Photo by Dmitry Schemelev on Unsplash
The Purification of a Niddah: When Silence Matters
Immersing in the Priestly Text: In support of Dr. Rabbi Zev Farber's contention in “The Purification of a Niddah: The Torah Requirement” that the Torah does not require women to immerse after niddah in order to become pure.
Published: August 9, 2014
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
[1] Admittedly, “there is no water to drink” – which is how the people formulate their complaint at Num 21:5 – could be bullied into implying the availability of undrinkable water. Even if one had the stomach for such rarified casuistry, one would first have to establish that the text and its readership presupposed essential uses for water besides drinking. Otherwise, what justification is there for construing “to drink” as qualifying rather than describing? Moreover, it must be wondered if brackish water was so plentiful why the miracle of Marah was not re-enacted? (At Marah Moses learnt how to make bitter water fit for human consumption; see Exod 15: 23-25.)
I reference menstruation here since one can assume that the women would have been menstruating, since this is a normal part of life. On the other hand, distempers such astsara‘at and zov need not have afflicted the wilderness generation on any large scale; in fact no more than a single instance of such individuals’ rustication is recorded (Num 5:2-3; aside from the non P story of Miriam in Num 12).
Lev 15:18 requires a couple to bathe after having relations. But postponing that bathing is nowhere threatened with punishment, in contradistinction to corpse-defiled persons who are sternly cautioned to get purified or else face karet (Num 19:13, 20). Moreover, failure of Lev 15:18’s couple to purify would cause no disruption to their private lives. It would probably keep them away from the sanctuary – although even that is not stated (see the Talmudic dispute at the end of tractate Yoma and elsewhere as to whether tevilah bizmannah mitsvah).
Isaac Sassoon, The Status of Women in Jewish Tradition, Cambridge University Press, 2011.
Jaubert’s French book of 1957 appeared in English translation as The Date of the Last Supper (Alba, 1965). Although Jaubert’s conclusions were assailed by a handful of scholars, James C. VanderKam reinstated her theory not only by defusing the attacks but more importantly by providing his own careful reading of the various Priestly itineraries. “The Origin, Character, and Early History of the 364-Day Calendar: A Reassessment of Jaubert’s Hypotheses” CBQ 41 (1979), pp. 390-411.
Deut recognizes the entire tribe of Levi as priests (Deut 18:1 et al). Not only in the story of Korah and his 250 levitic colleagues (Num 16), but throughout P all Levitic clans save the Aaronides are emphatically disbarred (Exod 28:1-8; Num 4:18-20; 17:5, 23; 18:1-7 etc.). Deut forbids all Israelites to partake of carrion (Deut 14:21); P, like Ezekiel, limits the prohibition to priests (Lev 22:8 etc.). Deut’s calendar of cultic repasts celebrated with household, servants, aliens, waifs and strays (Deut 12:6, 11-12,; 16:11) is completely precluded, nay overthrown, by P’s purity legislation.
Nid.7:4.
MS Assemani 66, New York, JTS 1956, p. 315.
Also known as baraita de-masekheth niddah, first published Frankfurt-am-Main 1889.
See Purity and Pollution in Zoroastrianism: Triumph over Evil by Jamsheed K. Choksy 1989 esp. pp 91-96.
As opposed to defilement conferred upon her – e.g. Lev 15:18. Accordingly the bottom falls out of the often touted a fortioi argument to the effect that ‘If the minor impurity of Lev 15:18 mandated washing, how much more so the weightier niddah impurity’.
Tevilah, which denotes immersion of the entire body in water, is the rabbinic counterpart of what Leviticus refers to as rahats besaro ba-mayim (e.g. Lev 15:5,6,7,8,10,11,21,22,27) and rahats kol besaro ba-mayim (Lev 15:16). In the story of Naaman the terms rahats be-and taval are used interchangeably (2Kgs 5: 10-14).
A parallel aggadah is found in the passage from the Tosefta quoted at the opening of the article,
“It says ‘On that day living waters shall flow out of Jerusalem’ [Zech 14:8]. Is it possible that those waters will mix with other springs? No – for it also says ‘On that day a fountain shall open… for purification and for a niddah’ [Zech 13:1]. Where do the waters go from there? To the ocean… (Tosefta Sukkah 3:3).
Responsa of Hatam Sofer, Yore De`ah responsum 194.
[15] One source left out of Farber’s taxonomy, and Rabbi Sofer’s, is the Meiri (Commentary to Niddah p.291):
Although tevilah for niddah and zavah is nowhere mentioned explicitly in the Torah, it was learnt on the basis of tradition by means of a binyan av from ‘they shall wash …until evening’ [Lev 15:18]. Others reasoned that if regarding the person who touches her bed it says ‘Let him launder his clothes and wash [bathe] in water’ [Lev 15:21] … how much more so the generator of that impurity herself. Later rabbis learnt it from akh be-me niddah yithhatta. However, some reject all the above derivations because the Talmud’s sole scripture supporting tevilat niddah is the hint from Zechariah cited in tractate Yoma from which they infer that tevilat niddah is oral Sinaitic halakhah (hilkhat sinai) but not biblically ordained. To my mind, however, it would not contradict the Talmud to derive it from the verses suggested by the above authors except that the Talmud’s proof-text [from Zechariah] is the only explicit text.