Deuteronomy or the Priestly Text: Which Is the Later Torah Source?

In the 1950s, Yehezkel Kaufmann challenged the regnant Graf-Wellhausen Hypothesis that the Priestly Text was the final Pentateuchal source to be written, and that it dates to the Post-Exilic Period. One pillar of his argument is that the Priestly Text seems wholly ignorant of Deuteronomy’s 7th century B.C.E. law of centralization of worship, and thus dates to earlier in the First Temple period. And yet, a closer look at P’s laws shows that it is simply taking centralization for granted.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Deuteronomy or the Priestly Text: Which Is the Later Torah Source?." TheTorah.com, July 16, 2026. https://www.thetorah.com/article/deuteronomy-or-the-priestly-text-which-is-the-later-torah-source.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Deuteronomy or the Priestly Text: Which Is the Later Torah Source?" (2026, July 16). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/deuteronomy-or-the-priestly-text-which-is-the-later-torah-source

Deuteronomy or the Priestly Text: Which Is the Later Torah Source?

Yehezkel Kaufmann alongside a Torah scroll. Wikimedia adapted

Published: July 16, 2026

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. For a basic description of what brought this theory about, see Zev Farber, “Documentary Hypothesis: The Revelation of YHWH’s Name Continues to Enlighten,” TheTorah (2014).

  2. Indeed, this is why it was often called G (=Grundschrift, “Core Text”) or Q (=Quelle, “Source”). Some important scholars that thought this way are Karl David Ilgen (1763–1834), Hermann Hupfeld (1796–1866), Theodor Nöldeke (1836–1930), and August Dillmann (1823–1894).

  3. The idea was first argued by Karl Heinrich Graf (1815–1869). This view was adopted by the important Dutch scholar Abraham Kuenen (1828–1891), and then by Julius Wellhausen (1844–1918) in his Prolegomena to the History of Israel, which became the classic work on the Documentary Hypothesis. See Julius Wellhausen, Prolegomena to the History of Israel, trans., J. Sutherland Black and Allan Menzies (Cambridge University Press, 2014; repr. of, Adam & Charles Black, 1885); trans. of, Prolegomena zur Geschichte Israels, 2nd ed. (G. Reimer, 1883); repr. of, Geschichte Israels 1 (G. Reimer, 1878).

  4. See discussion in, Alan T. Levenson, “Was the Documentary Hypothesis Tainted by Wellhausen’s Antisemitism?” TheTorah (2021).

  5. He won both the Bialik Prize for Jewish Thought (twice, 1933 and 1956) and the Israel Prize for Jewish Studies (1958).

  6. The book was published by Mosad Bialik in eight volumes, from 1937 through 1956. An abridged version was published in English, by Moshe Greenberg, The Religion of Israel from its Beginnings to the Babylonian Exile (University of Chicago Press, 1960). Quotations in this article are taken from Greenberg’s English abridgment where available but are my own translations from the original where not.

  7. Jacob Milgrom (The Anchor Bible Leviticus 1-16 [Doubleday 1991], 9) adduces Kaufmann’s authority to the effect that “‘There is not one demonstrable case in which P shows the influence of D’ (Kaufmann 1937-56: 1.61-65). The reverse situation, however - that D is dependent on P (and H) – is manifest in many instances.”

  8. To name a few illustrious examples: Moshe Greenberg, Moshe Weinfeld, Jacob Milgrom, Gary Anderson, Avi Hurvitz, Menahem Haran, Israel Knohl, and Richard Elliott Friedman. As for H “Holiness”—the siglum originally created for the Holiness Collection in Leviticus 17-26, and now extended by many to other passages ostensibly from this same alternative Priestly school—Knohl, and eventually Milgrom, date it to later than P.

  9. “This study”- Elrefaei continues, “illustrates the great impact of these two significant figures and shows that they are not irrelevant.” See Aly Elrefaei,Wellhausen and Kaufmann: Ancient Israel and its Religious History in the Works of Julius Wellhausen and Yehezkel Kaufmann, de Gruyter 2016 p. Vlll. Cf. idem “Yehezkel Kaufmann: An Academic Defender of Israel’s Religious Spirit,” TheTorah (2024).

  10. The Samaritans, however, understand it as a reference to Mount Gerizim. See discussion in Eyal Baruch, “Mount Gerizim and the Polemic Against the Samaritans,” TheTorah (2016).

  11. Had Kaufmann attacked the once fashionable idea of Ezra’s authorship of P, he would have carried conviction. In fact, since he wrote, the Ezra hypothesis has mostly fallen by the wayside. But a leap from mid-fifth century Ezra back to the monarchy overshoots an exilic/early post-exilic date which, based on both internal and external evidence, is the temporal niche where many serious scholars situate P. See discussion in, e.g., Rolf Rendtorff’s “The Gēr in the Priestly Laws of the Pentateuch” in Ethnicity and the Bible ed., Mark G. Brett (Brill 1996), 86-87.

  12. The LXX here reads “to our holy temples, to the house of the LORD” (εἰς τὰ ἅγια ἡμῶν, εἰς οἶκον κυρίου), which implies a Vorlage of אל מקדשינו אל בית י־הוה. The word מקדשיך at Ezekiel 28:18 probably refers to a single royal temple, albeit Tyre’s rather than

    Jerusalem’s. As R. David Kimhi (Radak, d. 1235) explains, a temple comprises several units each entitled to the honorific.

    רד"ק ירמיה נא:נא ...רבוי מקדשיך כי המקדש היה שלשה בתים אולם והיכל ודביר.
    Radak, Jer 51:51 …the plural “your holy places” is because the Temple had three structures: the vestibule, the sanctuary, and the holy of holies.

    References to multiple temples also appear in Psalms:

    תהלים סח:לו נוֹרָא אֱלֹהִים מִמִּקְדָּשֶׁיךָ אֵל יִשְׂרָאֵל הוּא נֹתֵן עֹז וְתַעֲצֻמוֹת לָעָם בָּרוּךְ אֱלֹהִים.
    Ps 68:36 You are awesome, O God, in Your holy temples; it is the God of Israel who gives might and power to the people. Blessed is God.
    תהלים עג:יז עַד אָבוֹא אֶל מִקְדְּשֵׁי אֵל אָבִינָה לְאַחֲרִיתָם.
    Ps 73:17 till I entered God’s sanctuaries and reflected on their fate.

    Commenting on this latter verse, Mitchell Dahood (Psalms 51–100, Anchor Bible [Doubleday, 1983], 192) writes:

    Plural miqdᵉšē conforms to the frequent Canaanite practice of employing plural forms for names of dwellings... Canaanite usage thus confirms the explanation of plural miqdāšekā in Ezek 28:18 proposed by G. A. Cooke, The Book of Ezekiel (Edinburgh, 1936), p. 324. He recognized that the plural may denote a single sanctuary with the precincts.

  13. Kaufmann, The Religion of Israel, 178–179.

  14. Some scholars surmise that theological scruples may have deterred P from using the anthropomorphic יראה את פני vocabulary for referring to the pilgrim’s visit to a shrine. The word יראה in scriptures such as Exodus 34:23’s יראה כל זכורך את פני האדן is traditionally vocalized as passive giving it the meaning of “shall be seen before the Deity.” However, there are indications the verb was once pronounced as active with the sense of ‘seeing the Deity’s face’ (see Hagigah 2a, Rashi and Tosafoth’s comments ad loc.). If indeed the latter was the original reading, P’s putative qualms about the phrase gain plausibility. Nor should we rule out the odds of an echo of the old ראיה in P’s own כי בענן אראה at Lev 16: 2.

  15. If, however, K intends to deny P’s חג its wayfaring connotation and assign it instead a connotation attested in the Talmud, it wouldn’t exactly redound to P’s antiquity. For in rabbinic sources חג serves interchangeably with מועד as a generic term for feast days so that Psalm 81:4’s יום חגנו is made to refer to Yom Teruah (b. Rosh Hashanah 8b).

  16. For Matzot see Exod 12:14; Lev 23:6; Num 28:17; for Sukkot, Lev 23:34,39,41; Num 29:12. Shavuoth (aka Pentecost or Feast of Weeks) is the odd man out: חג vocabulary occurs nowhere in P’s Shavuoth pericopae. Although its precise purport remains obscure, Lev 23:21’s ‘in all your habitations [בכל מושבתיכם]’ may indicate that Shavuoth was to be celebrated at home by the Israelite whose presence at the central sanctuary was required just twice a year. But exempting the one-day festival of Shavuoth from the pilgrimage duty simply makes it comparable to P’s other one-day Holy Days of Teruah and Atonement. In any event, P’s omission of חג from its Shavuoth texts has no bearing on P’s date relative to D. To argue that no legislation after D could have modified Shavuoth is to ignore the festival calendar of Ezekiel chapter 45, that by all estimations postdates D, yet skips Shavuoth altogether.

  17. Towards the end of P’s festival calendar, the Israelites are told to take special branches and fruit of trees וּשְׂמַחְתֶּם לִפְנֵי יְ־הֹוָה אֱלֹהֵיכֶם “and rejoice before YHWH your God” (Lev 23:40). In P, “before YHWH” denotes, not a spiritual state, but rather a geographic location, namely the sanctuary (See b. Sukkah 41a; Sifra Emor 9), where the priests are present and participate in the rites. Nevertheless, many scholars note that these verses have all the appearances of a late addition.

  18. Deut 18:1,6-7; 21:5; 33:8-10.

  19. Scriptures whose antiquity is generally acknowledged, such as the stories of Miriam (Num 12:14-15) and of the four anonymous outcasts (2Kgs 7:3-4, 10), attest to the banishment of lepers. And indeed, the Priestly text reiterates this requirement

    ויקרא יג:מו כׇּל יְמֵי אֲשֶׁר הַנֶּגַע בּוֹ יִטְמָא טָמֵא הוּא בָּדָד יֵשֵׁב מִחוּץ לַמַּחֲנֶה מוֹשָׁבוֹ.
    Lev 13:46 They shall be impure as long as the disease is present. Being impure, they shall dwell apart—in a dwelling outside the camp.

    Another P text (Num 5:4) reports that lepers and persons suffering a discharge or defiled through contact with a corpse were expelled after Moses had been expressly urged to expel them from the camp (Num 5:1–3).

  20. Both the Miriam story and the Priestly legislation use the term הסגר “quarantine,” but even this commonality only serves to highlight the different connotations of the verb in the respective Scriptures. In the Miriam story, it refers to keeping the person outside the camp for a set time, but in Leviticus, הסגר is a technical term that denotes keeping under observation or in quarantine. It is applied exclusively to cases of suspected leprosy whose incipient symptoms leave the priest undecided as to their nature. Lev 13:11 spells out the contradistinction between a doubtful diagnosis for which הסגר is imposed, and confirmed leprosy for which הסגר is expressly disallowed.

  21. This is either the name of a god or a technical term meaning “baby sacrifice.” See discussion in Daniel Vainstub, “Molekh: The Sacrifice of Babies,” TheTorah (2024).

  22. Lev 18:21; 20:2,3,4,5. It also appears in Jeremiah 32:35.

  23. Kaufmann, The Religion of Israel, 177.

  24. Kaufmann does not subscribe to the belief in Mosaic authorship of the Torah. Hence ‘the past’ (also ’the present and future’) represents the perspective of P whose advent K pushes back to an era long before Josiah and the promulgation of D - but not to the wilderness generation.

  25. Kaufmann, The Religion of Israel, 182–183.

  26. These six words obviously refer back to the cultic legislation of vv. 3-6. That does not stop desperate apologists (e.g., The Hertz Chumash p. 486) making them apply exclusively to satyr worship whose menace is invoked as the law’s motive in the immediately preceding clause.

  27. This is obvious, since they are described as eating only manna (and quail in some sources), but is also stated explicitly in several passages from P: Lev 19:23, 23:10; Num 15:18, 18:13.