Biblical Exegesis as a Source of Jewish Pluralism: The Case of the Karaites

Karaism is often characterized by its rejection of the Talmud in favor of a super-literalist interpretation of the Torah. But Karaism is better understood as an alternate, parallel form of Judaism based on the Bible.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Biblical Exegesis as a Source of Jewish Pluralism: The Case of the Karaites." TheTorah.com, June 6, 2017. https://www.thetorah.com/article/biblical-exegesis-as-a-source-of-jewish-pluralism-the-case-of-the-karaites.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Biblical Exegesis as a Source of Jewish Pluralism: The Case of the Karaites" (2017, June 6). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/biblical-exegesis-as-a-source-of-jewish-pluralism-the-case-of-the-karaites

Biblical Exegesis as a Source of Jewish Pluralism: The Case of the Karaites

Reading from the new Torah during Jubilee celebrations for the Anan HaNasi Synagogue, Ashdod, Israel. June 2013. Facebook היהדות הקראית העולמית-The Universal Karaite Judaism

Categories:

KaraitesEikev

Published: June 6, 2017

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. The issue of Karaite origins is still a matter of debate; for an overview of Karaism, see Meira Polliack, ed., Karaite Judaism: A Guide to its History and Literary Sources (Leiden/Boston: Brill, 2003). Karaites, understandably, consider their form of Judaism to be original and Rabbinic Judaism, with its belief in a divine Oral Torah, to be an innovation from the Second Temple period.

  2. Anan’s motto is discussed by Daniel Frank, Search Scripture Well (Leiden/Boston: Brill, 2004), pp. 1-32; Karaite scripturalism is discussed in Idem, “The Limits of Karaite Scripturalism: Problems in Narrative Exegesis,” in A Word Fitly Spoken. Studies in Mediaeval Exegesis of the Hebrew Bible and the Qur’an presented to Haggai Ben-Shammai (eds., Meir M. Bar-Asher, et al.; Jerusalem: Yad Ben Zvi and Hebrew University, 2007), pp. *41-*82.

  3. In the context of Karaism, the followers of Rabbinic Judaism are known as Rabbanites.

  4. For a general overview of Karaite laws concerning personal status, see Michael Corinaldi, The Personal Status of the Karaites (Jerusalem: Rubin Mass, 1984) [Hebrew].

  5. Eastern European Karaites spoke a Turkic language which they wrote in Hebrew letters; their Rabbanite neighbors spoke Judaeo-German (Yiddish), also written in Hebrew letters. The Karaite language, often called Karaim, has all but disappeared.

  6.  Karaite population estimates are hard to make, but it is unlikely that there are more than 40,000 Karaites worldwide; the Israeli community apparently numbers somewhere between 20-30,000. The headquarters of Universal Karaite Judaism is in Ramla, and their official website is: http://www.karaite.org.il/. American Karaites are centered in the Bay Area in California where they have their own synagogue; see http://www.karaites.org/.

  7. The first systematic list of principles of Karaism was formulated by the mid-twelfth-century Byzantine Karaite Judah Hadassi, in his book Eshkol ha-kofer (1149), thereby pre-dating Maimonides’ list of thirteen principles in his Commentary on the Mishnah (1168). There were, however, a number of Rabbanite lists of principles which pre-dated both Hadassi and Maimonides.

  8. The discussion will provide only a general outline of the divergent practices and the methods used by each group to arrive at their conclusions. The issues are more complex than presented here. Although the two groups differed in their interpretation of the biblical laws of torts and damages as well, these differences were mostly theoretical, since, in the diaspora, neither group had real authority to adjudicate civil law.

  9. The most prominent difference is the Karaite prohibition of the alyah, the fat-tail, which Rabbanites allow.

  10. While this interpretation might strike most readers as far-fetched, it should be remembered that the first half of both verses in Exodus refers specifically to the first fruits: “The first fruits of your land bring to the house of the Lord your God” (reishit bikkurei admatekha tavi’ beit ha-shem elohekha); it is the second half of these verses which mentions the prohibition of the gedi and its “mother’s” milk. Editor’s note: R. Joseph Bechor Shor offers a similar understanding of the latter term (ripen); see Zev Farber, “The Prohibition of Meat and Milk: Its Origins in the Text,” TheTorah.com (2014).

  11. Nevertheless, the echoes of this interpretation persisted, and over 200 years after Qirqisani, Abraham ibn Ezra wrote the following in his commentary on Exod. 23:19:

    אמרו חסרי הדעת: כי גדי – מגזירת מגד. ולא יתכן כי מ”ם מגד שרש והעד הנאמן: עם פרי מגדים, כי ככה לא ימצא בלשון הקדש. ועוד: מה טעם לא תבשל? ואין כח ביד אדם לבשל המגד. .. מה טעם לומר בחלב? ואנה מצאנו כלשון הזה. ועוד: מה טעם אמו? ואנה נקרא העץ אם המגד.
    Thoughtless people (hasrei da’at, maybe idiots), said that gedi(goat) is derived from meged (produce). That is impossible. The mem in the word meged is part of the root, as we see in the verse from Song of Songs 4:13: “with all choicest fruits” (im pri megadim). One does not find such a usage in the Holy Language [namely, Hebrew]. Furthermore, what does lo tevasheil, “do not cook” mean? People do not cause fruits to ripen… what does ba-haleiv mean? Where have we found such a usage where “the milk” means “being on the tree”? And what does it mean “its mother”? Where is the tree ever called the mother of the fruit?

    The exact same comments are made by the fourteenth century Karaite commentator Aaron ben Elijah, who was much influenced by Ibn Ezra, except he expressed his disapproval in less graphic terms than Ibn Ezra: he left out the words hasrei da’at, “the thoughtless ones” or “the idiots,” since he knew to whom Ibn Ezra was referring and did not want to say anything insulting about someone who had become accepted by the Karaites as one of their early sages.

  12. See m. Hullin, 8:4.

  13. See Sacha Stern, Calendar and Community (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001).

  14. Editor’s note: For more on what this verse might mean, see Jonathan Ben Dov, “The First Month of the Year,” TheTorah.com (2014).

  15. The lack of calendrical instructions in the Bible, despite the fact that a calendar is assumed, is mentioned by Abraham Ibn Ezra, in the introduction to his Commentary on the Torah, as an example of why there must have been an Oral Torah given along with the Written Torah. As Ibn Ezra asks rhetorically, why are the laws of leprosy, which is so rare and affects so few people, given in great detail, whereas the laws of the calendar, which affects every Jew daily, are missing in the Torah?

  16. Editor’s note: For a description of a solar calendar in force during the Second Temple period among some Jews, see Michael Segal, “The Jewish Calendar in Jubilees,” TheTorah.com (2014).

  17. Rabbinic exegesis did not understand this verse as a commandment concerning setting the calendar; see, e.g., Ibn Ezra’s commentary for an alternate explanation of signs and seasons.

  18. In addition, there are other minor differences concerning holidays and fast days. Karaites do not observe the post-Biblical Hanukkah; Purim is in the first Adar in a leap year; fast days are 24 Tishrei, 10 Tevet, 9 Tammuz, and 7 and 10 Av; there are no second days of the holidays in the diaspora. The Israeli Karaite community issues its own calendar annually. Editor’s note: For more on Karaite Purim, see Shawn Lichaa, “Comparing Purims,” TheTorah.com(2015). For more on Karaite “Tisha B’Av,” see Tomer Mangoubi, “Lamenting with Job: The Karaite Version of the Fasts for Jerusalem,” TheTorah.com (2016). 

  19. A Wednesday Rosh Hashanah means a Friday Yom Kippur, and a Friday Rosh Hashanah means a Sunday Yom Kippur; observing the two days one after the other is a major imposition. A Sunday Rosh Hashanah is avoided to make sure Hoshana Rabba, with its rituals including the willow branches, does not fall on Shabbat.

  20. Editor’s note: For a discussion of Karaite Yom Teruah, see Shawn Lichaa, “A Shofar-less Rosh Hashanah: A Karaite’s Experience of Yom Teru’ah,” TheTorah.com (2014).

  21. The differences between Karaite and Rabbanite (especially Rav Saadia Gaon) approaches to Psalms, and the polemical aspects of their commentaries, is described by Uriel Simon, Four Approaches to the Book of Psalms: From Saadiah Gaon to Abraham Ibn Ezra (Albany, NY: SUNY Press, 1991).

  22.  Contemporary Karaites use Israeli reproductions of Siddur ha-Tefillot ke-Minhag ha-Qara’im (Vilna, 1891-1893).

  23. Many of these practices were in use during the Second Temple but were abandoned by Rabbanites. An attempt by Maimonides’ son Abraham to renew some of them in the thirteenth century was unsuccessful, perhaps because of their similarity to Muslim prayer practices.

  24. All Karaite tzitzit include a blue thread, the tekhelet, with no particular source for the dye. In contrast, today only some Rabbanites use a blue thread; the blue color is produced from a particular sea-snail (Murex trunculus). The diverse methods of arranging the Karaite and Rabbanite tzitzit can be seen in a number videos posted on the internet.

  25. Editor’s note: See discussion in Yehudah Cohn, “The Origins of Tefillin,” TheTorah.com(2016).

  26. It is of interest that there is no specific prohibition of father-daughter relations in the Torah, but both Rabbanites and Karaites forbid them.

  27. Deut. 24:1, Is. 50:1, and Jer. 3:8 refer to a writ of divorce but no specifications are given.

  28. As mentioned above, Ashkenazim have traditionally prohibited intermarriage with Karaites. This is because they consider Karaite marriages valid and Karaite divorces invalid. The approach of Radbaz to Karaites (and Ethiopian Jews) was followed by Rabbi Moshe Feinstein with regard to Reform Jews in America and the problems of their remarriages after merely a civil divorce.

  29. Editor’s note: For an historical-critical discussion of this problem, see Isaac Sassoon, “The Priestly Repudiation of Yibbum,” TheTorah.com (2016).