The War Against Midian: A Study for How the Priestly Torah Was Compiled

In revenge for the Midianite seduction, Phinehas takes the sacred utensils from the Tabernacle and leads the war against Midian. Many details in this story contradict other Priestly texts, giving us a glimpse into how the Priestly Torah was compiled.

SBL Style

Click to copy

"The War Against Midian: A Study for How the Priestly Torah Was Compiled." TheTorah.com, July 16, 2020. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-war-against-midian-a-study-for-how-the-priestly-torah-was-compiled.

APA Style

Click to copy

"The War Against Midian: A Study for How the Priestly Torah Was Compiled" (2020, July 16). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/the-war-against-midian-a-study-for-how-the-priestly-torah-was-compiled

The War Against Midian: A Study for How the Priestly Torah Was Compiled

War against the Midianites (detail), Balthasar Bernards, ca. 1720-1728. Rijksmuseum

Categories:

Matot

Published: July 16, 2020

|

Last Updated: September 7, 2026

  1. See Num 10:35; 14:44; 1 Sam 4:3; 2 Sam 5:21; 11:11; 15:24. See also Moshe Greenberg, “Ḥerem,” EJ 8:344–350.

  2. See e.g. b. Sotah, 43a; Jacob Milgrom, Numbers, JPS 4 (Philadelphia: JPS, 1990), 373–375.

  3. Editor’s note: See discussion in Tzemah Yoreh, “The Two Arks: Military and Ritual,” TheTorah (2020).

  4. See e.g. Numbers Rabbah. Mattot, 22d; Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 21–36, AB 4b (New York, Doubleday, 2000), 452.

  5. August Knobel, Die Bücher Numeri, Deuteronomium und Josua (Leipzig: S. Hirzel, 1861), 169; Carl F. Keil and Franz Delitzsch, Commentary on the Old Testament in Ten Volumes, trans., J. Martin et al. (Grand Rapid: Erdmans, 1986), 1:225.

  6. The copper/bronze altar was not inside the Tabernacle, but outside in the courtyard, and would thus have been seen by non-priestly Israelites. For this reason, it would not have symbolized the divine presence and would not have been taken into battle.

  7. Menahem Haran, “המשכן: טַאבּוּ מודרג של קדושה” [The Tabernacle: A Graded Taboo of Holiness], in מקרא ועולמו: מבחר מחקרים ספרותיים והיסטוריים [The Bible and its World – Selected Literary and Historical Studies] (Jerusalem: Magnes, 2009), 62–69.

  8. Non-Priestly traditions, however, do describe the separation of the Ark from the Tabernacle / Temple. See Num 10:33; 1 Sam 4:4–5.

  9. The technical Priestly term כפר על נפש means to pay ransom for one’s person. This indicates that the commanders’ contribution in this case was not some kind of thanksgiving sacrifice.

  10. William H. Propp, Exodus 19–40 (AB 2b; New York: Doubleday, 2006), 477; Manfred Oeming, “שָׁקַל šāqal,” TDOT 15:457–462, esp. 458–459.

  11. See v. 52 where 16,750 shekels were paid for 12,000 warriors.

  12. See e.g. Num 1:46; 2:9; 4:46.

  13. Although there is almost a consensus regarding the existence of a Priestly document in the Pentateuch, this apparent consensus includes very different views on the date of its composition, its independent or redactive nature, and the scope of its original stratum. For some discussions of these and other related issues see the articles published in Sarah Shectman and Joel S. Baden, eds. The Strata of the Priestly Writings, Abhandlungen zur Theologie des Alten und Neuen Testaments 95 (Zürich: Theologischer Verlag Zürich, 2009).

  14. George B. Gray, Numbers, International Critical Commentary 4 (Edinburgh: T.&T. Clark, 1903), 419; Philip J. Budd, Numbers, Word Bible Commentary 5 (Waco: Word Books, 1984), 329–330.

  15. August Dillmann, Die Bücher Numeri, Deuteronomium und Josua (Leipzig: S. Hirzel, 1886), 187; Norbert Lohfink, Theology of the Pentateuch – Themes of the Priestly Narrative and Deuteronomy, trans., Linda M. Maloney (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1994), 221–224; Reinhard Achenbach, Die Vollendung der Tora:‎ Studien zur Redaktionsgeschichte des Numeribuches im Kontext von Hexateuch und Pentateuch, Beihefte zur Zeitschrift fiir altorientalische und biblische Rechtsgeschichte 3 (Wiesbaden:‎‪ Harrassowitz,‎‪ 2003), 615–622.

  16. Menahem Haran, “Book-Scrolls at the Beginning of the Second Temple Period: The Transition from Papyrus to Skin,” HUCA 54 (1983), 111–122, [p. 115].

  17. See Joel S. Baden, “Identifying the Original Stratum of P: Theoretical and Practical Considerations,” in The Strata of the Priestly Writings, ed., Sarah Shectman and Joel S. Baden, Abhandlungen zur Theologie des Alten und Neuen Testaments 95 (Zürich: Theologischer Verlag Zürich, 2009), 13–29 [p. 18].

  18. Editor’s note: Another example of contradictory Priestly conceptions relates to how the main altar was built and when it was plated in bronze/copper. See discussion in, David Frankel, “The Bronze Plating of the Altar: Numbers Versus Exodus,” TheTorah.com (2017).

  19. Numbers 25:1–9 includes both Priestly and non-Priestly text portions. See Itamar Kislev, “P, Source or Redaction: The Evidence of Numbers 25,” in The Pentateuch: International Perspectives on Current Research, ed., Thomas B. Dozeman, Konrad Schmid and Baruch J. Schwartz eds. (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2011), 387–399.

  20. This leaves the words “and it came to pass after the plague” in Numbers 26:1 [25:19], which open the five-chapter digression and are followed by an open parasha, disconnected from any context.

  21. See e.g., Milgrom, Numbers, 218; Jacob Licht, פירוש על ספר במדבר [A Commentary on the Book of Numbers], 3 vols. (Jerusalem: Magnes, 1995) 3.112–113; Shemaryahu Talmon, “The Signification of אחרית and אחרית הימים in the Hebrew Bible,” in Emanuel – Studies in Hebrew Bible, Septuagint and Dead Sea Scrolls in Honor of Emanuel Tov, ed. Shalom M. Paul, Robert A. Kraft, Lawrence H. Schiffman, Weston W. Fields, VTsup 94 (Leiden: Brill, 2003), 795–810 [807–808].

  22. Editor’s note: For a brief look at some traditional solutions to this problem, see TABS Editors, “The Midianite War: Where Is Joshua?” TheTorah.com (2013).

  23. The need to grant Phinehas the high priesthood as a reward for his deed indicates that he was not entitled to it in the first place.

  24. Itamar Kislev, על סף הארץ המובטחת: תיאור ההכנות לכניסה לארץ ומקומו בהתהוות התורה [On the Threshold of the Promised Land: The Account of the Preparations for Entering Canaan and the Formation of the Pentateuch] (Jerusalem: Magnes, 2013).

  25. Editor’s note: For a discussion of the legal elements in this text from a redaction critical perspective, see Zev Farber, “Elazar Speaks Once in the Torah: Why Does He Interrupt Moses?” TheTorah (2017).

  26. For a comprehensive treatment of these issues see Ariel Kopilovitz, “The Legislation of War: A Study of the Story of the Israelite War against Midian (Numbers 31),” Shnaton – An Annual for Biblical and Ancient Near Eastern Studies 23 (2014), 17–53 [in Hebrew].

  27. Numbers 25:16–18 were added by P’s editors in order to bridge the gap between the two story parts.

    כה:טז וַיְדַבֵּר יְ־הוָה אֶל מֹשֶׁה לֵּאמֹר. כה:יז צָרוֹר אֶת הַמִּדְיָנִים וְהִכִּיתֶם אוֹתָם. כה:יח כִּי צֹרְרִים הֵם לָכֶם בְּנִכְלֵיהֶם אֲשֶׁר נִכְּלוּ לָכֶם עַל דְּבַר פְּעוֹר וְעַל-דְּבַר כָּזְבִּי בַת נְשִׂיא מִדְיָן אֲחֹתָם הַמֻּכָּה בְיוֹם הַמַּגֵּפָה עַל דְּבַר פְּעוֹר.
    25:16 YHWH spoke to Moses, saying, 25:17 “Assail the Midianites and defeat them, 25:18 for they assailed you by the trickery they practiced against you, because of the affair of Peor and because of the affair of their kinswoman Cozbi, daughter of the Midianite chieftain, who was killed at the time of the plague on account of Peor.”

    See e.g. Gray, Numbers, 387; Licht, Numbers, 3:45.