). Nevertheless, other scholars argue for the historicity of Sihon, though placing him later in time. See Israel Finkelstein and Thomas Römer, “North Israelite Memories of the Transjordan and the Mesha Inscription,” TheTorah (2018).
This is Ed Greenstein’s preferred rendering; it is classically translated as “the Book of the Wars of the Lord.” For a discussion of what this book may have been, see Ed Greenstein “What was the Book of the Wars of the Lord?” TheTorah.com (2017). In contrast to the Masoretic pointing, the Greek LXX and the Aramaic Targum Onkelos think that the word “YHWH’s Battles” is not the name of the book but part of the quote.
Some commentators suggest that our quote was cut from the poem of the bards (21:27–30). This is the assumption of Nahmanides and of Abarbanel (Num 21:13); Benjamin W. Bacon, The Triple Tradition of the Exodus: A Study of the Structure of the Later Pentateuchal Books (Hartford: Student Publishing Co., 1894), 211; Manfred Weippert, “The Israelite ‘Conquest’ and the Evidence from Transjordan,” in Symposia celebrating the seventy-fifth Anniversary of the founding of the American Schools of Oriental Reserch (1900-1975), ed., Frank Moore Cross (Cambridge: ASOR, 1979), 15-34 [p. 21]. Specifically, I would place it at the end of v. 28 and before v. 29, but this requires some revisions to make it work and is very speculative.
See: George B. Gray, Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Numbers, ICC (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1986; reprint of 1903), 286; Israel Ben-Shem, כיבוש עבר הירדן: עיון מקראי [The Conquest of Transjordan: A Biblical study] (Tel Aviv: Student Union of Tel Aviv University, 1972), 13, 58.
On the enclitic mem see: Horace D. Hummel, “Enclitic Mem in Early Northwest Semitic, especially Hebrew,” JBL 76 (1957): 85–107; Chaim Cohen, “The Enclitic-mem in Biblical Hebrew: Its Existence and Initial Discovery,” in Sefer Moshe – The Moshe Weinfeld Jubilee Volume, ed. Chaim Cohen, et al. (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 2004), 231‒260. See also the section titles “Enclitic mem in Hebrew and Ugaritic” in Gary Rendsburg, “Boaz Married Ruth at the Threshing Floor: A Grammatical Solution to Ruth 4:5,” TheTorah (2020).
For more on Ar, see my “‘Waheb in Suphah’ and ‘The Settled Country of Ar,’” 9–16.
As noted earlier, Onkelos understands the words מלחמות י־הוה as part of the quote, and thus translates: קְרָבִין עֲבַד יְיָ עַל יַמָּא דְּסוּף וּגְבוּרָן עַל נַחֲלֵי אַרְנוֹן “YHWH fought battles at the Sea of Rushes and did wonders at the Arnon streams.” The latter is a reference to the midrash we will look at shortly.
sicut fecit in mari Rubro sic faciet in torrentibus Arnon.
For his sicut fecit (as he did), it is possible that Jerome is somehow reading את והב as one word, reflecting a variation on the Aramaic reflexive form אתיהב meaning “to be given,” but this is a stretch.
The full comment reads:
והב—פי' יהב, וי"ו מתחלף ביו"ד. והב משמע כמו (תהלים נה:כג) "השלך על יי יהבך." וזהו שלל שכתיב שם (דברים ג:ד) שלא היתה קריה אשר לא לקחנו מאתם ששים עיר כל חבל ארגוב, והרבה כי האי גוונא שם.
Waheb—meaning yaheb, vav being exchangeable with yod. The meaning of waheb is like (Ps 55:23) “cast your burden (yaheb) on the LORD.” [In the context of the book of YHWH’s Battles] this refers to booty, for it says that (Deut 3:4) “there was not a town that we did not take from them: sixty towns, the whole district of Argob.”
בסופה—לשון סופה וסערה, ופי' בסופה לא צרנו זמן ארוך על הכרכים, כ[י] א[ם] במהרה כיבשנו ושללנו.
“Be-Suphah”—the language of whirlwind and storm, meaning, [we took it] in a whirlwind, we did not lay siege on the cities for a long time, but we conquered them quickly and plundered them.
See: Isaak Samson Lange, פירושי התורה לר' יהודה החסיד [The Commentaries on the Torah by Rabbi Judah HeChasid], (Jerusalem: Daf Chen, 1975), 184.
See: Duane L. Christensen, “Num 21:14–15 and the Book of Wars of Yahweh,” Catholic Bible Quarterly 36 (1974): 359-360 [p. 360].
Tur-Sinai follows the Greek LXX and the Aramaic Targum Onkelos in reading the words “YHWH’s Battles” as part of the quote and not the name of the book. See: Naphtali H. Tur-Sinai, “כלום היה ספר מלחמות ה' בידי כותבי התורה?” [Did the Authors of the Torah Have a Book of the Wars of YHWH?] Yediot 24 (1959–60), 144–148 [p. 148]; reprinted in, פשוטו של מקרא [The Simple Meaning of Scripture] (Jerusalem: Kiryat Sepher, 1967), 1.167–169. The LXX itself translates the phrase as “setting fire in Zoab” (τὴν Ζωοβ ἐφλόγισεν). Jacob Licht and John Wever both suggest that for Waheb the LXX’s Vorlage had זהב “gold,” though whether a reference to the metal or a place name (like Di-zahab) is unclear. For סופה, Licht suggests that LXX is somehow reading שריפה, but he puts a question mark after the suggestion. See Jacob Licht, פירוש על ספר במדבר [A Commentary on the Book of Numbers] (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1991), 2:228–229; John W. Wevers, Septuaginta III1, Numeri, (Gottingen 1982), 257.
The context of this baraita is as follows: Mishnah Berachot 9:1 says that a blessing must be recited when one sees a place where miracles were performed for Israel. The Babylonian Talmud then quotes a baraita (a tannaitic source not found in the Mishnah) which lists such places, including the spots where Israel crossed the Sea, the Jordan River, and the Arnon River. The Talmud then asks what miracle happened at the Arnon River, and answers by quoting the Waheb text:
מעברות נחלי ארנון מנלן דכתי' על כן יאמר בספר מלחמות יי את והב בסופה ואת הנחלים ארנון
“The crossing points of the Arnon Streams,” from where do we know [that a miracle happened here]? For it is written (Num 21:14): “Therefore the Book of the YHWH’s Battles speaks of: Waheb in Suphah and the Arnon streams.”
After this comes the baraita quoted above.
The MS actually says תשו but this is almost certainly just a phonetic misspelling of טשו, which is what appears in all other versions.
The MS reads נהורת, but “light” makes little sense in context and all other versions read נקירותא.
This is not the only midrashic reading of the verse in the Talmud. An alternative reading, in b. Kiddushin 30b, reads the text together with a creative translation of the name of the book, yielding the point that people who “from the book [of the Torah] fight the battles of LORD (אתאהב בסופה) will love each other in the end.”
On this trip, I did not search Wadi Sawaqa, with its soft limestone, that forms neither cliffs nor caves. The midrash quoted previously, which mentions tunnels dug into the rock, inspired me to look in a place with hard rock as opposed to soft limestone (which by a riverbed would be too soft to support a tunnel). In any event, I didn’t really expect to find any tunnels—and alas, I did not.
A detailed description of the Roman road appears in my “‘Waheb in Suphah’ and ‘The Settled Country of Ar,’” 17.
Other scholars in this group were Yoram Zafrir, Zev Meshel, Amos Kloner, Eli Raz and Gideon Peli.
See: David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “ויה לימס ערביקוס” [Via Limes Arabicus], Cathedra 98 (2001): 159.
Khirbet el-Mudayna/Medeineh (خربة المدينه) in Arabic just means “city ruins” and there are six of them in Jordan. To distinguish between them, archaeologists use a geographical marker, such as the name of the wadi it is near. See: J. Maxwell Miller, “Six Khirbet el-Medeinehs in the Region East of the Dead Sea,” BASOR 276 (1989): 25–28; Chaim Ben David, “אתרי 'מדינה' על יובלי הארנון—'מדיין שבצד מואב'?” [The Mudayna Sites in Moab—Do they Preserve the Name of Biblical Midian?] in בהר ובשפלה ובערבה (יהושע יב, ח): עיונים ומחקרים מוגשים לאדם זרטל בשנת שלשים לסקר הר מנשה [In the Hill-country, and in the Shephelah, and in the Arabah (Joshua 12,8), Studies and Researches Presented to Adam Zertal], ed. Shay Bar (Jerusalem: Ariel University Press, 2008), 78–88.
This refers to a geomorphological formation: a hill with two peaks and a lower area in between. From the side, it looks like a horse’s saddle.
See: Alois Musil, Arabia Petraea (Vienna: Akademie der Wissenschaften, 1907), 1.247, 328–330, 332; Félix-Marie Abel, Geographie de la Palestine (Paris: Lecoffre, 1933–1938), 2.351.
One text that problematizes this identification is the description of Joab’s census of Israel in 2 Samuel 24. In describing the beginning of the census in the Transjordan, it states:
שמואל ב כד:ה וַיַּעַבְרוּ אֶת הַיַּרְדֵּן וַיַּחֲנוּ בַעֲרוֹעֵר יְמִין הָעִיר אֲשֶׁר בְּתוֹךְ הַנַּחַל הַגָּד וְאֶל יַעְזֵר.
2 Sam 24:5 They crossed the Jordan and encamped at Aroer, south of the town which is in the middle of the Wadi of Gad, and to Jazer.
According to this, the Town in the Stream is north of Aroer and not east of it, and can be found not in the eastern tributary of the Arnon, Wadi es-Saide, but in its northeastern tributary, Wadi el-Walla. For this reason, other scholars have suggested identifying the town in the stream with Khirbet Iskander, which is in Wadi el-Walla, in the territory of Gad. Nevertheless, this verse is likely corrupt. The ending “to Jazer” implies they were travelling north from Aroer, but the only verb we have is “to camp.” In his commentary on Samuel, Henry Smith notes that camping makes little sense here, and points to the Lucianic recension of the LXX, which reads not ויחנו בערוער “and they camped in Aroer” but ויחלו מערוער, “and they began at Aroer” (καὶ ή̓̕ρξαντο ἀπὸ Αροήρ). In line with this, I would argue that ימין “south” is likely a corruption for ומן “and from” and suggest reconstructing the verse as follows:
שמואל ב כד:ה ויחלו בערוער ומן העיר אשר בתוך הנחל אל הגדי ואל יעזר.
2 Sam 24:5 And they began at Aroer, and from the town which is in the stream, towards the Gadites and Jazer.
This makes perfect sense, since they started at the two southern border towns and headed north. It also works well with the other mentions of this town surveyed above.
The identification of Khirbet Arair with Aroer and of Wadi el-Mujib with the biblical Arnon is accepted by all scholars. See: Gerald L. Mattingly, “Arnon,” in Anchor Bible Dictionary (New York: Doubleday, 1992), 1.399.
The King’s Highway pass is almost certainly where the Priestly Text envisions the Israelites crossing. In February 2018 I joined a group led by Chaim Ben David, walking ancient roads in Jordan. On our first hiking day we walked south on the King’s Highway, from Arair/Aroer through the pass and down to Khirbet el-Balua.
See the Jordanian topographical map in Dept. of Lands, Trans-Jordan, Sheet 6A Diban, Amman 1934. In other sources it is written صافي, with Ș. See: Musil, Arabia Petraea, 1.246; Abel, Geographie de la Palestine, Map X; John Lewis Burckhardt, Travels in Syria and the Holy Land (New York: AMS Press, 1983; repr. of: London: John Murray, 1822), 373.
I will further note that H. Tristram used a similar indication to suggest that Suphah should be identified with an area named el-Tzafi (صافي), next to the southeastern corner of the Dead Sea. See: Henry B. Tristram, The Land of Moab: Travels and Discoveries on the East Side of the Dead Sea and the Jordan (New York: Harper and Brothers, 1873), 65. Such an identification, however, separates Suphah from the Arnon and the route of the Israelites, and thus cannot be accepted.
According to this suggestion, the quote from the Book of YHWH’s Battles has a clear geographic logic: The sites are listed from north to south. First comes Waheb in Wadi Suphah. The site is next to the Arnon which runs adjacent to Waheb, on its south. Then we have the southern slope of Wadi el-Mujib, Wadi es-Saide, that is tilted to the settled area of Ar on its top and its baton serves as the border between Moab and the Amorite kingdom of Sihon. This goes against the view of Miller who claims that the verses have no geographical logic. See: J. Maxwell Miller, “The Israelite Journey through (around) Moab and Moabite Toponymy,” JBL 108 (1989): 577–595 [p. 585]. The direction of the description, from north to south is against the direction of the Israelite itinerary that goes the opposite direction. There is no way that verses 14–15 describe the Israeli itinerary. This goes against Graham Davies, who sees the quote as part of the Israeli itinerary. See, Graham I. Davies, “The Wilderness Itineraries and the Composition of the Pentateuch,” Vetus Testamentum, 33.1 (1983): 1–13 [7–8]. In fact, the order of the sites from north to south supports the possibility, mentioned in a note above, that this quote was once part of the bard’s song about Sihon’s conquest.
See: Ben David, “The Mudayna Sites,” p. 79.