Moses and the Ten Commandments, Ohr Torah Synagogue, Acre. A. Teicher/Wikimedia
Uncovering Different Kinds of Torah Passages
Published: May 14, 2014
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Nachmanides wrote about this in his introduction to Genesis, Don Isaac Abarbanel discussed it extensively at the beginning of the book of Deuteronomy, and his contemporary, Rabbi Isaac b. Rabbi Joseph Karo, uncle of Rabbi Joseph Karo, discussed it in his book Toldot Yitzchak in several places.
Ran on the Rif, Megillah 11a, s.v. הללו משה מפי עצמו אמרן.
See also Eliyahu Rabba (Ish Shalom) parasha 7. And in Avot de-Rabbi Nathan,version1, chapter 1: “The Torah was given by Moses at Sinai, as it says: ‘He wrote them on two stone tablets and gave them to me’(Deuteronomy 5:19). And further on it says ‘The laws and statutes and teachings that the Lord gave between Him and the Israelites at Sinai by Moses’(Leviticus 26:46).”
Likewise Exodus Rabba (Shinan) Va’era 10. And it would be impossible not to cite the Babylonian Talmud, Menachot 29b, which describes Moses’ visit to Rabbi Akiva’s house of learning; the latter refers to a law that he is teaching, which Moses does not recognize or understand, as “law of Moses from Sinai,” and it is clear that this is not a historical description. See Shmuel Safrai, “‘Law of Moses from Sinai’ – History or Theology?” Mechkere Talmud 1 (5750): 11–38 [Hebrew]. In his treatment of the gemara, in Menachot, Safrai writes: “Moses does not understand even the very law that Rabbi Akiva calls ‘law of Moses from Sinai’ because Rabbi Akiva innovated in the law, and because they refer to words of Torah as ‘law of Moses from Sinai.’ This means that everything that is created and erected as a Jewish law has its origin in the law of Moses, and it is a continuation of the course of the Torah and law that was given to Moses at Sinai and spoken at Horeb…”
j. Kilayim 2:27; see also j. Terumot 2:41; j. Shabbat 1:3, 10:12; j. Nazir 7:56.
Rosh Tractate Niddah, “Laws of Ritual Baths,” §1; see also what he says further on.