Alexandr Ivanov, 1806-1858
Torah Narratives with Angels Never Actually Happened: Heretical or Sublime?
Maimonides believes that any story in the Bible with angels is a prophetic vision. Nahmanides calls this position “forbidden to believe” and claims they are real occurrences. Must the Torah be historically true or just philosophically?
Published: October 27, 2015
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
See Ben Zion Katz’s TABS essay for a discussion of this interpretation, “God’s Appearance to Abraham: Vision or Visit?”
For some discussions on the biblical conception of God, see James L. Kugel, The God of Old (Free Press, NY, 2003); Benjamin D. Sommer, The Bodies of God and the World of Ancient Israel (Cambridge University Press, 2011); Michael Wyschogrod, The Body of Faith(New Jersey: Aaronson, 1983). See also Marc Brettler’s TABS essay, “Differing Conceptions of the Divine Creator.”
This explains how it is that God, in verses 13-14, repeats the words of one of the men in verse 10, and promises that when he returns Sarah will have a son. This is not the way that Ramban understands Maimonides. In his understanding, Maimonides thinks of all three men as angels who together represent God. He thus states, ואם במראה לא נראו אליו רק אנשים אוכלים בשר, איך אמר “וירא אליו ה'” כי הנה לא נראה לו השם לא במראה ולא במחשבה, וככה לא נמצא בכל הנבואות. In other words, if Abraham only saw three meat eaters in his vision, then God did not appear at all! Ramban, it seems, cannot entertain the possibility that for Maimonides one of these meat-eaters represents God!
For more on Maimonides’ view of prophecy, see Haim Kreisel’s TABS essay, “What is Prophecy?”
One might even include the story of the Sinai theophany in this list, since Maimonides famously suggests that the קול גדול of Sinai was a special “created voice,” which might, in Maimonidean terms, be an “angel” of sorts (=messenger/message from God). For a suggested interpretation of Maimonides along these lines, see Sam Fleischacker’s TABS essay, “Making Sense of the Revelation at Sinai: Revisiting Maimonides’ Eighth Principle of Faith.”
This is evident from the fact that his example of the first kind of prophetic figure is Jacob’s vision of the ladder reaching heaven. In this prophecy,
“The word ‘ladder’ refers to one idea; ‘set up on the earth’ to another; ‘and the top of it reached to heaven’ to a third; ‘angels of God’ to a fourth; ‘ascending’ to a fifth; ‘descending’ to a sixth; ‘the Lord stood above it’ to a seventh. Every word in this figure introduces a fresh element into the idea presented by the figure.
From this we may deduce that Maimonides considers other prophetic visions, such as that of Abraham and the three visitors who came to his tent, to include material that simply formed the context within which the message was embedded.
אבל יחשוב שהיו המעשים נעשים מאליהם והמאמרים בכל דבר ודבר מראה.
But [Maimonides] thinks that the events took place of themselves, but that the accompanying dialogue relating to all these matters were visions.
Ramban mockingly presents these events as occurring “of themselves,” since it doesn’t make sense that the people of Sodom would demand the release of men that only appeared to Lot in a vision, or that Jacob would limp on his thigh after his prophetic vision, or that Sarah would laugh after Abraham was told in a private vision that she would have a child. It is clear, however, that despite Ramban’s (real or feigned) conservative reading, Maimonides’ position is more radical. Maimonides explicitly refers not only to “conversations” as occurring within prophetic visions but to “events” as well.
For one possible Maimonidean reading of the binding of Isaac story, see Chaim Trachtman’s TABS essay, “The Maimonidean Akedah.”
I further believe that, for Ramban, a “slippery slope” problem is at play here as well. If patriarchal stories can be removed from historical reality and understood as dreams and visions, why not the Mt. Sinai story, for example? Could not this too be understood as something that happened in Moses’ dream?
For a philosophical/theological exploration of this point, see Amit Kula’s TABS essay,“Existential or Non-Essential: History and Torah, Religious Language and Conceptions of God.”