King Solomon Solves the Case of the Two Prostitutes

So why aren’t we told which mother actually stole the baby?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"King Solomon Solves the Case of the Two Prostitutes." TheTorah.com, December 21, 2023. https://www.thetorah.com/article/king-solomon-solves-the-case-of-the-two-prostitutes.

APA Style

Click to copy

"King Solomon Solves the Case of the Two Prostitutes" (2023, December 21). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/king-solomon-solves-the-case-of-the-two-prostitutes

King Solomon Solves the Case of the Two Prostitutes

The Wisdom of Solomon, James Tissot, circa 1896–1902.

Categories:

Miketz

Published: December 21, 2023

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. Literally, “a listening heart.”

  2. Unless otherwise indicated, translations of the biblical text follow RJPS with modifications.

  3. For more on this episode in 1 Kings 3:4–15, see Dr. Ruth Fidler, “Solomon’s Divine Wisdom: Legitimizing His Kingship,” TheTorah (2021).

  4. Several additional textual clues indicate the close relationship between the dream episode in 3:4–15 and the episode that follows in v. 16–28. The episode in v. 16–28 opens with the particle אָז followed by the imperfect verb, which, as Craig Evan Anderson, “The Sword of Solomon: The Subversive Underbelly of Solomon’s Judgment of the Two Prostitutes,” in Partners with God: Theological and Critical Readings of the Bible in Honor of Marvin A. Sweeney, ed. Shelley L. Birdsong and Serge Frolov (Claremont, CA: Claremont Press, 2017), 73–81 [at 74, note 2], comments, indicates a correlation between the two; this unit is intended to illuminate the previous one. Moshe Garsiel, “Revealing and Concealing as a Narrative Strategy in Solomon’s Judgment (1 Kings 3:16–28),” CBQ 64.2 (2002): 229–247 [at 235], observes that the two narratives are linked by vocabulary as well. The verbs בּוֹא (come) and עָמַד (stand before) occur in both 1 Kings 3:15 and 16. In verse 15, Solomon comes and stands before the Ark, while in verse 16, the two prostitutes come and stand before the king. He notes both narratives use the verb שָׁמַע (“to hear,” vv. 9, 28) and the noun מִשְׁפָּט (“justice,” vv. 11, 28) and both have וְהִנֵּה, ‘‘and behold/look’’ (vv. 15, 21).

  5. In the Bible, terms for sex work most often derive from the root ז.נ.ה/י. Phyllis Bird, “To Play the Harlot: An Inquiry into an Old Testament Metaphor,” in Gender and Difference in Ancient Israel, ed. Peggy Day (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1989), 76. Quasi-marital relationships such as concubinage and the acquisition of slave “wives” fall under the umbrella of marriage in relation to usages of the term זנה .זנה is sometimes paired with נאף, “to commit adultery” (i.e., to violate a husband’s exclusive sexual right to his wife), but זנה is a more general and inclusive term, covering all instances of sexual intercourse in which there is an absence of a marriage bond between otherwise acceptable partners, including adultery, premarital sex by a daughter who is still part of her father’s household, and the sexual activities of a prostitute. Bird, “To Play the Harlot,” 76–77. Bird (90, note 13) also notes that for this reason, incest, bestiality, and homosexuality are not covered by זנה .זנה is also used figuratively to denote religious or political infidelity against God, in which those who commit it are unfaithful with other gods or nations (see e.g., Lev 17:7; 20:5; Deut 31:16; Judg 2:17; and 1 Chr 5:25). Those who engage in such behavior are often depicted metaphorically in prophetic texts as God’s promiscuous, unfaithful wife. (See, e.g., Jer 3:1–5; Ezek 16:15–34; Ezek 23:1–21; and Hos 1–3. נאף is used in a similar way in Isa 57:3 and Jer 23:10. נאף and זנה are paired in such metaphors in Jer 3:8–9; 13:27; Hos 2:4; 4:13–14.)

  6. זוֹנָה without אִשָּׁה carries the same meaning. The terms appear to be interchangeable, given that Rahab is referred to as a זוֹנָה in Joshua 6:17 and 6:25 an אִשָּׁה זוֹנָה in Joshua 2:1 and 6:22. (On אִשָּׁה זוֹנָה as an apposition of specificity, see Paul Joüon and Tamitsu Muraoka, A Grammar of Biblical Hebrew, 3rd reprint of 2nd ed. with corrections, Subsidia Biblica 27 [Roma: G&B press, 2011], 131b.) The nominal construction of זוֹנָה is the same as that used to denote occupations such as a guard (שומר), shepherd (רועה) or a priest (כוהן). In the Bible, זונה occurs exclusively in the feminine singular and plural forms. (See, e.g., Gen 38:15; Lev 21:7, 14; Deut 23:19; Josh 2:1; 6:17, 22, 25; Prov 6:26; 7:10; 29:3.) For more on the usage of this nominal pattern in biblical Hebrew to denote occupations, see Benjamin Kedar-Kopfstein, “Semantic Aspects of the Pattern qôṭēl,” HAR 1 (1977): 158, 164–165. Though זוֹנָה formally denotes a sex worker, it may also have been used more broadly to refer to women who are not actual sex workers but are viewed as being “loose” in relation to sexual mores, much as the term “whore” is used today both to refer to a sex worker and as a derogatory term for a woman considered by the speaker to be sexually promiscuous. The context does not always make clear which sense of the term is intended (see, e.g., Judg 11:1–3, 16:1). In addition, in some cases, זוֹנָה may refer to a woman who lives independently and may reflect a cultural assumption that such women were open to being propositioned. This observation has been made by several scholars, including Athalya Brenner, The Intercourse of Knowledge: On Gendering Desire and ‘Sexuality’ in the Hebrew Bible, Biblical Interpretation Series 26 (Leiden: E.J. Brill, 1997), 150–151; Phyllis Bird, “Prostitution in the Social World and the Religious Rhetoric of Ancient Israel,” in Prostitutes and Courtesans in the Ancient World, ed. Christopher A. Faraone and Laura McClure (Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, 2006), 40–58 [at 44–48]; and M.L. Garcia Bachman, Women at Work in the Deuteronomistic History (Atlanta: SBL, 2013), 274–277. Thus, texts in which a woman is called a זוֹנָה should be considered on a case-by-case basis to determine whether they refer to literal sex work.

  7. For a discussion of the use of veils in ancient Israel, see Karel van der Toorn, “The Significance of the Veil in the Ancient Near East,” in Pomegranates and Golden Bells: Studies in Biblical, Jewish, and Near Eastern Ritual, Law, and Literature in Honor of Jacob Milgrom, ed. David P. Wright, David Noel Freedman, and Avi Hurvitz (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 1995), 327–339.

  8. Mordechai Cogan, I Kings: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, Anchor Bible 10 (New York: Doubleday, 2001), 193–194, observes that the women are referred to as prostitutes only at the beginning of the episode. He suggests that this term was used mostly to set up a situation where circumstances like those in the case could occur, as well as showing that all subjects had access to justice from the king. Their occupation has no bearing on the rest of the story, and they are referred to simply as women after that.

  9. This may not be intended literally. Cogan, I Kings, 194, points out that this expression בַּיּוֹם הַשְּׁלִישִׁי, “on the third day,” indicates “an indefinite measure of time, an element common in storytelling meaning, ‘after a few days, shortly thereafter.’” (See, e.g., Gen 22:4; Josh 9:17; 1 Sam 30:1; and Est 5:1.)

  10. See further Joshua 2:3; 6:17–23. The זוֹנָה Samson visits in Judges 16:1–3 also appears to have her own house.

  11. This tendency goes back as far as Josephus (see Antiquities 8:27, 32). Ranaan Eichler, “Solomon’s Judgment: The Meta-Riddle,” Biblica 102 (2021): 30–44 [at 33–34], observes that Josephus in his retelling of the story changes several details of the biblical account, eliminating all doubt about who the mother of the living child is. Eichler also notes that several medieval commentators, including R. Joseph Ibn Kaspi, R. Isaac Abrabanel, R. David ibn Zimra (Radbaz), and R. Moses Alshekh also believed that the first woman is the mother of the live child.

  12. See, e.g., Gary A. Rendsburg, “The Guilty Party in 1 Kings III 16–28,” VT 48 (1998): 534–541, who also contends that if you look closely at the way each woman is referred to in the text, you can tell which one asks to spare the child, and which one says cut it in half. Eichler, “Solomon’s Judgment: The Meta-Riddle,” 35–36, notes that the earliest Jewish commentators to argue that the second woman was the mother of the live child were R. Hayyim Josef David Azulai (Chida) and R. Meir Leibush Weisser (Malbim).

  13. Among those who believe Solomon already knows who the mother of the live child is before he asks for the sword are R. Joseph Kara, R. Isaac Abrabanel, and R. Meir Leibush ben Yehiel Michal (Malbim). See the discussion in Angel, “Cut the Baby in Half,” 190–192.

  14. Among those who contend that there is no way for Solomon (or the reader) to identify the mother of the living child are Stuart Lasine, “The Riddle of Solomon’s Judgment and the Riddle of Human Nature in the Hebrew Bible,” JSOT 45 (1989): 61–86; Ellen van Wolde, “Who Guides Whom? Embeddedness as Perspective in Biblical Hebrew and in 1 Kings 3:16–28,” JBL 114 (1995): 623–642 [at 638]; and Meir Sternberg, The Poetics of Biblical Narrative: Ideological Literature and the Drama of Reading (Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press, 1987), 166–170.

  15. A low estimation of the value of prostitutes is also reflected Proverbs 6:26 and Joel 4:3. The stigma may also have attached to the prostitute’s clients, as suggested by Judah’s reluctance to continue searching for Tamar to retrieve his staff, seal, and cord, which he had given her in pledge (Gen 38:18) to guarantee that he would pay her for her services. Nor were the prostitute’s children immune to the stigma, if the introduction of Jephthah as בֶּן אִשָּׁה זוֹנָה, “the son of a prostitute,” refers to an actual prostitute and not simply a promiscuous woman (Judg 11:1). Bachman, Women at Work in the Deuteronomistic History, 319–320, makes a solid case that זוֹנָה in this context likely does not refer to an actual prostitute, since if she were a prostitute, Gilead would have no way of knowing the child was his, and the certainty of his paternity is taken for granted by the text. It is more likely that Gilead impregnated Jephthah’s mother out of wedlock, and then accepted the child into his home. This would explain why Jephthah and his mother had a lower status among his brothers and why she is referred to as a זוֹנָה.

  16. דברים כג:יט לֹא תָבִיא אֶתְנַן זוֹנָה וּמְחִיר כֶּלֶב בֵּית יְ־הוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ לְכָל נֶדֶר כִּי תוֹעֲבַת יְ־הוָה אֱלֹהֶיךָ גַּם שְׁנֵיהֶם.
    Deut 23:19 You shall not bring the fee of a prostitute or the pay of a dog into the house of YHWH your God in fulfillment of any vow, for both are abhorrent to YHWH your God.

    The association of כֶּלֶב with prostitution is based on this one text. The term כֶּלֶב generally means dog in the Bible. References to dogs tend to reflect an attitude of disdain and sometimes disgust towards them (see, e.g., Exod 22:30; 1 Kgs 14:11; 16:4; 21:19, 23–24; 22:38; 2 Kgs 9:10, 36; and Prov 26:11). There are also a few instances in which כֶּלֶב is used in reference to a person, either as a sign of self-abasement (2 Sam 9:8; 2 Kgs 8:13) or, when referring to someone else, to indicate scorn (2 Sam 16:9). Because מְחִיר כֶּלֶב is paired with אֶתְנַן זוֹנָה in Deuteronomy 23:19 and there are references to the קָדֵשׁ and קְדֵשָׁה (the so called “sacred prostitutes”) in the previous verse, the most common understanding of כֶּלֶב in this verse has been that it refers to a secular male prostitute. However, Elaine Adler Goodfriend, “Could keleb in Deuteronomy 23:19 Actually Refer to a Canine?,” in Pomegranates and Golden Bells: Studies in Biblical, Jewish, and Near Eastern Ritual, Law, and Literature in Honor of Jacob Milgrom, ed. David P. Wright, David Noel Freedman, and Avi Hurvitz (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 1995), 381–397, has made a strong case for understanding מְחִיר כֶּלֶב as referring to the price of an actual dog. Phyllis A. Bird, “Of Whores and Hounds: A New Interpretation of The Subject of Deuteronomy,” VT 65 (2015): 352–364, building upon this, provides an intriguing argument for this reading, noting that כֶּלֶב and זוֹנָה are also paired in 1 Kings 22:38, where כֶּלֶב clearly means dog. She contends that אֶתְנַן זוֹנָה and מְחִיר כֶּלֶב should be understood as formulaic expressions used idiomatically to denote something cheap, of low regard and of little or questionable value, perhaps in Deuteronomy 23:18 denoting something inadequate or unworthy of donating to the temple as a payment in fulfillment of one’s vow. The prohibition, then, concerns financial ethics—making an inadequate, insufficient, or cheap offering. If Bird is correct, the usage of this idiom (as well as their being paired with dogs twice in biblical texts) tells us something about how prostitutes were viewed: of low regard and of little value.

  17. That this restriction was deemed necessary indicates that some members of the general population probably did in fact marry prostitutes, just as they married the other categories of women prohibited for priests to marry. Thus, while there was a stigma, being a prostitute did not necessarily mean a woman would never be able to find a husband. Presumably if she married, the woman would stop practicing her trade, since otherwise she would be committing adultery.

  18. See also Proverbs 29:3. Isaiah’s metaphoric image of Jerusalem as a זוֹנָה in a complaint about thievery, deception, and bribe-taking in the city also reflects the stereotype of prostitutes as mercenary (1:21–23). The association of prostitutes with shamelessness is further reflected in a passage that describes a married woman intent on seducing a young man while her husband is away as impersonating a prostitute and brazenly seeking out men on the street and in the market, lurking at every corner (Prov 7:10–13). See the discussion in Bird, “Prostitution in the Social World and the Religious Rhetoric of Ancient Israel,” 45–48, and Claudia Camp, “1 and 2 Kings,” in The Women’s Bible Commentary, ed. C.A. Newsom and Sharon Ringe (Louisville, KY: Westminster/John Knox Press, 1992), 100.

  19. Phyllis Bird, “The Harlot as Heroine: Narrative Art and Social Presupposition in Three Old Testament Texts,” in Women in the Hebrew Bible: A Reader, ed. Alice Bach (New York: Routledge, 1999), 110.

  20. Bird, “The Harlot as Heroine,” 110.

  21. See, e.g., Garsiel, “Revealing and Concealing as a Narrative Strategy,” 235–247, who adds that the second woman is referred to as “the other woman,” which he contends in biblical texts is always derogatory (pp. 240–241). The belief that the plaintiff is the mother of the living child is reflected in some translations. The NRSV, for example, renders תְּנוּ לָהּ אֶת הַיָּלוּד הַחַי in verse 27 as “Give the first woman the living boy.” The translations in the NIV, ESV, and NASB are similar.

  22. Bird, “The Harlot as Heroine,” 110.

  23. Bird, “The Harlot as Heroine,” 111. Similarly, Bird, “Prostitution in the Social World and the Religious Rhetoric of Ancient Israel,” 48–49.

  24. Susan Ackerman, Warrior, Dancer, Seductress, Queen: Women in Judges and Biblical Israel, The Anchor Yale Bible Reference Library (New York: Doubleday, 1998), 115–116; and Mieke Bal, Death and Dissymmetry: The Politics of Coherence in the Book of Judges (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988), 43–93.

  25. See, e.g., J. T. Walsh, 1 Kings (Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 1996), 80; Richard Nelson, First and Second Kings (Atlanta, GA: John Knox, 1987), 39; and Hayyim Angel, “Cut the Baby in Half: Understanding Solomon’s Divinely Inspired Wisdom,” JBQ 39.3 (2011): 189–194 [at 193], who comments, “Prostitution is a lowly occupation in any society, but especially in a monotheistic theocracy where God's Temple is about to be built. The tenfold repetition of the term ‘the king’ in contrast to these prostitutes, then, is striking. It appears that a primary message of this narrative is that anyone could gain an audience with Solomon and receive a fair hearing…. That prostitutes could gain an audience with Solomon and that he would listen so attentively to their arguments that he could solve their case with no witnesses demonstrate Solomon's true wisdom.”

  26. Some contend that even though the case was unsolvable for Solomon without the ruse and the identity of the “real” mother of the living child is never explicitly stated in the text, there are subtle clues in the narrative to help the reader deduce the real mother of the living child. See, e.g. Rendsburg, “The Guilty Party In 1 Kings III 16–28,” 534–541.

  27. See the discussion in Garsiel, “Revealing and Concealing as a Narrative Strategy,” 231, on the relationship between Solomon’s request for judicial wisdom, the case of the two women, and Solomon’s recognition as king over all Israel.