Cairo Genizah and the Study of Midrash

Symposium

Cairo Genizah and the Study of Midrash

Is Elijah Pinchas?

Elijah the prophet is immortal, and Pinchas appears in a story long after the wilderness period. Both figures are described as zealots, leading to their identification as the same person by Pseudo-Philo (ca. 1st cent. C.E.) and later midrash. In a heated exchange preserved in a 13th-century fragment from the Cairo Genizah, two cantors and a congregant debate the rationality of this identification.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Is Elijah Pinchas?." TheTorah.com, July 20, 2016. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-elijah-pinchas.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Is Elijah Pinchas?" (2016, July 20). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-elijah-pinchas

Is Elijah Pinchas?

Pinchas with a halberd in his hand, Johann Sadeler,1577 (adapted). Rijksmuseum

Categories:

Pinchas

Published: July 20, 2016

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. Much of this article is based on, Moshe Lavee, “Literary Canonization at Work: The Authority of Aggadic Midrash and the Evolution of Havdalah Poetry in the Genizah” AJS Review 37.2 (2013): 285-313. We would like to thank Shana Strauch-Schick for help in translating and editing this article.

  2. Although the verse seems to identify the name of his hometown as Toshab (Tishbite = from Toshab), no such city is known to have existed in Gilead. Some scholars believe that the word is a corruption of the name Yabesh, with a metathesis of the letters ב and ש, and the addition of the ת, all influenced by the next word (תשבי). If so, Elijah’s hometown would be the famous city of Yabesh Gilead.

  3. Translation follows: Howard Jacobson, “Pseudo-Philo: Book of Biblical Antiquities,” inOutside the Bible: Ancient Jewish Writings Related to Scripture (eds., Louis H. Feldman, James L. Kugel, and Lawrence H. Schiffman; Philadelphia: JPS, 2013), 470-613 [580-581].

  4. For surveys of the views concerning the identification of Elijah and Phineas see Louis Ginzburg, The Legend of the Jews IV (Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society in America, 1954): 195-97 and n. 3 in vol. VI :316 – 317; Theodor’s comments to Bereshit rabba71:9 to Genesis 30:11 (ed. Albeck): 833 – 835; Seder ’Eliyahu Rabba (ed. Friedman): 2–11; Louis H. Feldman, “The Portrayal of Phinehas by Philo, Pseudo-Philo, and Josephus,” JQR92 (2002): 315–45; R. Hayward, “Phinehas-The Same as Elijah: The Origins of a Rabbinic Tradition,” JJS 29 (1978): 22-34. As noted above, the account of Phineas in Pseudo-Philo (Bib. Ant. 48:1-2) is filled with allusions to Elijah’s ministry, making this our oldest source containing the Phineas-Elijah complex. Another possible allusion to the Pinchas-Elijah identification is in the choice of 1 Kings 18:46-19:21 as the Haftarah for Parashat Pinchas. In rabbinic sources, the explicit identification is found in Targum Pseudo-Yonatan to Exod 6:18; and appears in later midrashim, including a text of Yelamdenu only preserved in later midrashic collections: Yalqut Shimoni, Pinchas 771 (ed. Heiman): 512; Midrash Hagadol (ed. Rabinovitch): 450 – 451; Midrash Aggadah, Numbers 25:13, (ed. Buber): v. 2, 148. It is also found in another genizah fragment of Midrash Tehilim, T-S Or.1080 13.2 published by S. A. Wertheimer, Batey Midrashot, (Jerusalem: Mosad ha-rav Kook, 1989): v.1, 296. See also Seeb. Bava Mesia’ 114a-b; Midrash Mishley 9:2, (ed. Wisotzky): 68.

  5. See Lavee, Canonization, p. 295, n.22.

  6. See, James L. Kugel, The Bible as It Was (Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press, 1997), 497-500.

  7. Num 25:7-8, 16th benefit (תועלת):

    והנה מצאנו לו מאורך החיים שכבר היה חי בימי פלגש בגבעה; אמר: ‘ופינחס בן אלעזר בן אהרן עֹמד לפניו בימים ההם (שופטים כ:כח). גם היה חי בימי דוד; אמר: ‘ופינחס בן אלעזר נגיד היה עליהם לפנים ה’ עמו’ (דהי”א ט:כ). והנה אמרו רבותינו ז”ל שעדיין הוא חי, ויחיה עד תחיית המתים; ולזה הסכימו שפינחס זה אליהו, כי נמצא לו אורך חיים נפלא, כמו שאמר מלאכי: ‘הנה אנכי שׂלח לכם את אליה הנביא וגו” (מלאכי ג:כג). והנראה בעינינו שהענין הוא כן, כמו שנזכור הטעם בביאור מלכים בגזרת ה’.

    1 Chronicles 9:23

    ואחשוב כי פנחס האריך ימים מאד כי ברית ה’ יתברך היתה אתו החיים והשלום בקנאו קנאת ה’ יתברך על דבר פעור . והנה היה נגיד זמן מה על זה המנוי והיה זה בימי דוד שנבררו אז המשמרות . והנה היה פינחס כהן גדול בימי פילגש בגבעה . וכבר זכרנו בספר שופטים ובספר מלכים מה שיעיד על אורך חייו . ולזה אמר לפנים ה’ עמו לפי שהוא היה מזמן קדום מאד כי בצאת ישראל ממצרים היה נולד פינחס לפי הנראה בפרשת וארא :

  8. Ralbag uses the Hebrew term “זרות” which is probably based on the same concept found in the Guide of the Perplexed (2:29) in the Hebrew Medieval translation of Ibn Tibon. Shlomo Pines translates the term in the Guide as “strange” but we prefer “peculiar” which seems closer to what Ralbag is trying to express.

  9. See also, Tanhuma, Ki Tisa 13; Seder Eliyahu Rabba 18 (ed. Friedman): 96 – 97; Tosfot, Bava Mesia’ 114a-b, s.v. “Mahu She-Yesadru”; see also Seder Eliyahu Zuta 15 (ed. Friedman): 199, also quoted in Yalqut Shimoni Nizavim 940.

  10. The word רעש is being understood as the term behind the name יערישיה, although etymologically speaking, they aren’t the same root; the root in the name is ע-ר-ש; same letters but a different order with a different meaning.

  11. The Tosafot on Baba Metzia 114b (s.v. mahu); Hadar Zekenim (a collection of the Tosafot’s comments on the Torah), Vayetzei 30:11; Tosafot HaRosh Bava Metzia 114b (s.v. “qivrei nachrim”); Rosh Bava Metzia 9:47.

  12. For more on the Cairo Genizah in the context of midrash studies, see Moshe Lavee and Shana Strauch-Schick, “The Cairo Genizah and Its Contribution to the Study of Midrash Aggada” TheTorah (2015).

  13. For a full transcription of the Judeo-Arabic fragment with translation to Hebrew and discussion see, Moshe Lavee and Moshe Gan-Zvi, “From France to Fustat: The Influence of Cultural Emigration on the Role of Aggadic Midrash and Piyyut in the Debate Surrounding the Prophet Elijah’s identity,” Pe’amim 139-140 (5774): 109-154 [Hebrew].

  14. Davidson, ’ozar ha-shira ve-hapiyut, (New York: JTS, 1924-1933), aleph, 5000. The title of the poem comes from a description of Elijah given by the people to Ahaziah king of Israel:

    מלכים ב א:ח וַיֹּאמְר֣וּ אֵלָ֗יו אִ֚ישׁ בַּ֣עַל שֵׂעָ֔ר וְאֵז֥וֹר ע֖וֹר אָז֣וּר בְּמָתְנָ֑יו וַיֹּאמַ֕ר אֵלִיָּ֥ה הַתִּשְׁבִּ֖י הֽוּא:
    2 Kgs 1:8 “A hairy man,” they replied, “with a leather girdle girt around his loins.” “That’s Elijah the Tishbite!” he (Ahaziah) said.
  15. This is meant as an intertextual reference to Numbers 25, which describes Pinchas, grandson of Aharon:

    במדבר כה:ז וַיַּרְא פִּינְחָס בֶּן אֶלְעָזָר בֶּן אַהֲרֹן הַכֹּהֵן וַיָּקָם מִתּוֹךְ הָעֵדָה וַיִּקַּח רֹמַח בְּיָדוֹ: כה:ח וַיָּבֹא אַחַר אִישׁ יִשְׂרָאֵל אֶל הַקֻּבָּה וַיִּדְקֹר אֶת שְׁנֵיהֶם אֵת אִישׁ יִשְׂרָאֵל וְאֶת הָאִשָּׁה אֶל קֳבָתָהּ…
    Num 25:7 When Pinchas, son of Elazar son of Aaron the priest, saw this, he left the assembly and, taking a spear in his hand, 25:8 he followed the Israelite into the chamber and stabbed both of them, the Israelite and the woman, through the belly.
  16. From the piyyut יה חזקי, aleph, 819, in: Davidson, ’ozar ha-shira ve-hapiyut, (New York: JTS, 1924 – 1933).

  17. דברי הימים א ח:כו וְשַׁמְשְׁרַ֥י וּשְׁחַרְיָ֖ה וַעֲתַלְיָֽה: ח:כז וְיַעֲרֶשְׁיָ֧ה וְאֵלִיָּ֛ה וְזִכְרִ֖י בְּנֵ֥י יְרֹחָֽם:
    1 Chron 8:26 Shamsherai, Shehariah, Athaliah, 8:27 Jaareshiah, Elijah, and Zichri were the sons of Yeroham.
  18. He doesn’t say why, but we note that the verse never says that this Elijah is the same one as from the stories in Kings. Alternatively, it may be that the interlocutor gives primacy to rabbinic material over biblical traditions.

  19. This is also shown later in the fragment. See ibid, p. 294.

  20. Lavee, “Canonization,” 290 – 294 (and p. 293 n. 21).

  21. This piyyut is likely of French or Provencal origin, since, except for its partial quotation in our fragment, it is only known from manuscripts of Mahzor Vitry (#209) and from a quote of R. Tam, by R. Samson of Sans (See Bezalel Ashkenazi, Shitah Mekubetzet BM 114b (Jerusalem: 1952), p 458.

  22. For more on this view of Elijah, and how it derives from the ending of Malachi, see Wendy Zierler, “Can Elijah Reconcile Fathers and Sons?” TheTorah (2016).

  23. This despite the fact that when Elijah announces his power to bring rain in 1 Kings 17:1, it was as part of his declaring a drought.

  24. This is a reference to Elijah being Pinchas.

  25. The term comes from Mal 3:1 and is being understood here as a reference to Elijah, who is mentioned at the end of the chapter.