King Saul’s Downfall: Sight and Sound

Saul’s failure to see and be seen when the Bible first introduces him signals his dismal prospects for a successful reign. Afraid of his soldiers, Saul listens to the wrong voices instead of YHWH.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"King Saul’s Downfall: Sight and Sound." TheTorah.com, July 17, 2024. https://www.thetorah.com/article/king-sauls-downfall-sight-and-sound.

APA Style

Click to copy

"King Saul’s Downfall: Sight and Sound" (2024, July 17). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/king-sauls-downfall-sight-and-sound

King Saul’s Downfall: Sight and Sound

King Saul (detail) Ernst Josephson, 1878. National Museum, Stockholm. Wikimedia

Categories:

Tetzaveh

Published: July 17, 2024

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. The same comment appears earlier (in Judg 17:6) as a criticism in the story of Micah’s house of God and the founding of the temple of Dan (chs. 17–18; and see 18:1, which notes the absence of a king). A reference to the absence of a king also begins the final narrative in the book of Judges (19:1), in which spousal betrayal and separation graduate into increasing moral degeneracy and violence and culminate in gang rape, dismemberment, civil war, massive casualties, ethnic cleansing, and kidnapping (chs. 19–21). Editor’s note: On this story as a critique of Saul, see Sara Milstein, “The Story of the Concubine at Gibeah: A Satire on King Saul,” TheTorah (2017). The moral disintegration that the phrase “doing right in one’s own eyes” signifies is corroborated by its characterization of Samson’s penchant for foreign women, notably those who belong to the Philistines, Israel’s enemy (Judg 14:3).

  2. Biblical translations follow NJPS, with modifications.

  3. The Samuel narratives are composite of multiple sources, but my focus is the final redacted Masoretic version as we now have it. In a literary sense it reflects, at the very least, an editor who, as Moshe Garsiel noted, “reworked his material with such genuine creative artistry that he cannot be regarded as an ‘editor’ in the restricted technical sense of collecting and arranging together material and providing editorial links and glosses; rather he seems to have been a skilled creative artist—an author in the full meaning of the word.” See Moshe Garsiel, The First Book of Samuel: A Literary Study of Comparative Structures, Analogies, and Parallels (Ramat Gan: Revivim, 1983), 15. For a small sampling of others who have approached the Masoretic text this way, see Peter Miscall, I Samuel: A Literary Reading (Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 1986). Also see Robert Alter’s comments in his introduction to The David Story (New York: W.W. Norton, 1999), where he criticizes biblical scholarship, which has “badly underrated this book by imagining that ideological strands can be identified like so many varieties of potatoes and understood as simple expressions of advocacy” (p. xiv). See also David Gunn and Dana N. Fewell, Narrative in the Hebrew Bible (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993), and the lengthy list of literary studies of Samuel under section N of the bibliography; and Gary A. Rendsburg, The Redaction of Genesis (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 1986), which argues against source criticism in favor of reading biblical narratives as large, unified blocks of literature.

  4. A leitwort, “leading word,” is a key word or root that is repeated within a text for literary effect.

  5. This contrasts with the screams that emerge from Israel’s Egyptian enslavement experience, which draw YHWH’s attention and which are “heard” by Him. See Exodus 2:24.

  6. Although I agree with the basic thesis proposed by Marsha White that the inauguration of Saul contained in 1 Samuel 1–14 consists of a “fixed document” from which a “highly nuanced account emerges that coheres and moves logically from segment to segment,” my interpretation of these scenes is vigorously at odds with her characterization of the story as “pro-Saul” and an “apologia for Saul’s kingship.” This scene of the stray asses is but one example of our opposing readings. Where White sees that these lost beasts of burden “providentially [lead] him to the priest and prophet Samuel,” I see the repeated failure to find and see as an indication of meager talent and a strike against the quality of his candidacy for the throne. See Marsha White, “History of Saul’s Rise: Saulide State Propaganda in I Samuel 1–14,” in A Wise and Discerning Mind: Essays in Honor of Burke O. Long, ed. Saul M. Olyan and Robert C. Culley, Brown Judaic Studies 325 (Providence, RI: Brown Judaic Studies, 2000), 271–292, esp. 273–274 and 285–286.

  7. שׁמואל א י:כא וַיַּקְרֵב אֶת שֵׁבֶט בִּנְיָמִן לְמִשְׁפַּחְתָּו [לְמִשְׁפְּחֹתָיו] וַתִּלָּכֵד מִשְׁפַּחַת הַמַּטְרִי וַיִּלָּכֵד שָׁאוּל בֶּן קִישׁ וַיְבַקְשֻׁהוּ וְלֹא נִמְצָא.
    1 Sam 10:21 Then Samuel brought forward the tribe of Benjamin by its clans, and the clan of the Matrites was indicated; and then Saul son of Kish was indicated. But when they looked for him, he was not to be found.
  8. The story also plays on the ability to speak, as disaffection with Saul’s reign immediately sets in, before which Saul remains mute:

    שׁמואל א י:כז וּבְנֵי בְלִיַּעַל אָמְרוּ מַה יֹּשִׁעֵנוּ זֶה וַיִּבְזֻהוּ וְלֹא הֵבִיאוּ לוֹ מִנְחָה וַיְהִי כְּמַחֲרִישׁ.
    1 Sam 10:27 But some scoundrels said, “How can this fellow save us?” So they scorned him and brought him no gift. And he made himself silent.

    An opinion in the Talmud sees the crisis as a punitive consequence of Saul’s inability to exercise leadership and quell the rumblings against his authority (b. Yoma 22b).

  9. For the recurrent pattern of sight imagery and blindness thematically constructed by the Deuteronomist as “a corollary of wickedness” in the Saul narrative see David Damrosch, The Narrative Covenant: Transformations of Genre in the Growth of Biblical Literature (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University, 1987), 228–233.

  10. The literature on this subject is vast; see, e.g., Herman Van Praag, “The Downfall of King Saul: The Neurobiological Consequences of Losing Hope,” Judaism 35.4 (1986): 414–428.

  11. Although there is a scholarly consensus that chapters 16 and 17 represent two opposing traditions on David’s introduction to Saul, Robert Alter (The David Story, 111 n. 55) accounts for the final redaction of both side-by-side as a foreshadowing of David’s complex character, which the reader will confront in the coming narratives. Taken as a whole, they reveal a multidimensional, often contradictory personality.

  12. Saul’s madness introduces another dimension in which the conflict between him and David plays itself out. As Zev Wiseman states, “The confrontation between Saul and David has shifted from the overt real and rational sphere to the hidden psychopathological and chaotic sphere evinced in Saul’s madness.” See Zev Wiseman, Political Satire in the Bible (Atlanta: Scholars Press, 1998), 54.

  13. The reflexive hitpaʿel form of this rare verb is rendered as “force oneself” or “restrain oneself” in BDB (Brown, Driver, Briggs, A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament [Oxford, 1906], s.v. אפק) and DCH (Clines, The Dictionary of Classical Hebrew, s.v. אפק). (HALOT [The Hebrew and Aramaic Lexicon of the Old Testament, s.v. אפק] proposes a translation of “to pluck up courage, to venture” for this verse, though it renders the verb elsewhere as “to control oneself.”) Other than expressions of divine conduct, this term appears in relation to only two other biblical personalities, Joseph and Haman, both vice regents wielding the full power of the monarch. Joseph, who is second only to Pharaoh in the Egyptian court, suppresses the urge to reveal his true identity to his brothers, who do not recognize him after a lengthy absence (Gen 43:31; also 45:1, where he no longer can contain himself). Thus, Joseph wields power while his identity is obfuscated. Haman, who has aspired to a position of power similar to that of Joseph, restrains himself from retaliating for Mordechai’s insolence, another member of the royal court who does not rise or bow in Haman’s presence (Esth 5:9, 10). Haman is fully recognizable but is powerless to act against defiance that undermines that recognition. With Saul, the term may import both senses—powerlessness and lack of identity—as he accedes to the will of the people and assumes Samuel’s role.

  14. I concur with L. Daniel Hawk, “Saul as Sacrifice: The Tragedy of Israel’s First Monarch,” Bible Review 12.6 (1996): 20–25, 56, that sacrifice is a central leitmotif that permeates the entire Saul narrative, but not with his interpretation that its significance is to transform Saul into a sacrificial figure “to appease Yahweh’s anger over the people’s demands and thus to make possible Israel’s transformation from confederacy to monarchy” (p. 22). My argument here in part accords with James G. Williams’ incisive analysis, which associates Saul’s mishandling of sacrifices with Saul’s role as a scapegoat, though from a different perspective. Pertinent to my claims here of Saul personifying the anarchy at the conclusion of Judges is his assertion, “The king is the sacrifice if he cannot handle the processes of exchange and substitution which prevent a reversion to chaos, and this is the fate of King Saul.” See James G. Williams, “Sacrifice and the Beginning of Kingship,” Semeia 67 (1994): 73–92, at 89.

  15. Saul’s role as a facilitator of sacrifices (here and in the Amalek episode, discussed below) achieves much more than depicting him as a cultic bungler. It is not simply a matter of ignorance, as Cristiano Grottanelli argues: “As opposed to a priest who is schooled in sacred things, he reveals himself to be absurdly ignorant.” It is also that Saul’s “religious” gesture is moved by self-preservation, and therefore the offering is directed ultimately to him rather than YHWH. See Cristiano Grottanelli, Kings and Prophets: Monarchic Power, Inspired Leadership & Sacred Text in Biblical Literature (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999), 96–97.

  16. No other battle in the Bible is depicted so starkly as being conducted along two distinct fronts as the original one between Amalek and the desert-wandering Israelites of the Egyptian exodus. Joshua spearheads the military charge against the enemy while Moses stands at a distance managing the conflict on a metaphysical plane of existence. The rise and fall of Moses’ arms toward YHWH determine the fortunes of the battle. The two fronts however operate in tandem, one mirroring the other. Thus, a war with Amalek is an especially suggestive vehicle to underscore the failings of the monarchy which stands for the rupture between the political and religious dimensions of the polis. Editor’s note: On Amalek in the Bible and in the account of Saul’s reign, see Gili Kugler, “Amalek: A Pawn in the Rivalry Between Saul and David’s Legacy,” The Torah (2022).

  17. Saul’s excuses in both incidents amount to an incriminating vindication of YHWH’s earlier concern that the people’s request for a king is a rejection of His own kingship (1 Sam 8:7).

  18. Meir Sternberg, The Poetics of Biblical Narrative: Ideological Literature and the Drama of Reading (Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1987), points out the dramatic effect of listening in this narrative: “This loaded verb, whose sense extends from hearing to obedience, resonates more than any other throughout the structure of repetition” (p. 513). Though he emphasizes the contrasting interplay between vox dei and vox populi, I have stressed the collapse of both into a vox animali.

  19. Thanks to Marc Brettler for this insight. See, e.g., P. Kyle McCarter, Jr., I Samuel: A New Translation with Introduction, Notes, and Commentary, AB 8 (New York: Doubleday, 1980), 26–27, 205–207.

  20. As Joel Rosenberg points out, “Saul’s kingship is but an extension of the idioms of judgeship…he never fully rises above the haphazard and ad hoc conditions of charismatic leadership.” See Joel Rosenberg, “1 and 2 Samuel,” in The Literary Guide to the Bible, ed. Robert Alter and Frank Kermode (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1990), 122–145 (at 128).

Related Topics:Saul, KingSamuel