I Changed My Mind

Symposium

I Changed My Mind

When I Stopped Seeing the Bible Only as Good, It Got Better

SBL Style

Click to copy

"When I Stopped Seeing the Bible Only as Good, It Got Better." TheTorah.com, August 27, 2026. https://www.thetorah.com/article/when-i-stopped-seeing-the-bible-only-as-good-it-got-better.

APA Style

Click to copy

"When I Stopped Seeing the Bible Only as Good, It Got Better" (2026, August 27). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/when-i-stopped-seeing-the-bible-only-as-good-it-got-better

Published: August 27, 2026

|

Last Updated: October 29, 2026

  1. Think of the not so implicit debate between Isaiah and Ezra/Nehemiah about how we esteem those living among us.

  2. The US Constitution lives because of the process of amendment, and the Court’s power to authoritatively interpret the current application of the law, even if that interpretation is unprecedented or overturns precedent. So too Torah law and halakhah.

  3. Editor’s note: For other discussions, see Shawna Dolansky, “Regarding Azazel and Homosexuals in the Same Parasha,” TheTorah (2015); David Frankel, “Male Homosexual Intercourse Is Prohibited – In One Part of the Torah,” TheTorah (2017); Isaac S.D. Sassoon, “What Does Deuteronomy Say about Homosexuality?” TheTorah (2017); Idan Dershowitz, “How the Prohibition of Male Homosexual Intercourse Altered the Laws of Incest,” TheTorah (2018).

  4. My involvement developed in stages, beginning with “Judaism and Homosexuality,” Tikkun 3.2 (1988): 52–54, 92–93; followed by a longer treatment in “Gay and Lesbian Jews: An Innovative Jewish Legal Position,” Jewish Spectator 55.3 (Winter 1990–1991): 6–14; and finally, “Enfranchising the Monogamous Homosexual: A Legal Possibility, a Moral Imperative,” submitted to the Committee on Jewish Law and Standards in 1991 (but not adopted).

  5. The prohibition of male/male homosexual acts (Leviticus 18: 22, Leviticus 20:13) labels male/male sex a “to’evah/abomination,” insisting one must not lie with a male “as with a woman.” I wrote that a modern posek (legal interpreter) is facing a devar chadash with contemporary homosexuality as an orientation. I delved deeply into ancient sexual practices, discovering that in Egypt, Greece, Rome, Babylon, male sex always involved the imposition of power: often coercive (master/slave, father/children, soldier/prisoner). Today those instances would all be categorized as rape, and the Torah was prohibiting what it knew: situational, power driven sex acts; it knew nothing of the possibility of gay/lesbian love and commitment. So I ruled that contemporary possibility more analogous to love and marriage than to rape or child rape. On that basis, I permitted marriage and ordination, and we have been the beneficiary of new rabbinic wisdom that such diversity always makes possible.

  6. Another example is the Akedah (“binding of Isaac”) is a deeply troubling story, in which God demands a loving father to murder his innocent son. The holiday liturgy forces a confrontation with it anew each year at Judaism’s most holy time, so I made that the specific theme of a Yamim Noraim sermon each year, each year offering a novel (for me) take on this troubling story. It is compiled in my book Passing Life’s Tests: Spiritual Reflections on The Trial of Abraham, the Binding of Isaac (Jewish Lights, 2013). My favorite portrays the entire episode from Sarah’s perspective, in which she flat out refused the Divine command as unjust and unworthy of God!