Biblical and Greek Ambivalence Towards Child Sacrifice

A look at the the practice and prohibition of child sacrifice in the Bible and the ambivalence underlying the stories of Jephthah’s daughter, Agamemnon’s daughter, and the binding of Isaac.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Biblical and Greek Ambivalence Towards Child Sacrifice." TheTorah.com, November 15, 2016. https://www.thetorah.com/article/biblical-and-greek-ambivalence-towards-child-sacrifice.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Biblical and Greek Ambivalence Towards Child Sacrifice" (2016, November 15). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/biblical-and-greek-ambivalence-towards-child-sacrifice

Biblical and Greek Ambivalence Towards Child Sacrifice

The Sacrifice of Iphigeneia. Artist: Bertholet Flemalle (1614–1675)

Published: November 15, 2016

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Jon D. Levenson, The Death and Resurrection of the Beloved Son (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1993), 1.

  2. Dedication: I dedicate this essay to the memory of my wife of 64 wonderful years, who passed away three days before this Yom Kippur (5777). Joyce was a woman of beauty who created even more beauty in music and art. We shared a love of biblical legends, which along with the topography of Israel, were the inspiration for her music and tapestries.

    This essay emerges from a course I offered at New College, Hofstra, on the Psychohistory of Early Biblical Figures, but has been updated by further reading and correspondence with the editors at TheTorah.com.

  3. For the pros and cons of each possible interpretation, see discussion in Eve Levavi Feinstein, “Giving Your Firstborn Son to God,” TheTorah (2016).

  4. Nicole Ruane notes,

    There are two examples of biblical narratives of the sacrifice of the firstborn child carried out with impunity – Jephthah’s sacrifice of his daughter (Judges 11) and Mesha of Moab’s offering of his son (2 Kings 3:27). In most biblical stories, as in the Akedah the special child is not actually destroyed.

    Nicole J. Ruane, Sacrifice and Gender in Biblical Law (Cambridge University Press, 2013), 197. A more careful look at the texts that Ruane adduces suggests that her conclusion is not as certain as she implies.

  5. This would mean that the Israelite author acknowledged the power of foreign gods to favor their loyalists.

  6. See, for example, Rashi, who suggests that the sight of the sacrifice reminded God that Israel also once sacrificed to false gods, thus souring God on an Israelite victory.

  7. Radak quoting his father, and Ralbag.

  8. The identity of Moloch has long been a matter of controversy, but should probably to be identified with the Ammonite god, Milcom.

  9. Passing a child through fire, may not have involved the death of the child—this too is a matter of scholarly debate. For a reading of the Molech ritual as something other than a sacrifice, see Moshe Weinfeld, “The Worship of Molech and of the Queen of Heaven and Its Background,” Ugarit Forschungen 4 (1972): 133-154. For one response to this argument, see Morton Smith, “A Note on Burning Babies,” Journal of the American Oriental Society 19.3 (1975): 477-479. See also John Day, Molech: A God of Human Sacrifice in the Old Testament (University of Cambridge Oriental Publications 41; Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989.)

  10. Leviticus and Deuteronomy are not necessarily referring to the same practice; Leviticus never mentions fire and Deuteronomy never mentions Molech. Nevertheless, the fact that 2 Kings 23:10 refers to passing sons and daughters through the fire for Molech, points to the reasonable hypothesis that Lev and Deut are, in fact, referring to the same ritual.

  11. See Robin Ngo’s discussion in his Biblical Archaeology Review article, “Did Carthaginians Really Practice Infant Sacrifice?”

  12. The biblical metaphor of covenant may be a reflection of the ANE concept of a covenant between a great king and his vassal kings. For more on this, see: Jon Levenson, “The Shema and the Commandment to Love God in Its Ancient Near Eastern Context,” TheTorah (2016); Pamela Barmash, “The Introduction of Blessings into our Treaty with God,” TheTorah (2014); Marvin Sweeney, “How Do We Conceive the Divine?” TheTorah (2014); Deena Grant, “Loving God Beyond the Way You Love Ashurbanipal,” TheTorah (2016); and Yitzhaq Feder, “The Significance of Hittite Treaties for Biblical Studies and Orthodox Judaism,” TheTorah (2014). See also Moshe Weinfeld, “Berit – covenant vs obligation,” Biblica 56 (1975), 120-128; Yoram Hazony, The Philosophy of Hebrew Scripture (Cambridge University Press, 2012), 126-128.

  13. J.G. Frazer, The Golden Bough, A Study in Magic and Religion, 3rd edition; vol. 6 “The Dying God,” (London: Macmillan, 1911), 160-195.

  14. Devorah Steinmetz, From Father to Son: Kinship, Conflict, and Continuity in Genesis(Literary Currents in Biblical Interpretation; ( John Knox Press, Westminster 1991) 29

  15. Genesis Rabbah 53:6 comments on the verse “a son in his old age” Genesis 21:2 that Isaac’s features were like those of Abraham. Because Abraham and Sarah had spent time in Gerar, some suggested that Isaac was Abimelech’s son, not Abraham’s child. But, Isaac looked just like Abraham, so, a great party was arranged to quell the doubts of all who mocked. See the Tzemah Yoreh essay in note 23.

  16. For modern defenses of this reading, see, David Marcus, Jephthah and His Vow (Lubbock: Texas Tech University, 1986), Jonathan Magonet, “Did Jephthah Actually Kill His Daughter?” TheTorah (2015).

  17. Flavius Josephus, Judean Antiquities, book 5 (trans. Christopher Begg), 66.

  18. Apparently, the offering of a first-born daughter could be providential, playing a similar role to that of a first-born son in fulfilling a vow to a god.

  19. Translation by Robert Potter (1781). Diana is the Roman equivalent of the Greek goddess Artemis

  20. As this command seems to contradict God’s explicit promises, one can imagine Abraham wondering how the promise of the great future could be achieved if the seed of the future was to be consumed on the altar. Commentators throughout the ages wondered at this question as well as the general question of how God could have made such a command. For a discussion of the many interpretations offered, see Isaac Kalimi, “Mitigating the Akedah,” TheTorah (2015).

  21. Targum Yerashalmi and Midrash Aggada (ad loc.), Sefer Ha-Yashar Vayera, 45b.

  22. See, Tova Hartman and Charlie Buckholtz, Are You Not a Man of God: Devotion, Betrayal, and Social Criticism in Jewish Tradition (Oxford University Press 2014). They argue that sometimes supporting characters in a story, such as Iphigenia and Isaac, appear to acquiesce to the demands of the dominant figures, such as their fathers Agamemnon and Abraham. In reality, they raise arguments against their fathers’ abrupt change from love, devotion and family in order to pursue honor, individual commitment to a god and national glory. The same paradigm applies to the story of Jephthah and his daughter. Jephthah utters a rash vow which will lead to the death of his daughter. Though she accepts her fate in order to assure military victory she bemoans the emptiness of her life. Iphigenia and Isaac raise questions as well. The ambivalence of the supporting characters parallels that of their fathers. The ambivalence colors the endings: do the children survive or is their sacrifice actualized? Both endings appear in text and legend.

  23. Sacrificial substitution is a major theme of by Rene Girard, Violence and the Sacred Baltimore (Johns Hopkins University Press 1987), ch. 1.

  24. See Tzemah Yoreh, “The Sacrifice of Isaac in Context: Recovering a Lost Ending of the Akedah,” TheTorah (2014).

  25. I found many of these midrashim in Louis Ginzberg, The Legends of the Jews v. 5 (Notes to Volumes 1 and 2 From the Creation to the Exodus, The Akedah ; Baltimore/London: Johns Hopkins Press, 1953), 255.

  26. Ibn Ezra Genesis 22:19.

  27. For a long discussion of the many rabbinic interpretations of this story, see Shalom Spiegel’s masterful work, The Last Trial: On the Legends and Lore of the Command to Abraham to Offer Isaac as a Sacrifice: The Akedah (trans. with an introduction by Judah Goldin; Jewish Lights Publishing, 2003 (3rd print).

  28. Spiegel, Prologue, 7

  29. Genesis Rabbah 56:11