Did They Fast on Tisha B’Av During the Second Temple Period?

In the early post-exilic period, the people ask the prophet Zechariah whether they should still fast to commemorate the destruction of the Temple now that it was being rebuilt. Zechariah, in a long collection of oracles, explains that the fasts will eventually be cancelled, once the people (7:9–10) “Execute true justice; deal loyally and compassionately with one another; do not defraud the widow, the orphan, the stranger, and the poor; and do not plot evil against one another.” So, did they ever cancel the fasts?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Did They Fast on Tisha B’Av During the Second Temple Period?." TheTorah.com, July 21, 2026. https://www.thetorah.com/article/did-they-fast-on-tisha-bav-during-the-second-temple-period.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Did They Fast on Tisha B’Av During the Second Temple Period?" (2026, July 21). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/did-they-fast-on-tisha-bav-during-the-second-temple-period

Did They Fast on Tisha B’Av During the Second Temple Period?

The Wailing Wall, Jerusalem, Carl Werner, 1879. Wikimedia

Published: July 21, 2026

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. The text in Kings is corrupt and only says the day and not the month.

  2. It is difficult to determine from the biblical texts how many years after the destruction Gedaliah was murdered. It is plausible that several years passed before he consolidated his position, the crops recovered, and the inhabitants of Judah who had fled during the war began returning to the land, and Gedaliah was assassinated only then. See discussion in Danel Kahn, “How Long Did Gedaliah Govern before He Was Assassinated?” TheTorah (2022).

  3. According to Ezra 6:15, the rebuilding was completed during year 6 of Darius’ reign, ca. 516 B.C.E.

  4. All translations of biblical text come from RJPS with adjustments.

  5. See Tova Ganzel, “למשמעות המשך קיומו של צום השביעי בימי שיבת ציון” [The Fast of Gedaliah: Its Continued Observance and Significance in the Restoration Period], Shnaton: An Annual for Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Studies 20 (2010): 51–69. See also, Tzvi Novick, “Tzom Gedaliah: Why Commemorate His Assassination?” TheTorah (2021).

  6. The rest of the book of Zechariah, which scholars call Deutero-Zechariah, comes from a different source. See discussion in, Hervé Gonzalez, “Zechariah 9–14 and the Continuation of Zechariah during the Ptolemaic Period,” Journal of Hebrew Scriptures 13 (2013).

  7. See discussion in, Joseph Tabory, מועדי ישראל בתקופת המשנה והתלמוד [Jewish Festivals in the Time of the Mishnah and Talmud] (Magnes, 1995), 398–399, who remains unsure about whether these fasts were kept during this period or not.

  8. For a discussion of this festival and what Nehemiah means by it being in the Torah, see Alex Jassen, “

  9. For text and commentary, see Vered Noam, מגילת תענית: הנוסחים, פשרם, תודותיהם, בצירוף מהדורה ביקורתית [Megillat Ta’anit: Versions, Interpretation, History, with a Critical Edition] (Yad Ben Zvi Press, 2003), 217–222.

  10. The scholion has two main ancient variants, the Oxford and Parma manuscripts, respectively, as well as one hybrid version. For an overview, see Vered Noam, “Megillat Ta’anit and Its Scholion (Commentary),” TheTorah (2015).

  11. The word באב appears in the printed edition but not the manuscripts. Nevertheless, Jacob Nahum Epstein (1878–1952) argues that Tisha B’Av is the original intention. Moreover, he argues that a similar line in Mishnah Taanit 4:5 also once had this meaning, and that later discomfort and revisions have reframed the line to mean something very different, but the redaction critical basis for this argument is too intricate to adduce here. See Jacob Nahum Epstein, “זמן עצי הכהנים” [The Time of the Wood for the Priests], מחקרים בספרות התלמוד ובלשונות שמיות [Studies in Talmudic Literature and Semitic Languages], trans., Ziporah Epstein (Magnes 1983),1.1–5; trans. of “Die Zeiten d. Holzopfers” [The Time for the Wood Offering] Monatsschrift für Geschichte und Wissenschaft des Judentums [MGWJ] 78 (1934): 79–103. A similar ideological revision took place in the hybrid scholion. See Noam, Megillat Ta’anit, 219 [n.28].

  12. See discussion in Paul (Pinchas) Mandel, “'לא היו ימים טובים לישראל כחמישה עשר באב וכיום הכיפורים': על המשנה האחרונה של מסכת תענית וגלגוליה” [There Were no Better Days for Israel than the Fifteenth of Av and the Day of Atonement': On the Last Mishnah of Tractate Ta'anit and Its Developments], Teudah 11 (1996): 147–178 [168–170 nn 95–99].

  13. Similarly, the date established for the Fast of Gedaliah also appears in Megillat Ta'anit as a day on which fasting is prohibited:

    מגילת תענית בתלתא בתשרי אתנטלת אדכרתא מן שטרא.
    Megillat Taʿanit On the third of Tishrei, the practice of including the divine name in contracts was abolished.

    The Parma version of the scholion explains:

    מגילת תענית סכוליון פ' אמרו חכמים ז"ל: אפשר שיכתב שם שמים בשטרות, נמנו עליהם וגנזום. יום שגנזום עשאוהו יום טוב.
    Megillat Taʿanit Scholion Parma The Sages of blessed memory said: “Is it fitting that the Name of Heaven be written on legal documents?” They voted and placed them in the genizah. They day they buried them, they made into a celebration.

    (See discussion in Noam, Megillat Taʿanit, 235.) Thus, the text forbids fasting on this date. Admittedly, the origin of fixing the Fast of Gedaliah on the third of Tishri is unclear, and it may have been on a different date. Karaites believe Gedaliah died on the 24th of the 7th month, and that this event is commemorated by the fast mentioned in Nehemiah 9:1.

  14. It is possible that the Festival of the Wood Offering was a continuation of the actions the people had been called upon to undertake in the prophecies of Haggai.

    חגי א:ח עֲלוּ הָהָר וַהֲבֵאתֶם עֵץ וּבְנוּ הַבָּיִת וְאֶרְצֶה בּוֹ (ואכבד) [וְאֶכָּבְדָה] אָמַר יְ־הֹוָה.
    Hag 1:8 Go up to the hills and get timber, and rebuild the House; then I will look on it with favor and I will be glorified—said YHWH.

    In this prophecy, which was intended to encourage the people to build the Temple despite the hardships, Haggai affirms that God desires this Temple.

  15. It may be that Rabbi Judah HaNasi’s leniency on the 17th of Tammuz was of a piece, and that he wished to cancel the whole set of fasts for the destruction of Jerusalem, but the text is focusing on Tisha B’Av since it is the most prominent of the four.