The Torah Begins with Creation to Defend Israel’s Right to the Land?

The theme of a divine creator’s right to assign territory to his people is pervasive in the Bible and ancient Near Eastern literature. Perhaps the rabbinic midrash which suggests that the Torah begins with creation to defend Israel against the accusation they stole the land of Canaan were onto something.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The Torah Begins with Creation to Defend Israel’s Right to the Land?." TheTorah.com, October 14, 2020. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-torah-begins-with-creation-to-defend-israels-right-to-the-land.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The Torah Begins with Creation to Defend Israel’s Right to the Land?" (2020, October 14). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-torah-begins-with-creation-to-defend-israels-right-to-the-land

Categories:

Bereshit

Published: October 14, 2020

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. For R. Isaac in the Tanchuma, as for Rashi, the purpose of the Torah is legislative; even the stories of the patriarchs and matriarchs are unnecessary. The notion that the Torah is a work of “law,” narrowly defined, rather than more generally “instruction,” dates at least as far back as the second century B.C.E.; see Thomas C. Römer and Marc Z. Brettler, “Deuteronomy 34 and the Case for a Persian Hexateuch,” Journal of Biblical Literature 119.3 (2000): 401-419, [p. 418 fn. 83]. To be clear, Rashi’s source is the Tanchuma—the opinion often expressed that this R. Isaac is Rashi’s father is mistaken. As will be seen below, Rashi frequently combines distinct rabbinic sources in his Torah commentary.

  2. This is similar to what we see in the book of Job, in which God shuts down Job’s questioning by asking him where he was when God was creating the universe and forming all of its wonders.

  3. The Hebrew text of Rashi is from alhatorah.org, which uses (in this passage) on MS Florence Pluteo III.03. The translation is based upon Morris Rosenbaum and Abraham M. Silbermann, Pentateuch with Rashi’s Commentary (London: Shapiro and Valentine, 1929–1934). Accessed via Sefaria.

  4. Micah Joseph Berdichevski, “In Two Directions,” in The Zionist Idea, ed. Arthur Hertzberg (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1997), 295–297. Hebrew original in Ba-Derekh 2 (Lipsiah, 1922): 18–20.

  5. This follows the reading in 4QDeutj and the LXX. The Masoretic Text and the Samaritan Pentateuch read ישראל here, which would mean that the boundaries of nations was determined based on the number of Israelites, an odd notion that is likely best explained as a late attempt by a scribe to correct the non-monotheistic implications of the original text. For more on this, see Jonathan Ben-Dov, “Are There Gods, Angels, and Demons in Deuteronomy?” TheTorah (2018).

  6. The text is unclear about whether YHWH and Elyon, the Most-High, are the same deity, and thus that YHWH is effectively in control of the entire world, or whether YHWH is merely a favored member of Elyon’s pantheon, who can choose his people and land.

  7. In the Greek and some English versions, this is vv. 10–12.

  8. Again, in some English versions this would be vv. 19-21, 25.

  9. God’s violent defeat of monsters appears again in Isaiah 51:9–11, where the defeat of Rahab culminates not in the founding of ancient Israel but in its re-founding in the return from Babylonian exile.

  10. Named for its first words, “When on high,” the Enuma Elish has been seen by many scholars as an influence on the depiction of God as dividing waters to form the world in Genesis 1.

  11. English text from, Benjamin Foster, Before the Muses: An Anthology of Akkadian Literature, 3rd ed. (Bethesda: CDL Press, 2005), 460.

  12. Here, earthly gods.

  13. Etymology of “Babylon” disputed by Ignace J. Gelb in 1955 in “The Name of Babylon,” available in Richard S. Hess and David Toshio Tsumura (eds.) I Studied Inscriptions from Before the Flood (Winona Lake: Eisenbrauns, 1994), 266–269.

  14. Here, heavenly gods.

  15. Foster, Before the Muses, 471.

  16. Another Mesopotamian text relating creation to the exaltation of a specific deity and thus, on the human plane, a specific place, is the Sumerian Eridu Genesis. In this text the gods create humanity and the animals, and apportion themselves among the cities, with the first and foremost being the city of Eridu, home of the god Enki. As another victory of water management, Enki saves humanity from the gods’ foolhardy flood, thus maintaining worship service for the gods who almost destroyed their worshippers completely. This act of saving humanity exalts Enki and Eridu.

  17. The inscription itself dates to around the late eighth or early seventh century, but the content of the inscription may be far older.

  18. Translation from Miriam Lichtheim, Ancient Egyptian Literature (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1975), 1.55.

  19. This papyrus dates to the mid-13th century, but its text is possibly centuries older. The various Egyptian cosmogonies generally feature the god of one city as the prime creator.

  20. Eckart Otto, Das Deuteronomium im Pentateuch und Hexateuch: Studien zur Literaturgeschichte von Pentateuch und Hexateuch im Lichte des Deuteronomiumrahmens (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, FAT 30, 2000) p. 108 and 247, argues that the Genesis 1:1–2:4a creation account is written to directly oppose the Persian/Zoroastrian claim that Ahura-Mazda is the creator and land distributor.

  21. Otto, op. cit. pp. 75, 108, 247. From p. 108: “Die Hexateuch Redaktion, die durch die Integration von P einen von der Schöpfung (Gen 1) bis zum Bundeschluß in Sichem (Jos 24) reichenden Zusammenhang herstellt, interpretiert den Landbesitz als Skopus ihres Werkes als Ziel der Schöpfung und unter Einbeziehung der Urgeschichte auch der Weltgeschichte.” According to Römer and Brettler, above, narrowly seeing Torah only as “Law” prejudices interpreters against the theory of the Hexateuch as a canonical reality.

  22. Difficult Freedom: Essays on Judaism (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, 1990): 16–17 (from “A Religion for Adults”).

  23. We see this claim as well with Cain, who was banished from the face of the land and from God (Genesis 4:14, 16).

  24. Shimon Gesundheit, “Der Anfang der Tora: Ansätze jüdischer Exegeten des Mittelalters zu einer theologischen Interpretation der Urgeschichte und mögliche Berührungspunkte zur modernen theologischen Forschung,” Zeitschrift für die alttestamentliche Wissenschaft 119 (2007): 602–610.