Map of the Israelites' Journey, Dirk Janszoon van Santen, 1700. Rijksmuseum.nl
Wandering in the Wilderness: Deuteronomy’s Ideological Harmonization of J and E
Deuteronomy cannot accept that Israel, under YHWH’s command, had to bypass Seir because the Edomite king would not allow them to pass through (Numbers 20). Thus, Deuteronomy has Israel wandering aimlessly, skirting Seir in a southward march away from Canaan (E) while waiting for the exodus generation to die for the sin of the spies (J).
Published: July 20, 2023
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Moses himself is included in that punishment (v. 37) and Joshua is appointed to replace Moses as the leader that will lead the people to the land (v. 38). This appointment saves Joshua from the fate of the rest of his generation.
This is the meaning of this phrase in all Semite languages. Thus, all roads leading to Jerusalem were known as “the way of Jerusalem.” As roads lead in opposite directions, this clues the reader/listener into the direction of travel. Thus, a way from point A to point B was “the way of B” going one direction and “the way of A” going the opposite direction.
In this verse the Deuteronomic author interrupts the spies story with YHWH’s order, which will only be fulfilled only in 2:1.
Yam Suph here could be a reference either to the Al-Jafr Basin (“The Lake of Rushes”) on the eastern side of the Seir mountains, or to the Gulf of Aqaba (Yam Soph, “The Sea at the End”), to the south. For more explanation of these two toponyms, see David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “The Yam Suph in the Transjordan?” TheTorah (2017). A third biblical Yam Suph is the Egyptian one, which the E source has in the danger by the sea story in Exodus, but whether this is understood as the Bitter Lakes or the Gulf of Suez, this cannot be the referent here in Deuteronomy, as the Israelites are very far from Egypt.
The directions are actually to go west and then south. East in biblical Hebrew is קדם – forwards. To turn, in this verse, means to go westwards. This makes sense in D, which conflates Kadesh-barnea and Kadesh, with both terms referring the Ein Musa (near Petra) in southern Transjordan.
In the J source, Kadesh-barnea, where the Israelites are encamped for the spies story, is in the Wilderness of Paran, and refers to Ein el-Qudeirat in the Sinai Peninsula, southwest of the Negev. In E, Kadesh on the border of Edom, where the Israelites are encamped with the Edomites refuse them passage through Seir, is in the Wilderness of Zin, and refers to Ein Musa. In combining these stories, the Deuteronomist conflates the two toponyms, placing them both in Ein Musa, following E’s geography. A discussion of why and how Deuteronomy does this requires a separate treatment. For another example of D playing loosely with E’s geographic markers, see David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “Wadi Zered,” TheTorah (2021). For a discussion of Kadesh-barnea and Kadesh in the other sources, see David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “Solving the Problem of “Kadesh in the Wilderness of Paran,” TheTorah (2015); idem, “Locating Be’er-lahai-roi,” TheTorah (2014).
The version in Judges has a very brief account of this, saying merely וְלֹא שָׁמַע מֶלֶךְ אֱדוֹם “but the king of Edom would not consent.” The text here continues by saying that the same request and refusal took place in Moab, something which does not appear in Numbers. It is possible that Judges here relies on the fuller E text, which the compiler of the Pentateuch cut; alternately the author of Judges composed this idea, since it helps Jephthah score polemical points against the Ammonites (a brother tribe of the Moabites).
In its brief presentation, Judges does not include this second back and forth.
A snippet of this north-south journey preserved elsewhere in Deuteronomy (10:6–7), listing the itinerary stops until Yotbat in the Negev. See my, “Why Deuteronomy has an Account of Aaron's Death in the Wrong Place,” TheTorah (2015).
The inhabitants of Seir in Deuteronomy 2 are called “sons of Esau” instead of Edomites. Apparently, the Deuteronomic author no longer thought of the area of Seir as “Edom,” likely because of the Edomite migration from Transjordan to southern Cisjordan, which already began to take place in the Deuteronomist’s period. This process eventually led to the termination of Edom as a political entity, which Yigal Levin (“The Formation of Idumean Identity,” ARAM 27.1–2 [2015], 187–202 [187–188]) dates to 553/552 B.C.E.
The E narrative, as reflected in Num 20 and in the speech by Jephthah, is concerned with Edom. In the D narrative, this toponym is systematically replaced by “Seir.” The same phenomenon can be seen in Chronicles too. For instance, Amaziah strikes the Edomites in 2 Kings 14:7, and this becomes “the children of Seir” in 2 Chronicles 25:11.
This is only the most obvious difference between E and D’s account. Other differences are:
- Place of Origin – In Numbers and Judges the Israelites contact the Edomites from Kadesh, before the circumvention of its territory. While, in Deuteronomy, the circumvention comes before contacting the descendants of Esau that live in Seir. Yet, in D too, it comes after the long stay at Kadesh (1:46).
- Delegation – In Numbers Moses sends a delegation; in Deuteronomy no delegation is sent.
- King – Numbers and Judges mention the King of Edom; Deuteronomy references no such personage. Probably, as there was no king in mount Seir when Deuteronomy was written.
For another approach to the differences between the crossing Edom stories in Deuteronomy and Numbers, see David Glatt-Gilad, “Reimagining the Israelite Edomite Encounter,” TheTorah (2016).
See William A. Sumner, “Israel’s Encounters with Edom, Moab, Ammon, Sihon, and Og according to the Deuteronomist,” Vetus Testamentum 18 (1968): 216–228 [p. 221].
Indeed, the only reason Sihon can refuse in Deuteronomy is because YHWH wants him to, so that Israel can destroy him and take his land (Deut 2:30).
The story ends with the Israelites responding that they are now willing to enter the land, and a group of them try climbing the mountain and are struck and crushed by the Amalekite and the Canaanite who lives there.
See discussion in Joel S. Baden, J, E, and the Redaction of the Pentateuch, FAT 68 (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2009), 99–195.
D’s account differs in many details from its original; most notably, it cuts Jethro entirely out of the story. See Bernard Levinson, “The Founding of Israel’s Judicial System,” TheTorah (2021).
D relates the story in such detail that we can actually reconstruct missing parts of the J story from D’s retelling. See my, “Using Deuteronomy to Fill in the Lacunae of Numbers’ Spies Story” TheTorah (2016).
Note that in D, the Israelites get the order to turn (west) and march (1:40). They do not fulfill the order right away. First, they abode at Kadesh(-barnea) for "many days" (1:46). The many days appear again as the duration of skirting mount Seir (2:1b). It tells us that D counts the abode at as part of the duration of the march.
Instead, from the itinerary stops in Deuteronomy’s opening verse (which derive from J), we can deduce that Israel travels from Mount Sinai to Kadesh-barnea, then into Seir, where they settle opposite (west of) the Al-Jafr Basin (Suph) until the exodus generation dies out. Then they head north into Moabite Transjordan. For a reconstruction of J’s itinerary, using this verse, see my, “Where in the Transjordan Did Moses Deliver His Opening Address?” TheTorah (2018).
It is, in fact, so unusual that Menahem Haran, who was convinced that D only had E, tried to invent an E spy story as a source! See, Menahem Haran, האסופה המקראית: תהליכי הגיבוש עד סוף ימי בית שני ושינויי הצורה עד מוצאי ימי הביניים [The Biblical Collection: Its Consolidation to the End of the Second Temple Times and Changes of Form to the End of the Middle Ages] (Jerusalem: Bialik and Magnes, 2003) 2.197–198. Other scholars argued that Deuteronomy 1–3 must derive from a different Deuteronomic author than the rest of the book, and that unlike this latter author, this one had both J and E.
A good example of D’s attempt to fit J’s story into the E framework, is the trip through Ar-Moab. (For more on this toponym and region, see my, “Ar Moab,” TheTorah [2020].) According to E, the Israelites travelled on the Moabite Wilderness highway, on the eastern part of what E calls Ar, the province of eastern Moab. This part of Ar was scarcely inhabited; they are skirting Moab and avoiding the population (as E does with Edom). This point is emphasized in the abbreviated retelling of E in Judges:
שופטים יא:יח וַיֵּלֶךְ בַּמִּדְבָּר וַיָּסָב אֶת אֶרֶץ אֱדוֹם וְאֶת אֶרֶץ מוֹאָב וַיָּבֹא מִמִּזְרַח שֶׁמֶשׁ לְאֶרֶץ מוֹאָב וַיַּחֲנוּן בְּעֵבֶר אַרְנוֹן וְלֹא בָאוּ בִּגְבוּל מוֹאָב...
Judg 11:18 They traveled on through the wilderness, skirting the land of Edom and the land of Moab. They kept to the east of the land of Moab until they encamped on the other side of the Arnon; and they never entered Moabite territory….
Yet in D, we are told:
דברים ב:ח... וַנֵּפֶן וַנַּעֲבֹר דֶּרֶךְ מִדְבַּר מוֹאָב. ב:ט וַיֹּאמֶר יְ־הוָה אֵלַי אַל תָּצַר אֶת מוֹאָב וְאַל תִּתְגָּר בָּם מִלְחָמָה כִּי לֹא אֶתֵּן לְךָ מֵאַרְצוֹ יְרֻשָּׁה כִּי לִבְנֵי לוֹט נָתַתִּי אֶת עָר יְרֻשָּׁה.
Deut 2:8 …We marched on in the direction of the wilderness of Moab. 2:9 And YHWH said to me: “Do not harass the Moabites or provoke them to war. For I will not give you any of their land as a possession; I have assigned Ar as a possession to the descendants of Lot.”
This means they are walking through a population center. Similarly, as quoted above, Moses tells Sihon king of Heshbon that the Moabites (like the Esauites) sold food and water to Israel. Thus, in D, Israel is clearly travelling through Ar, where they would have encountered people. This is J’s itinerary, not E’s. Thus we have here a sleight of hand: D uses E’s terms, calling the land Ar (E’s term) instead of Hatzerot (J’s term), and stating that the Israelites travelled on the Wilderness Road. And yet, the “meat” of D’s story, that Israel encountered friendly Arites, is J’s conception of the trip, and one that makes sense only if they are taking a more western road, going through Ar.