The Chanukah Oil Miracle Never Happened—A 19th Century Heresy

The miracle of the jug of oil lasting eight days is first narrated in the Babylonian Talmud, centuries after the establishment of Chanukah. In 1891 Poland, Chaim Zelig Slonimski, an observant, science-minded Jew, denied the historicity of this miracle, claiming that he was following in the footsteps of Maimonides. Some of his enlightened colleagues—and even some secular Zionists—thought he was endangering people’s connection to Judaism and providing antisemites a pretext to mock the Talmud.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Chanukah Oil Miracle Never Happened—A 19th Century Heresy." TheTorah.com, December 15, 2025. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-chanukah-oil-miracle-never-happened-a-19th-century-heresy.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Chanukah Oil Miracle Never Happened—A 19th Century Heresy" (2025, December 15). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-chanukah-oil-miracle-never-happened-a-19th-century-heresy

The Chanukah Oil Miracle Never Happened—A 19th Century Heresy

Chaim Zelig Slonimski, March 31, 1810-May 15, 1904. Wikimedia

Published: December 15, 2025

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. For more on these works and what they say about Chanukah, see Malka Z. Simkovich, “Uncovering the Truth about Chanukah,” TheTorah (2013); Katell Berthelot, “The Maccabean Victory Explained: Between 1 and 2 Maccabees,” TheTorah (2022); Steve Mason, “Josephus Rejected the Rebellion Against Rome, Why Did He Celebrate Chanukah?” TheTorah (2022); Zev Farber, “Chanukah: Not Judah Maccabee’s Holiday,” TheTorah (2022).

    The research for the article was supported by the Emmy Noether Junior Research Group ‘Emancipatio Rabbinica,’ funded by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation; project number 518233389).

  2. For the context of this story’s emergence, see Shai Secunda, “The Development of the Chanukah Oil Miracle in Context of Zoroastrian Fire Veneration,” TheGemara (2016).

  3. Chaim Zelig Slonimski, “מאי חנוכה” [What Is Chanukah?] Ha-Tsfirah 18, issue 278 (1891), 1123. Later in the polemic Shmuel Alexandrov claimed that the source of the story is the Scholion, the commentary to the scroll of Ta’anit, a position long held by scholars. Vered Noam, however, has shown recently that the story first appears in the Babylonian Talmud, and only later did it find its way into manuscripts of the Scholion, see Vered Noam, Megilat Ta’anit: Versions, Interpretation, History (Yad Ben-Zvi Press, 2003), 266-276.

  4. Slonimski also received international attention due to his computing machine and the improvements he made in the telegraph, see Nicolas Slonimsky, “My Grandfather Invented the Telegraph,” Commentary 63 (Jan 1997), 56-65; “Chaim Zelig Slonimski,” The Computer Timeline.

  5. See, for example, Yehudah Leib Katzenelson, מה שראו עיני ושמעו אזני: זכרונות מימי חיי [What my Eyes Saw and my Ears Heard: Memoir] (Bialik Press, 1947), 44-46.

  6. Chaim Zelig Slonimski, מציאות הנפש וקיומה מחוץ לגוף [On the Immortality of the Soul] (Warsaw 1880), 12–13; Ira Robinson, “Hayyim Selig Slonimski and the Diffusion of Science Among Russian Jewry in the Nineteenth Century”, The Interaction of Scientific and Jewish Cultures in Modern Times, eds. Yakov Rabkin and Ira Robinson (E. Mellen 1995), 49–65; Jeffrey Blutinger, “Creatures from Before the Flood: Reconciling Science and Genesis in the Pages of a Nineteenth-Century Hebrew Newspaper”, Social Jewish Studies 16 (2010), 67-92.

  7. Chaim Zelig Slonimski, “The Questions of our Time and Time for Questions,” Ha-Tsfirah 17, issue 264 (1890), p. 1088. The Talmudic quote following b. Berakhot 31b. See also Maimonides, Guide for the Perplexed, I, 26.

  8. Unlike medieval Jewish philosophers, for whom the challenge was philosophical reasoning, for Slonimsky it was scientific reason that forced a new understanding of Jewish tradition.

  9. He saw rabbinic tradition as the textual backbone of Jewish culture that cannot be bypassed because it is the very language through which Jews comprehend the world.

  10. Hayyim Zelig Slonimski, “זאת חנוכה” [This is Chanukah], Ha-Tsfirah 18, issue 283 (1891), 1144–1145.

  11. Hasagot HaRa’abad on Mishneh Torah, Repentance 3:7.

  12. The Ra’abad is reacting to Maimonides’ claim that one who believe God has a body or form is considered min and thus has no portion in the world to come (Mishneh Torah, Repentance 3:7). Aside from stating that “Many greater and better than he followed this opinion” that God has a body or form, The Ra’abad adds that this misguiding is due to “what they saw in biblical phrases, and more particularly in the texts of the Aggadot, which misdirect [or distort] opinions.”

  13. See Chaim Zelig Slonimski, מלשני בסתר ואגודת מכתבים [Secret Informants and Collected Letters] (Odesa 1894), 5-7.

  14. The anonymous authors of this poster fully understood the implications of using Ra’abad’s medieval quote and it is the only excerpt of the original article brought in the poster. They seem to not recognize its medieval origin, instead prescribing it to Slonimski himself.

  15. Slonimski himself published this pashkevil in a Jewish-Russian newspaper: Хаим-Зелик Слонимский, “Писмо в редакцiю”, Недъльная Хроника Восхода, Годь 11, Но. 5 (2 Февраля, 1892), Cтр. 117-118. [Chaim Zelig Slonimski, “Letter to the Editor,” Weekly Chronicle of Voskhod 11, issue number 5 (1892), pp. 117-118 (from Russian).]

  16. See Theodore R. Weeks, “Best of Both Worlds: Creating the Żyd–Polak,” East European Jewish Affairs 34,2 (2004), 1–20; Marcin Wadzinski, Haskalah and Hasidism in the Kingdom of Poland (Portland, Oregon, 2005), 200-207.

  17. See Samuel Hirsz Peltyn [Judaita], “Nie tędy droga!” Izraelita 27, nr. 5 (29.01.1892), pp. 33–35; Chaim Zelig Słonimski, “Odpowiedź,” Izraelita 27, Nr. 6 (05.02.1982), pp. 42–43; Samuel Hirsz Peltyn [Judaita], “Panu Ch. Z. Słonimskiemu,” Izraelita 27, Nr. 7 (12.02.1892), pp. 49–50.

  18. Based on Pirke Avot 1: 11. The same phrase, this time in Hebrew, was later used by Alexander Zederbaum as the title to his essay against Slonimski.

  19. Peltyn [Judaita], “Nie tędy droga!”, pp. 34-35 (from Polish).

  20. Chaim Zelig Słonimski, “Odpowiedź,” Izraelita 27, Nr. 6 (05.02.1982), pp. 42–43; Samuel Hirsz Peltyn [Judaita], “Panu Ch. Z. Słonimskiemu,” Izraelita 27, Nr. 7 (12.02.1892), pp. 49–50.

  21. Aharon Ze’ev, Anu Nos’im Lapidim. The poem was written in 1936. See Aviad Kleinberg, “The Enchantment of Judaism: Israeli Anxieties and Puzzles,” Critical Inquiry 35.3 (2009): pp. 616–617; Haggith Gor Ziv, “Teaching Jewish Holidays in Early Childhood Education in Israel: Critical Feminist Pedagogy Perspective,” Taboo 15.1 (2017), 125-126; National Library, “הסיפור המדליק מאחורי 'אנו נושאים לפידים'” [The Amazing Story Behind ‘We Carry Torches’] HaSafranim (Dec 19, 2019).

  22. Алексе́й С. Суво́рин, “Маленькая хроника,” Новое время 5706 (17.01.1892), p. 3.

  23. Alexander Zederbaum, “חכמים הזהרו בדבריכם” [Wise Men, Be Cautious with your Words], Ha-Melitz 32, issue 18 (1892), p. 1. From its inception in the early 1880s, the Jewish national movement highlighted the Chanukah story, focusing mainly on the Maccabees’ military victory and political independence, but not necessarily diminishing the miracle.

  24. Slonimski’s rivals within Polish Hasidism were outraged by his remarks, but the broader public were familiar with the old maskil’s inclinations.

  25. Alexandrov also stated the true Jewish nationalism should support a flourishing diaspora and late condemned Herzlian Zionism. On these ideas and Alexandrov interest in Christian-Orthodox theology see Isaac Slater, “A Forgotten Variety of Religious Zionism: The Thought of Shmuel Alexandrov,” Journal of Jewish Studies 74 (2023), pp. 140–163; Isaac Slater, “Those Who Yearn for the Divine: Rabbi Shmuel Alexandrov and the Russian Religious-Philosophical Renaissance,” Judaica Petropolitana 5 (2016), pp. 55–68.

  26. This is playing off the Talmudic description of Job as fictional (b. Baba Batra 15a).

  27. Shmuel Alexandrov, Agadat Pakh ha-Shemmen, p.2, Warsaw 1892.

  28. To illustrate this claim, Alexandrov brought dozens of references and quotations from across rabbinic, kabbalistic, and Hasidic literature, each casting new meaning to the miracle.

  29. Dov Ber Yehuda Leib Ginzburg, אמונת חכמים [Faith in the Sages] )Vilnius 1892(, 27–32. See Rabbi Moshe Chaim Luzzatto, Derekh Hashem (Jerusalem, 2009), book II, part 5-6.

  30. Ginzburg, Faith in the Sages, 15-17.

  31. Shmuel Alexandrov, Divrei Shmuel, Warsaw 1893, pp. 4-5.

  32. Rabbi Yehudah Meishel Tzirkel of Borisov; Rabbi Pinchas Rozovsky of Shvinitsyan, Rabbis Isaac Leib Stolyar of Kozhnits, and Rabbi Yosef Levinstein of Slutsk.

  33. Isaac Leib Stolyar, Nes Pakh ha-Shemen, Vilna 1893.

  34. His efforts, including in the Miracle of Hannukah Oil debate, were recorded in his history book, see Ya’akov Halevi Lifshitz, Zikhron Ya’akov: History of the Jews in Russia and Poland, 1760-1896, Bnei Brak 1968, III, pp. 205-208. More on Lifshitz see Israel Bartal, Shimon the Heretic: On Orthodox Counter-history, Jerusalem and Berlin: Blima Books 2025.

  35. See Chaim Zelig Slonimski, Malsheni Baseter ve-Agudat Mikhtavim, Odesa 1894, pp. 8-9.

  36. Kol Kore ‘al Harei Yisrael (manuscript), The National Library of Israel, Archival Division, Salomon Buber Archive (Shmuel Alexandrov file), ARC. 4* 1222 / 68. Available here.

  37. Shmuel Alexandrov, “Letter to the editor,” Talpiot 1 (1895), X, pp. 1-2. Emphasis in the original. Living in the Belarusian city of Bobruisk, Alexandrov probably suffered at the hands of the Chabad-Kapust hasidim. The Rabbe’s brother held court in Bobruisk.

  38. This may be playing off Rabbi Akiva’s similar phrase, אם הלכה, נקבל “if it’s the law, we accept it,” in the Mishnah (Keritot 3:9).

  39. Shmuel Alexandrov, “Letter to the editor,” p. 2.

  40. Shmuel Alexandrov, Mikhtevei Mechkar u-Vikoret, Vilnius 1907, p. 79.

  41. After securing the borders of legitimate interpretation of the Talmudic tale the conservative camp continued to reinforce them, adding to the dozens of books and articles written during the debate dozens more. Some of these works were reprinted in New York in the early 2000s. For a preliminary list see, Zerachya Licht, “Chaim Zelig Slonimsky and the Hanukkah Debate,” The Seforim Blog (December 26, 2016). Licht’s list does not include Alexandrov’s, Slonimski’s, Peltyn’s and Suvorin’s works. It also does not represent, as Licht himself wrote, the elaborated discussion of various authors with Slonimski, published in Ha-Tsfirah in dozens of essays and letters. Yet, it does provide a glimpse to the stir created in rabbinic circles, a stir that provoked comments well into the 20th century.