Setting up the Tabernacle. Illustration from the 1911 Illustrated History of the Bible by John Kitto
The Tabernacle: A Post-Exilic Polemic Against Rebuilding the Temple
The Priestly Torah discusses the Tabernacle at extraordinary length, emphasizing its portability. Nothing in P ever says this structure was meant to be temporary. P’s Tabernacle was not foreshadowing the Temple, but was a polemic against Haggai and Zechariah’s agitation to build the Second Temple.
Published: January 30, 2018
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
In P these seem to refer to the same entity.
Some examples of such polemical repetition in the Priestly Torah are:
- Double Tamid (perpetual daily offering) – P repeatedly mentions the need to offer a second lamb in the afternoon (Ex 29:39,41; Num 28:4,8). This seems designed to contradict or update the older concept of one only one tamid offering per day (e.g., Lev 9:17, Num 28:23).
- The twenty-gerah shekel – Ezekiel introduces what appears to be a new fiscal system which includes the twenty-gerah shekel (Ezek 45:12). It was evidently adopted by the Priestly Torah, where it is referenced four separate times (Exod 30:13; Lev 27:25; Num 3:47, 18:16).
- Daytime Shabbat – The Pentateuchal sources seem to be in disagreement about whether the day begins in the night or in the morning. The older stratum of P, which believes Shabbat starts in the morning, is likely aware of the position that Shabbat starts at night, and thus repeats “the day” multiple times in its story about Israel’s introduction to Shabbat (Exod 16). For more on this example, see my “Shabbat HaYom, HaYom, HaYom: Stylistic Repetition or Polemical Assertion?” com (2015)
- Israelites in the Tent – In P’s thinking, Levites may enter the Tent of Meeting when necessary, but not Israel. P underscores this by repeating the word “Children of Israel” five times in one sentence (Num 8:19), emphasizing Israel’s role versus that of the Levites.
Did the author and community behind The Temple Scroll resent the lack of explicit Pentateuchal authority for a temple and decide to compensate by having the deity at Sinai issue Moses with detailed plans for such an edifice? After the Scroll’s preamble, col. 3 line 4 explicitly prescribes the building of a bayit, and lest the bayit’s material were in doubt, line 7 specifies avnei gazit. Thereafter, columns 4-6 lay out the bayit’s architectural design in meticulous detail. Thus, the Scroll defies anyone who would claim that a temple was not divinely ordained at Sinai (The Temple Scroll edited by Yigael Yadin, Jerusalem 1977 vol.3 plates 18-21).
Cf. Lev 19:23; 23:10; 25:2; Num 15:2, 18; 35:10. Incidentally, bayit occurs some thirty times in these twenty verses devoted to house- tsara‘at – verse 36 cramming the word no fewer than three times. So it cannot be said that P is shy of the word bayit when legislating for life in the land.
The Tamid is described at Exod 29:42 as “a perpetual burnt-offering throughout your generations at the entrance to the Tent of Meeting.”
Though conjoined by “and,” what we have here is most likely an example of hendiadys – in which case miqdash and ohel mo‘ed are being equated. See also:
- Encamping before the mishkan eastward … keeping guard of the miqdash (Num 3:38)
- …and does not get sprinkled he has defiled YHWH’s mishkan ……and does not get sprinkled… he has defiled YHWH’s miqdash (Num 19:13, 20).
And not necessarily in name only, but also in its orientation. Its east-west axis, characteristic of ancient temples of the area, transpires from numerous verses (e.g., Exod 26:23, 40:22; Num 3:23,29,35,38 etc.). Some turn the mishkan’s orientation on its head to argue that P had the Jerusalem Temple in mind and unwittingly oriented its peripatetic tent east-west. The flimsiness of such an argument is patent.
Admittedly, some scholars doubt that Isa 66:1 means to object to the building of a temple since verse 20 of the same chapter refers uncritically to Israelites bringing their minchah to bet YHWH [the Lord’s house; the temple]. Moreover, because Isaiah 56-66 is considered to form a unit often dubbed Trito-Isaiah, 66:1 – according to these scholars – ought to be understood in the wider context of that literary unit. Not atypical is the argument of Jill Middlemas:
It is inconceivable that the presentation of the Temple as the location of the cultic worship of Israel’s deity can lie alongside its condemnation and rejection. Therefore, the interpretation of the expression as ‘What is this house …’ used as a criticism of the sanctuary is untenable. A more likely interpretation of Isa 66:1 necessitates its placement in its larger context.
Jill Middlemas, “Divine Reversal and the Role of the Temple in Trito-Isaiah,” in Temple and Worship in Biblical Israel: Proceedings of the Oxford OT Seminar (The Library of Hebrew Bible/Old Testament Studies 422; ed. John Day; London: T&T Clark, 2005), 164-187 [178]. Of course if one insists on concurrence between all elements of so-called Trito-Isaiah, then one has no choice but to deny the unique message of 66:1. Indeed one would have to force it into conformity with the unit’s every other utterance, including Isa 60:13 which appears to echo in both language and thought Ezekiel 43:7 (see further). Those who have outgrown the compulsion to reconcile by hook or by crook all diverse elements of the Pentateuch, are surely open to the idea of biblical books encompassing more than one voice. “Trito Isaiah” is a convenient scholarly construct; but not everyone is willing to stifle 66:1’s rare witness, to what we believe to have been a once outspokenly anti-temple ideology, for the sake of neat unanimity within that construct. Among the unwilling is Shalom Paul:
The final chapter of the book [of Isaiah] begins with a scathing theological polemic against those who would build an earthly sanctuary for God who dwells on high … [It is a] polemic against the popular view that the Temple on earth serves as the divine abode … This belief that the Temple was god’s sanctuary and resting place, is reflected in other biblical verses as well, e.g., Psalm 132 … v.14 “This is my resting place for all time; Here I will dwell for I desire it.” This motif of a temple as the earthly divine residence is prevalent also in Mesopotamian sources.
Shalom M. Paul, Isaiah 40-66 Translation and Commentary (Eerdmans Critical Commentary; Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2012). 608, 611.
Another voice to enter the fray is Psalm 132 – coming down full blast on Ezekiel’s side (see quotation infra).
For instance, Joseph Blenkinsopp writes:
Haggai and Zechariah … give no hint of any previous attempt to rebuild the temple, which at their time still lay in ruins (Hag 1:4). Both prophets attribute the foundation laying to Zerubabel and place it in the reign of Darius not Cyrus (Hag 2:18; Zech 4:9).
Ezra- Nehemiah: A Commentary by Joseph Blenkinsopp Philadelphia, PA 1988 p.100. See also “Was the Second Temple a Persian Project?” by James M. Trotter, SJOT vol. 15/1 (2001) pp.276-294. To account for Ezra’s variant history Blenkinsopp opines that the author “has simply telescoped events in the early Persian period to fit in with his own theological perspective”. Moreover, the chronology of the Achaemenid rulers seems confused in the Ezra account, which only adds to the skepticism about its reliability.
But was it undiluted faith in a temple’s efficacy that prompted Haggai to guarantee the people abundance if only they would build a temple (e.g. Hag 2:15-19), or did Achaemenid politics play a role as some scholars suspect? Trotter, for one, thinks that,
[T]he construction of the second temple was motivated by the administrative interests of the empire not the religious zeal of the local population… A sociological analysis of the relationship between the Persian imperial center and the Yehudite colony supports the view that the temple in Jerusalem would have served imperial goals….
James M. Trotter, op. cit. pp. 290-291. If imperial pressure actually tilted the balance in favor of the pro-temple faction, perhaps the Rabbis were onto something when they credited the Persians with building the second temple. See b. Yoma 9b-10a.
Terence Fretheim, “The Priestly Document: Anti-Temple?” VT 18 (1968): 313-329. Fretheim has been seconded by Propp: “For me as for Fretheim, P makes the most sense as a protest against the Temple hierocracy, continuing the argument of 2 Sam 7:5-6 … P is implicitly antimonarchical and anti-Temple, advocating instead worship in a tent as in days of yore.” (The Anchor Bible Exodus 19-40: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary by William H. C. Propp 2006 p. 732).