Decorated initial-word panel of Deuteronomy, f.254v in the Harley MS 762. British Library
The Opening Of Devarim: A Recounting or Different Version of the Wilderness Experience?
Deuteronomy presents Moses’ account as a retelling of the story narrated in Exodus and Numbers. And yet, so many details contradict the earlier narrative. Here are ten examples.
Published: July 1, 2013
|
Last Updated: October 28, 2026
For more on the judicial system problem, see Bernard M. Levinson, “The Founding of Israel’s Judicial System,” TheTorah (2021); David Frankel, “Deuteronomy’s Jewish Democratic and Egalitarian Agenda,” TheTorah (2014).
See Editors, “Whose Idea Was It to Send Scouts?” TheTorah (2014). The story in Numbers itself is generally believed to be a combination of two versions, one from the Yahwist (J) and the other from the Priestly Text (P). See Editors, “Unscrambling the Scout Story with the Documentary Hypothesis,” TheTorah (2015). The differences between the story in Deuteronomy and Numbers is that the former was likely only aware of the J version, though how true it is to that version is unclear. See discussion in, David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “Using Deuteronomy to Fill in the Lacunae of Numbers’ Spies Story,” TheTorah (2016); David Frankel, “The Grain and Pomegranates of Mei Merivah (מי מריבה),” TheTorah (2015).
They do eventually say that the scouts frightened them (v. 28), but this is only after their initial panic and rebellion and the narrator/Moses never makes it clear that this in fact occurred.
See Editors, “Who Were the Loyal Scouts?” TheTorah (2014).
For more on this contradiction, see David Glatt-Gilad, “Reimagining the Israelite-Edomite Encounter,” TheTorah (2016); David Ben-Gad HaCohen, “Wandering in the Wilderness: Deuteronomy’s Ideological Harmonization of J and E,” TheTorah (2023).