Guests at a Banquet, Nina de Garis Davies 1920–21; original ca. 1390–1349 B.C. Met Museum
Egyptians Would Not Dine with Hebrews... or Cow-Eating Greeks
The Greek historian Herodotus, who visited Egypt in the 5th century B.C.E., reports that Egyptians would not kiss a Greek on the mouth or use any of their food implements—knife, fork, or pot—because Greeks ate cows, which Egyptians regarded as sacred. This background sheds light on the biblical account of Egyptians refusing to eat with Joseph’s brothers—or even with Joseph himself.
Published: December 18, 2025
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Dis-moi ce que tu manges, et je te dirai ce que tu es.
One wonders what family meals were like in the household of Joseph, Asenath, Menasseh and Ephraim.
See Patricia Crone, Pre-Industrial Societies – Anatomy of the Pre-Modern World, on Kindle, location 1287.
See Genesis Rabbah §86, Rashi (ad loc.)
For an extended discussion of the meanings of the term “Hebrew” in its various instances in the Bible see Yitzhaq Feder, “Don’t Call me Hebrew! The Mysterious Origins of the First Anti-Semitic Slur,” TheTorah (2015); Albert D. Friedberg, “Who Were the Hebrews?” TheTorah (2017).
On a parallel track in the Torah, Joseph’s brothers were called abhorrent to Egyptians because they were “shepherds.” This was one reason Joseph wanted them settled in Goshen, where presumably they would be safer; see Gen. 46:34.These two ways of identifying the members of Jacob’s family overlap in this case. Both were reasons to be despised by Egyptians, but they were not necessarily identical. Not every “shepherd” was a “Hebrew,” nor vice versa.
The German original reads: “Josef speiste auch nicht mit den Mizrim. Er hat also selbst als Fürst seine ibrische Herkunft nicht verleugnet.”
I elaborate here on some of the issues discussed by Jan Assmann and Zev Farber, “Shepherds and Eating with Hebrews: An Abomination to the Egyptians?” TheTorah (2016).
Jan Assmann, The Mind of Egypt: History and Meaning in the Time of the Pharaohs (tr. A Jenkins; New York: Metropolitan Books, 2002), 395.
While the practices Herodotus reported have been characterized by contemporary Egyptologists as fantastic, Herodotus’ account was probably not totally inaccurate, see Assmann, Mind of Egypt, 394.
Contrary to Ibn Ezra, Egyptians were certainly not vegetarians, similar to the people of India, who are the majority of the inhabitant on earth, according to Ibn Ezra (on Exod. 8:22).
She is one of Zeus’ mortal lovers.
Herodotus, The History, trans. David Grene (University of Chicago Press, 1987), 148.
See Wis 11:15 and Philo, De Vita Contemplativa, 8-9.
This need to distinguish himself from those who ate Special Kosher A from those of B is a classic example of what Freud called the “Narcissism of Small Differences,” or what I have called the “Rule of the Martian.” Precisely because these two groups look so similar to an outsider the need to say I am not B but A is so dominant.
Louis Dumont, Homo Hierarchicus: The Caste System and its Implications. Complete Revised English Edition, trans. Mark Sainsbury, Louis Dumont, and Basia Gulati (University of Chicago Press, 1980), 86-87, supplied two elaborate charts, one of castes and sub-castes who accept or refuse cooked food from each other and another of the castes and subcastes that will share a pipe.
Claude Levi-Strauss, The Raw and the Cooked, Mythologiues, trans. John and Doreen Weightman (University of Chicago Press, 1969), 1.142, 164. In my study of ancient Jewish sectarianism, I have explored the implications of this idea for the food rules of ancient Jewish groups. See Albert Baumgarten, “A Sectarian’s Food and its Implications,” Self, Soul and Body in Religious Experience, ed. Albert Baumgarten, Jan Assmann, and Guy Stroumsa; Studies in the History of Religion, 78 (Brill, 1998), 125-147. Ancient Jewish sectarians took the rules that applied to the food of non-Jews and applied them to the food of Jews with whom they disagreed, much like the El-Al passenger above.
The New Testament ascribes this practice to James and Peter, as opposed to Paul, who argues for the right of Jewish believers in Jesus to eat together with their gentile fellow believers. See discussion in, David M. Freidenreich, “Food and Table Fellowship,” The Jewish Annotated New Testament, 2nd ed., ed. Amy-Jill Levine and Marc Z. Brettler (Oxford University Press, 2017), 650–653.
See discussion in Shirly Ben-Dor Evian, “Was the Joseph Story Written in Egypt During the Persian Period?” TheTorah (2017).