Photosvit | Dreamstime ©
A Woman Who Seizes a Man’s Testicles During a Fight, Her Hand Is Cut Off
A wife who intervenes in a fight to save her husband by grabbing his opponent’s testicles is punished by having her hand cut off (Deut 25:11–12). What is the nature of her offense? Why isn’t her intent to save her husband a mitigating factor? What is the relationship between the punishment and the crime?
Published: August 27, 2020
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
The term אח (ach) often means “brother” or denotes some form of kinship relationship in biblical Hebrew, but the expression איש ואחיו (ish ve’achiv) is an idiomatic usage best translated as “one another.” See, e.g., Gen 13:11; Joel 2:8; and Zech 7:9, 10.
While the term איש (ish) generally denotes a man, in every case in the Hebrew Bible in which it appears with the feminine singular possessive, it refers to a woman’s husband. See, e.g., Gen 3:16; Lev 21:7; Num 5:13; Judg 13:6; 1 Sam 1:8; 2 Sam 3:16; and 2 Kgs 4:9.
The verb used to describe the woman’s action, חזק in the hiphʿil, can mean to take hold of, grasp, grab hold of, or seize. It does not necessarily imply physical harm through the act of grabbing or grasping, but it does seem to entail the use of a firm grip. For examples, see note 29.
Literally, “Your eye shall not [look with] pity.” This translation of these verses is my own. The NJPS translation reads, “If two men get into a fight with each other, and the wife of one comes up to save her husband from his antagonist and puts out her hand and seizes him by his genitals, you shall cut off her hand; show no pity.” All other quotes from the Hebrew Bible in this article are from the NJPS translation with adjustments.
The LXX translates τῶν διδύμων αὐτοῦ “his twins,” exchanging one euphemism for another, but the Samaritan Pentateuch reads בבשרו, “his flesh,” which changes the law entirely.
Often it has the sense of cutting off and cutting into pieces. In addition to the usages mentioned above, קצץ in the piel can mean “to cut” (thread in Exod 39:3; a cord in Ps 129:4); cut off (used in 2 Kgs 16:17; 18:16; and 24:13 in reference to items and decorations in the Temple made with precious metals being either cut off or trimmed or stripped of those precious metals); cut or break in half (Ps 46:10); and cut up or cut into pieces (2 Chron 28:24).
See Judg 1:6-7 (thumbs and big toes) and 2 Sam 4:12 (hands and feet).
It is also used for curved, bent, or hollowed objects, such as curved implements or utensils (Exod 25:29 and Num 7:86); the hollow or pocket of a sling (1 Sam 25:29); and the handle of a door bolt (Cant 5:5). Often כף is used in contexts related to placing something in someone’s hands (Exod 8:27, 28 and Num 5:18; 6:19), handfuls of something (Lev 9:17 and 1 Kgs 17:12), clapping hands together (Num 24:10; 2 Kgs 11:12; Ezek 6:11; and Ps 47:2), and grabbing or grasping something (Ezek 21:16 and Ezek 29:7, both with the verb תפש). It is also used a few times to refer to the sole (instep, which is the curved part) of the foot (usually expressed as כף רגל).
כף and יד are used together in the same verse as synonyms in Gen 40:11; Exod 4:4; Ezek 21:16; and Ps 18:1, and they are placed in poetic parallelism in Isa 62:3; Jer 15:21; Ps 71:4; Prov 10:4; and Prov 31:19, 20. In none of these cases does there appear to be any distinction between כף and יד in terms of meaning. Sandra Jacobs, The Body as Property: Physical Disfigurement in Biblical Law, LHBOTS 582 (Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2014), 165, 171–172, questions the translation of כף here as hand, pointing out that since כף often refers to the palm of the hand, perhaps that is the sense here, which would indicate a partial hand amputation (perhaps preserving the thumb). While this could be the case, this type of amputation is unattested in the ancient Near East. Given that כף and יד are commonly used as synonyms in the same verse or set of verses, the most likely meaning here for כף here is simply hand.
There have been a few other, quite creative, suggestions for the punishment that hinge on different translations of קצץ and כף. Lyle Eslinger, “The Case of an Immodest Lady Wrestler in Deuteronomy 25:11-12,” VT 31 (1981): 269-81, translates קצץ as “to cut off” and כף as a term for genitalia, based on what he claims are two other usages of כף for genitalia elsewhere: Gen 32:26, 33, where it refers to the scrotum, and Cant 5:5, where it (euphemistically) refers to the labia. Based on this translation, he suggests that the wife’s punishment is genital mutilation in the form of female circumcision. Jerome Walsh, “You Shall Cut Off Her ... Palm? A Re-Examination of Deuteronomy 25:11-12,” JSS 49.1 (2004): 47-58, proposes that קצץ in this context should be translated as to cut or shave (hair), and that כף refers to the general pelvic region (groin), and thus the woman’s punishment is public humiliation through shaving of her pubic area. Neither of these translation suggestions have gained a wide following. For an astute analysis and critique of both, see Sandra Jacobs, “Instrumental Talion in Deuteronomic Law,” ZABR 16 (2010): 263-278 [265-269].
The translation is from Martha T. Roth (ed.). Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor, SBLWAW 6 (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 2nd ed., 1997), 156-57, with slight adjustments. The ellipses indicate missing parts of the text. For a detailed discussion of what body part the final ellipses might have indicated, see Jacobs, “Instrumental Talion in Deuteronomic Law,” 272–274. Jacobs discusses all of the options that various scholars have suggested (eyes, breasts, nipples, fingers, thumbs) and concludes based on the available evidence that fingers or thumbs are the most likely option.
A case from a trial record in Nuzi dating to about the 15th century B.C.E. also involves a woman committing what might be a similar offense and also includes a punishment involving the cutting off of a finger. It concerns the wife of a slave who intervened in a fight to help one of the men involved (who may or may not be her husband), and she put her hand on the aḥu of one of the other men fighting and drew blood, apparently injuring him at least to some extent in that area. She is brought to court, and after testimony from four witnesses against her, she is found guilty after refusing to undergo the ordeal of the oath of the gods, and the judge decrees that a fine must be paid as compensation to the man she assaulted for his injury, and he also seeks the consent of her master to cut off her finger. It is not clear if the cutting off of her finger is an additional punishment, or if her master had the option of choosing between compensation and mutilation. How similar this case is to MAL A 8 and Deut 25:11-12 depends on the translation of aḥu, the term used to denote the body part that was injured. When aḥu is used to refer to a human body part, it generally denotes the arm, and occasionally the side of the body. Cyrus H. Gordon, “A New Akkadian Parallel to Det. 25:11-12,” JPOS 15 (1935): 29-34, asserts that the term can also be used as a euphemism for genitalia, and that this is how it is used here. However, the usage of aḥu as a euphemism for genitalia is not attested anywhere else, so it is difficult to accept Gordon’s reading. If aḥu here refers to the man’s arm, a body part where it would be easy to draw blood during a fight (in contrast to the genitalia), then it is a simple case of assault, and the punishment fits in well with the way assault is treated in the Middle Assyrian Laws, but it doesn’t shed light on Deut 25:11-12. It does, however, tell us that cutting off fingers was considered an appropriate punishment for assault of a woman against a man in some cases in the larger ancient Near Eastern cultural milieu, and it may indicate that in some cases people may have had the option of a choice between monetary compensation and mutilation, but it is difficult to tell, since in this case the judge may have been seeking to punish the woman with both. Gordon’s suggestion that aḥu could be a euphemism for “privates” is based heavily on Deut 25:11-12 and MAL A 8 (see n. 6 in Gordon’s notes on his translation, 32-33), and thus his logic is rather circular. On the range of usages of the term aḥu, see CAD, vol. A, part 1, 205-210.
The laws before and after MAL A 8 are also worth noting. The one before (MAL A 7) sentences a woman who hits a man to both a fine and a beating. Thus, there is something about women assaulting men that is being highlighted in both MAL A 7 and 8. The one after (MAL A 9) is a bit difficult to read in parts but seems to address a man who assaults a (possibly married) woman. If he lays a hand on her, he is punished with the loss of this finger. If he kisses her, one of his lips is cut off. Jacobs, “Instrumental Talion in Deuteronomic Law,” 271-275, identifies the punishments in MAL A 7,8, and 9 as instrumental talion: the offending organ is the locus of punishment in all three cases, just as is the case in Deut 25:11-12. For a translation of these texts, see Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor, 156-157.
The translations in the Septuagint and Targumim also reflect an understanding that cutting off the woman’s hand was the punishment. The translation of the first half of v. 12 in the Septuagint is ἀποκόψεις τὴν χεῖρα αὐτῆς , “You shall cut off her hand.” The verb ἀποκόψεις is commonly used in cases of cutting and chopping, and in a few other cases is specifically used in contexts of cutting off limbs. The word χεῖρα is the common word for hand, the equivalent of יד in the Hebrew Bible. See LSJ, 100. Targum Onqelos renders the woman’s sentence as “you shall cut off her hand” (ותקוץ ית ידה) and Targum Pseudo-Jonathan as “you shall cut off her hand up to the wrist” (ותקטעון ית פיסת ידה, following M. Jastrow, Dictionary of the Targumim, Talmud Babli, Yerushalmi, and Midrashic Literature [New York: G.P. Putnam’s Sons, 1903], 1168 on the translation of פיסת ידה).
This is his name in MSS Munich 95 and Vatican 116 (where it is R. Judah ben R. Dostai). The printed editions have R. Dostai ben Judah.
Gersonides is an exception here in that he interprets the sentence as mutilation, though he also allows for extenuating circumstances. On Rashi, Ibn Ezra, and Gersonides on this verse, see Carasik, The Commentators’ Bible, 169.
This is the text as it appears in MSS Paris 176 and Frankfurt 150 and other editions. MS Paris 177 adds the words וכאשר לא תוכל להציל המוחזק מכפה, “when you cannot save who is held in her hand.” (MS information is taken from the AlHaTorah website.) This latter phrase follows the interpretation of R. Judah ibn Balaam (see below) and may have been added by a scribe uncomfortable with the implication of ibn Ezra’s interpretation.
Though if the woman does sustain additional injury beyond miscarriage, it becomes a case of lex talionis, though the exact penalty is elusive. See discussion in, Sandra Jacobs, “Deathblows to a Pregnant Woman: What Restitution Was Required?” TheTorah (2020). Some correlations between Deut 25:11–12 and Exod 21: 22–25 are noteworthy: Both laws open with the same wording (כי ינצו אנשים, “if men are fighting”) and both address injuries (or potential injuries) that relate to loss of or possible potential loss of progeny caused by that situation. There are several significant differences, though. Deut 25:11-12 doesn’t say that the man suffered physical injury, while the woman in Exod 21:22-25 suffers a miscarriage. For the miscarriage itself, if that is the only harm done, the punishment is simply financial compensation. The woman in Deut 25:11-12, however, suffers the loss of her hand. While the wife’s intent is clear in the law in Deuteronomy, it is not clear from the description whether the man who injured the pregnant woman intended harm, or if it was by accident, or whether she tried to intervene or was just a bystander.
Numbers 35:31, by prohibiting the use of such a payout in the case of a murder reveals that in other cases monetary compensation was an option.
Other cases in which the admonishment “show no pity” occur (all of which are in Deuteronomy) involve severe penalties (the death penalty in Deut 13:9 and 19:13; and the possibility of the death penalty in Deut 19:21) with no mention of paying money as an alternative.
Translated from the Arabic by Ma’aravi Peretz.
It is likely that this is the meaning of the Tanna Qama (first opinion) in Sifrei Deuteronomy 293; the text speaks about “saving her” but this may derive from a scribe misunderstanding the derasha and adjusting it from the original “saving him.”
וקצתה את כפה—מלמד שאתה חייב להציל(ה)[ו] בכפה. מנין אם אין אתה יכול להציל אות(ה)[ו] בכפה הציל(ה)[ו] בנפשה? תלמוד לומר לא תחס עינך.
“Cut off her hand”—This teaches that you must save (her) [him] at the expense of her hand. How do you know that if you cannot save (her) [him] at the expense of her hand that you can save (her) [him] at the expense of her life? The text says “Show no pity.”
The text as is makes little sense, since she is not the one in danger; correcting the text to “him” in these cases yields the position of R. Judah ibn Balaam and Maimonides. Perhaps the fact that similar derashot appear in the case of rape (permission to kill the rapist if necessary) caused the confusion here.
Translation by Eliyahu Touger (New York: Moznaim Publishing Corporation, 1997).
Or, in case of Deut 19:21 in which the offense is bearing false witness, the potential damage. The principle of lex talionis, also called retaliative justice, is outlined in Exod 21:23-25; Lev 24:19-20; and Deut 19:21. For a discussion of how this principle is applied in both biblical law and narrative, see Jacobs, The Body as Property, 68-127.
Jacobs, “Instrumental Talion in Deuteronomic Law,” 269. She credits Bernard Jackson with suggesting this term while supervising her doctoral research at the University of Manchester (n. 41).
This explanation for the relationship between the punishment and the crime is the one most favored by contemporary scholars. For a survey of biblical, ancient Near Eastern, and post-biblical texts that apply this principle, see Yael Shemesh, “Punishment of the Offending Organ in Biblical Literature,” VT 55.3 (2005): 343-365. Examples include Num 5:11-31 (if the woman has committed adultery, the waters will affect her “thigh” and “belly.” In this case both terms probably refer to her reproductive organs, the very organs by which she sinned); 1 Kgs 13:4 (Jeroboam’s offending hand is withered); Ps 31:19 (the psalmist wishes for lying lips to be made speechless); Prov 30:17 (the eye that mocks a father or scorns obeying a mother will be gouged out by ravens and eaten by birds of prey); and Job 31:21–22 (Job states, in a form of self-imprecation, that if he has raised a hand against the fatherless, let his shoulder by dislocated and his arm broken). There are four cases in the Laws of Hammurabi where the hand, as the offending organ, is cut off (LH 195, for a son who strikes his father; LH 218, for a physician who either caused a patient’s death or destroyed his eye, LH 226, for a barber who shaves off the slave hair lock of someone’s slave without the owner’s consent, and LH 253, for someone who steals seed and fodder after being hired to cultivate a field).
Eslinger, “The Case of an Immodest Lady Wrestler,” 277–281, offers a variation of this approach, arguing that the woman’s offense was committing an act of unfair intervention in a fight by employing a “below the belt” move. He sees this law as a result of the author’s reflections on Gen 32:25–33, in which Jacob and a divine entity are wrestling, and one, when he sees he is losing, resorts to an underhanded move against his opponent to gain the advantage. Eslinger argues that Jacob is the one who committed the underhanded move, not the divine entity (which is by far the more common interpretation), and that this law is the Deuteronomic authors’ critique of Jacob’s using such an underhanded method to gain the advantage, and a way of discouraging his audience from emulating Jacob’s tactics.
This would entail not only being excluded from certain religious gatherings, but also being excluded from the public assembly, which means losing certain rights and privileges associated with citizenship. See Jeffrey Tigay, JPS Torah Commentary: Deuteronomy (Philadelphia, JPS, 1996), 209-211, for a discussion of the significance of the Assembly of YHWH in ancient Israel and all of the implications for a man who is excluded from it. Somewhat similarly, Lev 21:17-23 lists the physical defects that would disqualify a male from the priestly line from functioning as a priest (from approaching the altar, thus making sacrifices), which includes crushed testes (v. 20). See also, David Glatt-Gilad, “The Prohibition of Joining the Assembly of the Lord,” TheTorah (2015).
In several cases, body parts are grabbed hold of (hands in Gen 19.16; Isa 4:1; 41:13; and Jer 31:32, and feet in 2 Kgs 4:27) with no indication of harm. In cases in the Bible where physical harm or damage is related to the grasping or seizing, that harm or damage is noted by additional descriptors. See, e.g., Deut 22:25; Judg 19.25; 1 Sam 15.27; 17.35; 2 Sam 1:11; 2.16; 13:11; and 2 Kgs 2.12.
John H. Elliott, “Deuteronomy - Shameful Encroachment on Shameful Parts. Deut 25:11-12 and Biblical Euphemism in Ancient Israel,” in The Old Testament in Its Social Context, ed. Phillip F. Essler (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2006), 161–176 [168–169] provides a lengthy list of biblical euphemisms used for male and female genitalia.
See, e.g., Gen 9:20–27; 2 Sam 6:20; Isa 47:3; Jer 13:26; Ezek 16:36–37; 23:10; and Nah 3:5. For an in depth study of shame in the Hebrew Bible (with a focus on the prophetic texts), see Johanna Stiebert, The Construction of Shame in the Hebrew Bible: The Prophetic Contribution, JSOTSup 346 (London: Sheffield Academic Press, 2002).
John Elliott sees the woman’s behavior as an egregious violation of gender boundaries that not only humiliates the man but brings profound shame on all concerned. The wife “transgressed into male space and violated the physical boundary of a male not her husband or relative.” The husband allowed his wife to engage in this behavior and not only needed but accepted her help in a situation in which women should not interfere, and the other man allowed “an ‘inferior’ female to get the better of him by grabbing his ‘family jewels,’ knocking him to his knees with her nutcracker grip, and violating his sanctum sanctorum.” Elliott, “Deuteronomy,” 172-173.
Philo, The Special Laws, 3.31.169–172, 173–175, trans. F. H. Colson, Loeb Classical Library (Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press, 1937), 7.583-585. Philo continues his discussion of the importance of modesty by talking about how men and women should avoid seeing the other sex undressed, adding:
Surely, then, if it is reprehensible for them to use their sight, their hands are far more guilty. For the eyes often take liberties and compel us to see what we do not wish to see, but the hands are ranked among the parts which we keep in subjection, and render obedient service to our orders.
Philo, The Special Laws, 3.31.176-177. Colson, Philo, 585-587. For a discussion of Philo’s treatment of women, see Dorothy I. Sly, Philo’s Perception of Women, Brown Judaic Studies 290 (Atlanta: Scholar’s Press, 2020). For a discussion of how Philo deals with another Torah law about gender, see my, “The Prohibition of Cross-Dressing,” TheTorah (2018).
On the custom of Levirate marriage generally and Deut 25:5–10 in particular, see Tigay, Deuteronomy, 231-234 and 482-483. For a perspective on this practice within the larger context of biblical law (including attempts in the Priestly and Holiness sources to put an end to the practice), see Dr. Hacham Isaac S. D. Sassoon, “The Priestly Repudiation of Yibbum,” TheTorah (2016).
Rabbi Ovadia ben Jacob Sforno, in his commentary on Deuteronomy (ad loc), expands on this connection, claiming that the latter law reacts to the former by limiting the freedom of a woman to embarrass a man in public to ḥalitza only.
Editor’s note: For a look at some of these laws, see Cynthia Edenburg, “Deuteronomy’s Uncompromising Demand for Women’s Sexual Fidelity,” TheTorah (2014).
Editor’s note: For more on this view in the Bible, see Joel S. Baden, “God Opened Her Womb: The Biblical Conception of Fertility,” TheTorah (2017).
Steffan Mathias, “Reproducing Torah: Human and Divine Sexuality in the Book of Deuteronomy,” Sexuality and Law in the Torah, LHBOTS 675 (ed. Hilary Lipka and Bruce Wells, Bloomsbury T&T Clark, 2020), 217–238 [228–236].