Collecting the Manna (adapted), after print by: Claude Mellan, in or after 1640. Rijksmuseum.nl
A Testy YHWH
YHWH continuously tests Israel in the wilderness with water, manna, and quail. When they fail, YHWH threatens to leave them and then punishes them with fire and plague. J's depiction of YHWH as an emotional deity is already reflected in the stories of Eden and the flood.
Published: June 13, 2023
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
Bdellium is a hardened pale-brown tree resin.
Compare the cognate term in Old Babylonian, lišdu “cream” (Chicago Assyrian Dictionary, vol. L, 215).
Reinhard Achenbach (Die Vollendung der Tora: Studien zur Redaktionsgeschichte des Numeribuches im Kontext von Hexateuch und Pentateuch, Beihefte zur Zeitschrift für Altorientalische und Biblische Rechtsgeschichte 3 [Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz, 2003], 226–227) argues that, given the earlier description of manna in Exodus, the description here must be a later supplement. This ignores how different the description is here, and its literary use in highlighting the ungratefulness of the people.
Noth does think that some verses from J were moved into Exodus from their original spot and merged with the P story. He makes this suggestion tentatively in, Martin Noth, A History of Pentateuchal Traditions, trans. Bernhard W. Anderson (Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall, 1972), 31 [n. 110]; trans. of Überlieferungsgeschichte des Pentateuch (Stuttgart: W. Kohlhammer Verlag, 1948). For his discussion of the manna stories as J and P doublets, see Martin Noth, Exodus: A Commentary, trans. John S. Bowden, Old Testament Library (S.C.M. Press, 1962), 131–137; trans. of Das zweite Buch Moses, Exodus, Das Alte Testament Deutsch 5 (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1959). See also, Anthony F. Campbell and Mark A. O’Brian, Sources of the Pentateuch: Texts, Introductions, Annotations (Minneapolis, MN: Augsburg Fortress Press, 1993), 41–43, 144 [n 127], 150–152.
See Richard Elliott Friedman, The Bible with Sources Revealed (HarperSanFrancisco, 2003), 146–148, 258–260. While critics generally agree that much of Exodus 16 is from P, Joel Baden has recently argued for a revival of the classical view that these portions are not in their original place. See Joel Baden, “The Original Place of the Priestly Manna Story in Exodus 16,” Zeitschrift für die alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 122 (2010): 491–504; idem., “The Structure and Substance of Numbers 15,” Vetus Testamentum 63 (2013): 351–367. For a recent defense of the canonical order, see Graham Davies, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on Exodus 1–18, 2 vols., International Critical Commentary (London: T&T Clark, 2019), 2:434.
David Ben-Gad HaCohen (“Finding the Source of Water in Marah” [TheTorah 2015]) has a different source division here, with the Marah story as a combination of E and P, with no J at all. In his reading, the J water story is in Exodus 17.
Most commentators assume the entity being put to the test here is Israel, which grammatically speaking can also be referred to in the third person masculine singular. Nevertheless, Moses is the subject of the earlier part of the verse, implying that this too should refer to him.
Verse 27, describing Israel’s stay in the Elim oasis, is a Priestly text.
The J story is much shorter than the P version into which it was spliced.
Many scholars believe v. 35b to also form part of J, since it is a doublet with v. 35a (a Priestly verse).
Some scholars see this as a doublet, but I believe it works as part of J’s storyline.
This phrase, which comes out of the blue, seems to be the addition of the redactor. Alternatively, it could have read הצור הֶחָרֵב “the dry rock”—rocks are generally dry of course, but the text wants to emphasize a desert scene with no water in sight. The redactor then changed the preposition to bring Horeb into the story.
In P, Aaron stretches out his arm holding his own staff. For a source division of this plague, see Marc Zvi Brettler, “Source Criticism: It’s in the (Plague of) Blood,” TheTorah (2015).
At this point in J, came the scene in which Moses gathers the Levites and they kill the offending Israelites. This scene is now included as part of the Golden Calf account in Exodus 32. For a detailed argument supporting this reconstruction, see Joel E. Baden, “The Violent Origins of the Levites: Text and Tradition,” in Levites and Priests in Biblical History and Tradition, ed. Mark A. Leuchter and Jeremy M. Hutton (Atlanta, GA: SBL, 2012), 103–116.
In J’s storyline, after the Israelites quarrel at Massah and Meribah, YHWH informs Moses that he will appear to them at Mount Sinai (Exod 19:10–11). In J, as is also the case in the canonical text, מזה “from here,” in Exodus 33:1 is Sinai.
Verse 2 is from E, though the reference to an angel seems to be redactional.
At this point in the J text, a small portion of what is now the opening verses of Exodus 18 likely appeared, which helps bridge the gap in the narrative.
In an earlier publication, I attributed this brief story to E. See, Philip Yoo, “The Absence of Wisdom in the Wilderness” in Perspectives on Israelite Wisdom: Proceedings of the Oxford Old Testament Seminar, ed. John Jarick, Library of Hebrew Bible/Old Testament Studies 618 (London: T&T Clark, 2015), 352–374 [p. 360]. Jeffery Stackert argues that E’s original sequence is as follows: after Moses descends Mount Horeb he pitches a tent outside the encampment (Exod 34:29, [transposed] 33:6b–11) and then complains to YHWH (Num 11:11–12, 14–15); see A Prophet Like Moses: Prophecy, Law, and Israelite Religion (New York: Oxford University Press, 2014), 82–92. In keeping with this, I now believe that the story in Num 11:1–3 is from J.
For the source division of this chapter between J and E, see Joel Baden, Composition of the Pentateuch: Renewing the Documentary Hypothesis, The Anchor Yale Bible Reference Library (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2012), 82–102. See also, Benjamin Sommer, “Reflecting on Moses: The Redaction of Numbers 11,” Journal of Biblical Literature 118 (1999): 601–624. In this piece, we will discuss only the J source. For a discussion of the purpose and function of the E storyline, see Stackert, A Prophet Like Moses, 92–107.
Editor’s note: For a discussion of this term and the related erev rav in Exodus 12:38, see David J. Zucker, “Erev Rav: A Mixed Multitude of Meanings,” TheTorah (2020).
David Frankel (“Were the Israelites Craving for Meat or Starving for Food?” TheTorah [2017]) argues that this story originally had no connection to manna, and that they were complaining about the lack of food. In his reading, vv.6b–9 are a later supplement.
An attempt to read the different descriptions of the manna’s taste appears in Midrash Rabbah:
שמות רבה כה:ג כתוב אחד אומר הנני ממטיר לכם לחם מן השמים וכתוב אחד אומר וטעמו כצפיחת בדבש ואומר והיה טעמו כטעם לשד השמן כיצד מתקימין שלשה כתובין הללו בחורים היה טועמין טעם לחם זקנים טעם דבש תינוקות טעם שמן
Exodus Rabbah 25:3 One verse says, “Behold, I will rain bread from heaven for you” [Exod 16:4]. One [other] verse says, “Its taste was like wafers in honey” [v. 31]. And [another verse] says, “Its taste was like the taste of an oily cake” [Num 11:8]. How do you place these three verses? The young tasted the taste of bread, the old the taste of honey, and the babies the taste of oil.
The ingratitude here is so stark that it has led some scholars to posit that the author of this story lacks the tradition of slavery in Egypt. See Gili Kugler, “The Israelites Were Sojourners in Egypt and Life Wasn’t So Bad,” TheTorah (2023).
The phrase here does double-duty, as it introduces Moses’ comments in the J story as well as in the E story. When redacting multiple stories into one, the complier generally deleted the doubled language. See Baden, Composition of the Pentateuch, 88. Formulaic introductions to quotes are an obvious example of doubled language that needs to be cut, but the same approach was taken for birth and death notices, among other things—people can be born and die only once. For an example of this, see David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “The Unknown Yet Known Place of Moses’ Burial,” TheTorah (2015).
Here again, the compiler used one formulaic introduction to introduce YHWH’s now combined speech, which was originally two different speeches. In doing so, the compiler also added the copulative ו “and” here, to connect the otherwise unrelated speeches.
This appears earlier in J's Sinai pericope. In J’s own linguistic profile ק.ד.ש [HtD-stem] may be closer to the sense of encountering God.
They do say this earlier, in Exodus 14:11–12, in the story of the escape by the sea. Similarly, later, after the Israelites hear the scouts’ false report, they are closest to an insurrection and a return to Egypt when they declare: נִתְּנָה רֹאשׁ וְנָשׁוּבָה מִצְרָיְמָה, “Let us set a leader and let us return to Egypt” (Num 14:4; my translation); see Philip Yoo, Ezra and the Second Wilderness, OTRM (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2017), 58. (The Israelites also say this in Numbers 20:5, but this is an E story.)
Jacob Milgrom, Numbers, JPS Commentary (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1989), 88, may be correct that the second part of YHWH’s quotation is a summary of Numbers 20:5.
The motif of 600,000 also appears in P (Exod 12:37; Num 1:46, 2:32; 26:51), but applies only to Israelite males—with the exception of males from the tribe of Levi—eligible for military conscription.
As Jacob Milgrom writes, “it would almost seem that the quail are brought to Israel in order to prove God’s point to Moses!” Milgrom, Numbers, 88.
The precise meaning of chomorim is uncertain.
As James Kugel notes, some of the early interpreters insisted that only the plague, and not the quails, was the punishment for complaints; see James Kugel, The Bible as It Was (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1997), 463–465. The positive description of the quail in the P story in Exodus likely influences this reading. The view that the quails were a generous gift also appears in Nehemiah 9:15, 20; see Yoo, Ezra and the Second Wilderness, 53–54.
Numbers 11:35, the last verse in this chapter, belongs to the Priestly source (P).
The intertwined E story, in which YHWH is granting people prophecy to help Moses with the burden of leading the people, obscures the J imagine of YHWH here.
Editor’s note: See Marc Zvi Brettler, “Differing Conceptions of the Divine Creator,” TheTorah (2013).
From documentarian perspectives, see the discussions in Benjamin Sommer, The Bodies of God and the World of Ancient Israel (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2009), 38–44; and Anne Knafl, Forming God: Divine Anthropomorphism in the Pentateuch, Siphrut 12 (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2014), 78–82.
Editor’s note: See, Ben-Zion Katz, “God’s Appearance to Abraham: Vision or Visit?” TheTorah (2013).
Editor’s note: See Ronald Hendel, “The Flood Changes God Not Humanity,” TheTorah (2019).
In J’s own presentation of the wilderness period, the Israelites were completely devoid of wisdom. This is evident by the lack of wisdom expressions in J; see Yoo, “Absence of Wisdom,” 359–360. Indeed, it does not take long for the Israelites to forget YHWH’s warnings, as their first complaints come immediately after they leave Sinai.