Ten Commandments on stone tablets. 123rf
The Status of the Decalogue
Published: May 14, 2014
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
See Rabbi Nissim Gaon, Berakhot 12a; Rashi, Berakhot 12a; Sefer Abudirham, “Laws of Recitation of Shema.” See also the Tzelach (Tziyun le-Nefesh Chayah, by Yechezkel Landau) Berakhot 12a, s.v. שם למקבעינהו בנהרדעא וכו.
In modern scholarship, there is also a debate over the status of the Decalogue. Weinfeld claims that “among all the laws, only the list of commandments in the Decalogue is perceived as foundational and primary in the establishment of a connection between God and Israel. It was only the Decalogue that the Israelites merited hearing straight from the Deity’s mouth…” Moshe Weinfeld, “Uniqueness of the Decalogue and its Place in Jewish Tradition,” in The Decalogue in History and Tradition, ed. B. Z. Segal (Jerusalem: Magnes, c1990), 1–34 (Hebrew edition). Against this, Yair Hoffman claims that there are no explicit references to the Decalogue in the Bible except in three places, and that the supposed echoes of them are not conclusive; Y. Hoffman, “The Status of the Decalogue in the Hebrew Bible,” in H. G. Reventlow and Y. Hoffman (eds.), The Decalogue in Jewish and Christian Tradition (New York: T&T Clark, 2011) 32–49.