Is Illness a Divine Punishment?

“I YHWH am your healer”—Exodus 15:26

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Is Illness a Divine Punishment?." TheTorah.com, March 13, 2025. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-illness-a-divine-punishment.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Is Illness a Divine Punishment?" (2025, March 13). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/is-illness-a-divine-punishment

Is Illness a Divine Punishment?

By the sick sister, Maurycy Minkowski 1905. Desa Unicom

Categories:

Ki Tisa

Published: March 13, 2025

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Rita Charon, Narrative Medicine: Honoring the Stories of Illness (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2006), 66. Charon’s work built on the research of doctors and sociologists, among others, conducted during the 1980s and 90s.

  2. For a detailed discussion, see the work of anthropologist Arthur Kleinman, The Illness Narratives: Suffering, Healing, and the Human Condition (New York: Basic Books, 1988); and sociologist Arthur Frank, The Wounded Storyteller: Body, Illness, and Ethics (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1995).

  3. See e.g. David Morris, The Culture of Pain (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1991), 19; and Katherine Southwood, “Metaphor, Illness, and Identity”; “The ‘Innards’ in the Psalms and Job as Metaphors for Illness,” HBT 42 (2020): 159–185 (p. 230).

  4. See e.g. Susan Sontag, Illness as Metaphor and AIDS and Its Metaphors (London: Picador, 2001), 59; Southwood, “Metaphor, Illness, and Identity,” 229–231. The best example of this thinking in the Bible is represented by Job’s friends in the book of Job, but it can also be found in the book of Proverbs and the Deuteronomistic and Chronistic Histories, among other texts.

  5. Editor’s note: For additional interpretations of the golden calf narrative, see Rami Arav, “The Golden Calf: Bull-El Worship,” TheTorah (2022); Joel Baden, “What Was the Sin of the Golden Calf?” TheTorah (2017); and Gili Kugler, “The Decalogue’s Opening Laws, Written in Response to the Golden Calf,” TheTorah (2022).

  6. Biblical translations follow NJPS, with modifications.

  7. See, e.g., Martin Noth, Das zweite Buch Mose: Exodus, ATD 5 (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1959), 207; and the English translation, Martin Noth, Exodus: A Commentary, trans. J. S. Bowden, OTL (Philadelphia: Westminster, 1962), 251.

  8. See also Exodus 21:22.

  9. See Exodus 7:27. The verb is also used in association with the plagues on Egypt elsewhere in the Bible, e.g. Joshua 24:5; Isaiah 19:22.

  10. See, e.g., 1 Samuel 12:15; 25:38; 26:10; Zechariah 14:12; Psalm 89:23; 2 Chronicles 13:20; 21:18.

  11. William H.C. Propp, Exodus 19–40: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (New York: Doubleday, 2006), 541, 565. Similarly, John I. Durham, Exodus (Waco: Word Books, 1987), 433, concludes: “At the end of chap. 32, we have no answers, only questions.” Propp (Exodus 19–40, 565) does align with Noth, however, regarding the threat in verse 34: “One could (and I would) take this as a threat for the distant future, when the Assyrians will deport the calf-worshipping Northern Kingdom in 722/21 B.C.E.”

  12. Elaine Scarry, The Body in Pain: The Making and Unmaking of the World (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1985), 13, 15–16. In the context of this metaphor, the hammer is wielded against the body not as a tool, but as a weapon.

  13. Scarry, The Body in Pain, 220.

  14. Scarry, The Body in Pain, 220.

  15. Some commentators (e.g. Noth, Das zweite Buch Mose, 205; Nahum Sarna, The JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus [Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1991], 210) have suggested that the drinking of the ground up statue mixed with water was a ritual to identify the guilty parties, like in the ritual of the woman suspected of adultery in Numbers 5:11–31. But most see it primarily as a way to irreversibly destroy the divine statue, noting the similarity between what Moses does to the golden calf and what the goddess Anat does to the body of the defeated god Mot in Ugaritic mythology, including the sequence of burning, grinding, and scattering the fallen deity (e.g. Brevard S. Childs, The Book of Exodus: A Critical, Theological Commentary [Philadelphia: Westminster Press, 1974], 569; Durham, Exodus, 431; Propp, Exodus 19–40, 560). This act ensured that the calf statue could never be reconstituted: Even if the gold powder could be recovered, it would be from excrement and the dead bodies of the 3,000 slain by the Levites, rendering it impure. See Propp, Exodus 19–40, 560, who notes Ramban’s (R. Moses ben Nahman, 1194–1270) comment that the gold would be passed in the Israelites’ excrement (ad loc.).

  16. Scarry, The Body in Pain, 209.

  17. Scarry (The Body in Pain, 209, 360) argues that this is a scene repeated again and again in the Bible, for example in the condemnations of idol worship and resulting punishments in Hosea 14:1 and Jeremiah 13:22–27.

  18. The idea is not necessarily uplifting, but it could explain why idol-worship is frequently the sin that bears the most severe punishment in the Bible—something that is difficult to justify by the standards of modern morality. It can often seem that YHWH is acting self-interestedly, preserving the exclusivity of his people’s devotion at the expense of all who suffer the painful effects of his punishment—including, presumably, innocent community members such as children. See e.g. Ronald E. Clements, “Prophecy, Ethics, and the Divine Anger,” in Ethical and Unethical in the Old Testament: God and Humans in Dialogue, ed. Katharine J. Dell (London: T&T Clark, 2010), 88–102 [pp. 90–91].

  19. Portier-Young (The Prophetic Body, 16–29) has recently published a thorough analysis of how the western (Christian) privileging of words, mind, reason, and related concepts over bodies and materiality has historically skewed biblical scholarship in ways that are not native to these texts.

  20. See, e.g., Benjamin D. Sommer, The Bodies of God and the World of Ancient Israel (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009), 4–5; Yosefa Raz, “Reading Pain in the Book of Job,” in The Book of Job: Aesthetics, Ethics, Hermeneutics, ed. Leora Batnitzky and Ilana Pardes (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2015), 77–97 [pp. 81–83]. See also Francesca Stavrakopoulou, God: An Anatomy (New York: Knopf, 2022).

  21. See Annette Schellenberg, “More Than Spirit: On the Physical Dimension in the Priestly Understanding of Holiness,” Zeitschrift fur die alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 126.2 (2014): 163–179 [p. 178].

  22. Additional forms of divine manifestation include, e.g., thunder, lightning, smoke, and earthquake (Exod 19:16–19).

  23. For fire imagery, see also, e.g. Exodus 3:2; 13:22; 14:24; 24:17; for cloud imagery, see, e.g. Exodus 13:22; 14:24; 19:16; 24:18; 40:34–38.

  24. Editor’s note: On God’s name and presence in Deuteronomy, see Michael Carasik, “In the Presence of God,” TheTorah (2015).

  25. The כָּבוֹד also appears in, e.g. Exodus 24:17; 29:43: 33:18, 22; 40:34–35. Additional manifestations of YHWH occur through His name (e.g. Exod 20:24; 33:19; 34:5, 14) and His angel (e.g. Exod 23:20; 32:34; 33:2–5). YHWH is also made manifest in indirect ways. Moses functions as His earthly representative. For example, Moses’ reactions to the Israelites’ behavior in the golden calf story—his nose burns and he uses fire as a form of destruction (32:19–20)—mirror YHWH’s actions earlier in the narrative (v. 10). See Durham, Exodus, 430. And after he sees part of YHWH’s body, Moses’ frighteningly shiny face functions as a constant physical reminder of his role as the mediator of the divine presence (34:29–35). See Rhiannon Graybill, Are We Not Men? Unstable Masculinity in the Hebrew Prophets (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2016), 32; and Anathea E. Portier-Young, The Prophetic Body: Embodiment and Mediation in Biblical Prophetic Literature (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2024), 103–104. The tabernacle, constructed in Exodus (chs. 35–40), also becomes a visible manifestation of YHWH’s presence.

  26. Scarry (The Body in Pain, 204, 206–207) notes a few of these, but misses many others.

  27. The rabbis viewed the Song of Songs as an allegory for the relationship between YHWH and Israel, with Israel represented by the female lover.

  28. Text and translation, with modifications, from Sefaria. See also Brevard S. Childs, The Book of Exodus, 575.

  29. The rabbis here use the shared root פ.ר.ע, “to loose, open,” to connect the description of the Israelites worshipping the calf to Leviticus’ requirement that lepers leave their heads uncovered during the period of their uncleanness.

  30. E.g. Erik Raymond, “Is the Pandemic Punishment?” The Gospel Coalition (TCG), 6 April 2020.

  31. Editor’s note: See Edward L. Greenstein, “Speaking Truth to Power, Job Accuses God of Being Unjust,” TheTorah (2020).

  32. On this function of modern illness narratives, see Charon, Narrative Medicine, 9, 56. In a medical context, since the narratives are formed out of the specific experiences of a single, embodied individual, they do not claim to be universal or didactic.