Josephus Rejected the Rebellion Against Rome, Why Did He Celebrate Chanukah?

The Great Revolt against Rome was rooted in the Hasmonean ideology of Judean independence, yet Josephus, who warned against fighting Rome, still celebrated the Hasmonean military triumph against the Greeks.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Josephus Rejected the Rebellion Against Rome, Why Did He Celebrate Chanukah?." TheTorah.com, December 22, 2022. https://www.thetorah.com/article/josephus-rejected-the-rebellion-against-rome-why-did-he-celebrate-chanukah.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Josephus Rejected the Rebellion Against Rome, Why Did He Celebrate Chanukah?" (2022, December 22). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/josephus-rejected-the-rebellion-against-rome-why-did-he-celebrate-chanukah

Josephus Rejected the Rebellion Against Rome, Why Did He Celebrate Chanukah?

Detail of the relief representing "the spoils of the capture of Jerusalem" adorning the southern pillar of the Titus Arch erected in C. 80 CE. Photo by Jean-Pol Grandmont, Wikimedia

Published: December 22, 2022

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. Tal Ilan found they account for 39.9% of attested names in Judea’s male population. Tal Ilan, Lexicon of Jewish Names in Late Antiquity. Part I: Palestine 330 BCE–200 CE (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2002), 6–8.

  2. These are the only named Hasmonean women with whom we are familiar. Editor’s note: For more on Miriam and Shalomzion, see Malka Z. Simkovich, “Mariamme, the Last Hasmonean Princess,” TheTorah (2019); Mika Ahuvia, “Jewish Queens: From the Story of Esther to the History of Shelamzion,” TheTorah (2015).

  3. Translations of Josephus are mine.

  4. This is clear from the pedigree Josephus offers about himself in his autobiography (Vita 1–6). See Tessa Rajak, Josephus: The Historian and his Society (London: Duckworth, 2002; repr. of 1983), 16–20.

  5. Josephus tries to connect his line to theirs using some slight obfuscation:

    Jud. Ant. 16.187 We [= I], on the other hand, being of an ancestry close to the kings from Asamoneus, and for this reason holding the priesthood with honor, have considered lying about them to be unbecoming, and so we lay out their actions purely and fairly.

    He is criticizing Nicolaus of Damascus here, and saying that, unlike Nicolaus, he (Josephus) tells the truth about everyone.

  6. The name Josephus gives for the festival, Lights, is unattested elsewhere. His hesitant explanation of that name curiously does not even connect it with the lighting of lamps he has just mentioned (Jud. Ant. 12.319). Instead, he imagines a more abstract reason, connected with the suddenness of sunlight after night’s darkness. Clearly, Josephus knows nothing of the rabbinic tradition about the oil lasting for eight days. Editor’s note: For more on the development of this theme, see Malka Z. Simkovich, “Uncovering the Truth About Chanukah,” TheTorah (2013); Shai Secunda, “The Development of the Chanukah Oil Miracle in Context of Zoroastrian Fire Veneration,” TheGemara (2016).

  7. John was the only one, Josephus claims, to whom God granted the three greatest privileges: high priesthood, political rule, and the gift of prophecy (Jud. War 1.68–69; Jud. Ant. 13.299–300).

  8. Josephus everywhere expresses pride in the Hasmonean conquests, to the point that he expresses regret that, following Rome’s arrival, the territory conquered by Judea had to be returned to local rule:

    For we tossed away our freedom and fell under subjection to Rome, and the territory we had acquired by force of arms—seizing it from the Syrians—we were forced to give back to the Syrians (Jud. Ant. 14.77; cf. Jud. War 1.57).

  9. William R. Farmer, Maccabees, Zealots, and Josephus: An Inquiry into Jewish Nationalism in the Greco-Roman Period (New York: Columbia University Press, 1956); Martin Hengel, Die Zeloten; Untersuchungen zur jüdischen Freiheitsbewegung in der Zeit von Herodes I. bis 70 n. Chr. (Leiden: Brill, 1961); Menachem Stern and Jonathan J. Price, “Zealots and Sicarii,” Encyclopedia Judaica (Detroit: Macmillan Reference, 2007; repr. of 1973), 21.467–80.

  10. Following this, Joseph composed the twenty-volume Judean Antiquities, a prequel to War, which explores the Judean character by examining Moses’ matchless laws and their historical outworking. (A single-volume autobiography, extolling the author’s own character, is an appendix to the Antiquities.) The two-volume essay On the Antiquity of the Judeans, which we misname Against Apion, makes a vigorous case for the great age and superiority of Judean law.

  11. Helgo Lindner, Die Geschichtsauffassung des Flavius Josephus im Bellum Judaicum (Leiden: Brill, 1972).

  12. The righteous administration and Torah observance of the high priest Onias III had rendered Seleucid kings favorable toward Jerusalem (2 Macc 3.1), whereas the intrigues of greedy priests who abandoned Moses’ laws and pursued foreign ways turned the ruling power ferociously against Jerusalem and its ancestral ways (2 Macc 4.1–17; 5.15–26; 6.1–11).

  13. As in Daniel’s vision, they will find solace in the life to come after resurrection (2 Maccabees 7). Daniel R. Schwartz, 2 Maccabees (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2008), 296–319. In contrast, according to 1 Maccabees, even observance of Torah may be suspended in the fight against foreign powers. See the rejection of dying rather than fighting on sabbaths in 1 Macc 2.29–41. Editor’s note: For more on the theme of martyrdom in 2 Maccabees, and how this distinguishes it from the militant conception of 1 Maccabees, see Katell Berthelot, “The Maccabean Victory Explained: Between 1 and 2 Maccabees,” TheTorah (2022).

  14. 1 Maccabees is justly characterized as propaganda for the Hasmonean house, whose basic proposition, supported by biblical turns of phrase and poetic outbursts, is that the Hasmoneans are divinely chosen to fight Israel’s corner. In case the point is missed, it includes an episode in which other commanders launch a campaign and fail because “they were not of the seed of those men to whom the deliverance of Israel was given, by their hands” (1 Macc 5.62).

  15. BJ 1.38, 48, 50; AJ 12.416–419; 13.32, 37–38, 43–61, 149, 170, 223–224, 227, 249, 259.

  16. See Isaiah Gafni, “Josephus and 1 Maccabees,” in Josephus, the Bible, and History, ed. Louis H. Feldman and Gohei Hata (Detroit: Wayne State University Press, 1989), 116–131; Erich S. Gruen, “The Hasmoneans in Josephus,” in A Companion to Josephus, ed. Honora H. Chapman and Zuleika Rodgers (Chichester: Wiley-Blackwell, 2016), 222–234.

  17. Editor’s note: For some discussion of Jeremiah’s project, trying to convince Judah not to rebel, see James A. Diamond, “How Do We Know a True Prophet? Jeremiah vs. Hananiah,” TheTorah (2021).

  18. Though, he adds, Jeremiah’s contemporaries did not abuse him in the way that Josephus’ compatriots attacked him (Jud. War 5.392–393)

  19. Lamentation and dirge are prominent themes in War (from Jud. War 1.9–12). And the climactic scene of distress, a mother eating her infant because of famine (Jud. War 6.201–119), recalls Lamentations 4:10 (“compassionate women have boiled their own children”). David Daube, “Typology in Josephus,” Journal of Jewish Studies 31 (1980): 18–36; Shaye J. D. Cohen, “Josephus, Jeremiah, and Polybius,” History and Theory 21 (1982): 366–381.

  20. 1 Macc 1:54 Now on the fifteenth day of Kislev, in the one hundred forty-fifth year (=167 B.C.E.), they erected a desolating sacrilege on the altar of burnt offering… 1:59 On the twenty-fifth day of the month they offered sacrifice on the altar that was on top of the altar of burnt offering.

  21. 1 Macc 4:52 Early in the morning on the twenty-fifth day of the ninth month, which is the month of Kislev, in the one hundred forty-eighth year (=164 B.C.E.), 4:53 they rose and offered sacrifice, as the law directs, on the new altar of burnt offering that they had built. 4:54 At the very season and on the very day that the nations had profaned it, it was dedicated with songs and harps and lutes and cymbals.

  22. 2 Maccabees 10.1–5 agrees that the rededication is on the same day as the defilement, but it dates it to the second anniversary, not the third. Josephus does not appear to have had this work.

  23. The book of Daniel is set in the time of the Neo-Babylonian and early Persian empires, but as scholars have long noted, the predictions were clearly composed by an author or authors who lived during the Antiochian persecution, before the Maccabean revolt. The author, an eyewitness to the persecution, was aware of early Maccabean resistance efforts (Dan. 11:14, 34), but insisted that only God could bring a solution “not made with hands” (2:34, 45; 8:25).

  24. E.g., Goldstein, I Maccabees, 42–48.

  25. In in the manner of Jeremiah, the prayer describes the suffering of Israel as divine punishment for sin.

  26. In the vision of the fourth beasts, the sins of Antiochus IV—called “the new little horn of the fourth beast” in this vision—are described as:

    דניאל ז:כה וּמִלִּין לְצַד עליא [עִלָּאָה] יְמַלִּל וּלְקַדִּישֵׁי עֶלְיוֹנִין יְבַלֵּא וְיִסְבַּר לְהַשְׁנָיָה זִמְנִין וְדָת וְיִתְיַהֲבוּן בִּידֵהּ עַד עִדָּן וְעִדָּנִין וּפְלַג עִדָּן.
    Dan 7:25 He will speak words against the Most High, and will harass the holy ones of the Most High. He will think of changing times and laws, and they will be delivered into his power for a time, times, and half a time.

    (For more on this prophecy and its connection to the pre-Maccabean period, see Michael Segal, “Daniel’s Vision of the Four Beasts: The Prehistory of Chanukah,” TheTorah [2017].) This is referred to again in the final chapter of Daniel, in which Daniel witnesses a conversation between divine beings:

    דניאל יב:ו וַיֹּאמֶר לָאִישׁ לְבוּשׁ הַבַּדִּים אֲשֶׁר מִמַּעַל לְמֵימֵי הַיְאֹר עַד מָתַי קֵץ הַפְּלָאוֹת. יב:ז וָאֶשְׁמַע אֶת הָאִישׁ לְבוּשׁ הַבַּדִּים אֲשֶׁר מִמַּעַל לְמֵימֵי הַיְאֹר וַיָּרֶם יְמִינוֹ וּשְׂמֹאלוֹ אֶל הַשָּׁמַיִם וַיִּשָּׁבַע בְּחֵי הָעוֹלָם כִּי לְמוֹעֵד מוֹעֲדִים וָחֵצִי וּכְכַלּוֹת נַפֵּץ יַד עַם קֹדֶשׁ תִּכְלֶינָה כָל אֵלֶּה.
    Dan 12:6 One said to the man clothed in linen, who was above the water of the river, “How long until the end of these awful things?” 12:7 Then I heard the man dressed in linen, who was above the water of the river, swear by the Ever-Living One as he lifted his right hand and his left hand to heaven: “For a time, times, and half a time; and when the breaking of the power of the holy people comes to an end, then shall all these things be fulfilled.”

    In contrast, Daniel 8 seems to be working with a slightly shorter period:

    דניאל ח:יג וָאֶשְׁמְעָה אֶחָד קָדוֹשׁ מְדַבֵּר וַיֹּאמֶר אֶחָד קָדוֹשׁ לַפַּלְמוֹנִי הַמְדַבֵּר עַד מָתַי הֶחָזוֹן הַתָּמִיד וְהַפֶּשַׁע שֹׁמֵם תֵּת וְקֹדֶשׁ וְצָבָא מִרְמָס. ח:יד וַיֹּאמֶר אֵלַי עַד עֶרֶב בֹּקֶר אַלְפַּיִם וּשְׁלֹשׁ מֵאוֹת וְנִצְדַּק קֹדֶשׁ.
    Dan 8:13 Then I heard a holy being speaking, and another holy being said to whoever it was who was speaking, “How long will [what was seen in] the vision last—the regular offering be forsaken because of transgression; the sanctuary be surrendered and the [heavenly] host be trampled?” 8:14 He answered me, “For twenty-three hundred evenings and mornings; then the sanctuary shall be cleansed.”

    As the tamid (daily offering) was brought twice a day, the number here is 1150 days, which comes out to about three and a quarter years. John J. Collins (Daniel, Hermeneia [Minneapolis: Fortress, 1993], 336) suggests that this chapter may have been written slightly later than the other passages, and thus some of the time may have already elapsed.

  27. Elsewhere in Antiquities, Josephus will make much of Daniel and that prophet’s proximity to God. This is proven, he says, by the unique precision of Daniel’s predictions and the confidence with which he promised a good outcome, not only doom (Jud. Ant. 10.266–269). Scholars also trace mysterious ancient oracles that Josephus mentions to passages in Daniel. Discussion in Steve Mason, “Josephus, Daniel, and the Flavian House,” in Josephus and the History of the Greco-Roman Period: Essays in Memory of Morton Smith, ed. Fausto Parente and Joseph Sievers, Studia Post-Biblica 41 (Leiden: Brill, 1994), 161–191.

  28. This philosophy fits conveniently with that of the great Greek historian of Roman conquest, Polybius (264–146 B.C.E.), another of Josephus’s inspirations. When Josephus has King Agrippa recall the rise and fall of nations in Jud. War 2.345–409, makes changes of fortune (tychē) a root theme, and has his character say, “Fortune has transferred to them [Romans] from every side, and God, who hands the rule to one nation after another, is now over Italy” (Jud. War 5.367); anyone familiar with Polybius would hear the resonances. See discussion in, Arthur M. Eckstein, “Josephus and Polybius: A Reconsideration,” Classical Antiquity 9 (1990): 175–208; Frank W. Walbank, Polybius, Rome and the Hellenistic World: Essays and Reflections (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002), 258–276; Fergus Millar, Rome, the Greek World, and the East, vol. 3: The Greek World, the Jews, and the East, ed. Hannah M. Cotton and Guy M. Rogers (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina), 51–66.

  29. The Vita, or “Life of Flavius Josephus,” is Josephus’ autobiography. Like all his works, it is written in Greek.  

  30. Editor’s note: For more on Berenice, see Malka Z. Simkovich, “Queen Berenice: A Woman of Contrasts,” TheTorah (2016).

  31. For a detailed discussion of how these events unfolded, see Steve Mason, “Why Did Judaeans Go to War with Rome in 66–67CE? Realist-Regional Perspectives” in Jews and Christians in the First and Second Centuries: How to Write Their History, ed., Peter J. Tomson, Joshua J. Schwartz Compendia Rerum Iudaicarum ad Novum Testamentum 13 (Leiden: Brill, 2014), 126–206.

  32. Cestius Gallus died in the interim. Editor’s note: For more on Vespasian and this war, see David Gurevich, “Why Did Vespasian and Titus Destroy Jerusalem?” TheTorah (2016).

  33. The author of 2 Maccabees came a close second, but he insisted that he was abridging a (lost) history, by Jason of Cyrene, not writing one (2 Macc 2.24–30).