Joshua dividing the Land by Lot (colorized). Cassell's Illustrated Family Bible c. 1880
Dividing the Land by Lot: The Bible’s Postfacto Is Plato’s Utopia
In Plato’s Laws, the Athenian stranger proposes founding a future state by dividing land into equal plots among citizens, organized into twelve districts each dedicated to a specific god. The Bible also prescribes a lottery system for allocating land—both among tribes and family units—but never explains how such a lottery could function fairly given the unequal sizes of tribes and families. Why?
Published: July 15, 2025
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
For a detailed discussion of lot system in the Bible and Jewish interpretation, see Shraga Bar-On, הטלת גורל, אלהים ואדם במסורת היהדות: הן מקרא ועד שלהי הרנסונס [Lot Casting, God, and Man in Jewish Literature: From the Bible to the Renaissance], מחשבות [Mahshavot] (Bar Ilan University, 2020).
NJPS with adjustments.
If there are twelve tribes who will receive land, Gad and Reuben received in the Transjordan, Judah, Ephraim and Manasseh already received their land in chs. 15–17, this leaves seven tribes who have not yet received land allocations.
Translation by Trevor J. Saunders in Plato: Complete Works, ed. John M. Cooper and D. S. Hutchinson (Hackett, 1997), 1318–1616 [1425–1426]. For the significance of the lot and the different meanings it carried in ancient Greece, see Irad Malkin and Josine Blok, Drawing Lots: From Egalitarianism to Democracy in Ancient Greece (Oxford University Press, 2024). See especially chapter 6 for discussions on the founding of colonies and land distribution by lot.
Whether or not the biblical text depicts the historical reality is a different question, but certainly the Bible envisions tribes forming before they receive land. For some discussion of tribal formation in ancient Israel and the Bible, see Andrew Tobolowsky, The Sons of Jacob and the Sons of Herakles: The History of the Tribal System and the Organization of Biblical Identity, FAT 2 (Mohr Siebeck, 2017).
Plato too is speaking of lots for family units, but for Plato, tribes are merely the sum total of whatever family units are given land in a particular district.
See discussion in, Michael Fishbane, Biblical Interpretation in Ancient Israel, Oxford 1988, 184-185, 197-199; David Frankel, The Murmuring Stories of the Priestly School (Leiden: Brill, 2002), 258-260; Emanuel Tov, “Glosses, Interpolations, and Other Types of Scribal Additions in the Text of the Hebrew Bible,” in Language, Theology, and the Bible: Essays in Honour of James Barr (ed. S.E. Balentine & J. Barton; Oxford: Clarendon, 1994), 40-66 [Revised version: The Greek and Hebrew Bible (1999), 53-74]. For some other examples, see Zev Farber, “Elazar Speaks Once in the Torah: Why Does He Interrupt Moses?” TheTorah (2017), dealing with Numbers 31:22; idem, “The Origins of Sukkot,” TheTorah (2017) and Lisbeth S. Fried, “Sukkot in Ezra-Nehemiah and the Date of the Torah,” TheTorah (2015), both dealing with Leviticus 23:39.
The text is part of a larger work known as the מגילת הסרכים, Manual of Discipline or Rule Scroll. The “Two Spirits” section offers a symbolic interpretation of the land inheritance passages in general. For some basic discussions of this text, see John R. Levison, “The Two Spirits in Qumran Theology,” in The Bible and the Dead Sea Scrolls: The Princeton Symposium on the Dead Sea Scrolls, ed. James H. Charlesworth; (Baylor University Press, 2006), 2.169–194; Mladen Popović, “Anthropology, Pneumatology, and Demonology in Early Judaism: The Two Spirits Treatise (1QS 3:13–4:26) and Other Texts from the Dead Sea Scrolls,” in Sibyls, Scriptures, and Scrolls: John Collins at Seventy, ed. Joel Baden, Hindy Najman, Eibert J. C. Tigchelaar; JSJSup 175 (Brill, 2016), 1029–1067.
Hebrew text is from Elisha Qimron, מגילות מדבר יהודה: החיבורים העבריים [Dead Sea Scrolls: The Hebrew Writings] (Yad Ben Zvi, 2010) 1.216.