Why Can Women’s Vows Be Vetoed?

The vows of maiden daughters and wives are subject to veto by the woman’s father or husband. What does this say about the status of women in ancient Israel?

SBL Style

Click to copy

"Why Can Women’s Vows Be Vetoed?." TheTorah.com, August 3, 2016. https://www.thetorah.com/article/why-can-womens-vows-be-vetoed.

APA Style

Click to copy

"Why Can Women’s Vows Be Vetoed?" (2016, August 3). TheTorah.com. https://www.thetorah.com/article/why-can-womens-vows-be-vetoed

Why Can Women’s Vows Be Vetoed?

Hannah prays and makes a vow, from Die Bibel in Bildern, Julius Schnorr von Carolsfeld, 1860. Wikimedia

Categories:

Matot

Published: August 3, 2016

|

Last Updated: October 28, 2026

  1. Susan Niditch, “Vowing Women: Personal Religion, Gender, and Power” in Epigraphy, Philology, and the Hebrew Bible: Methodological Perspectives on Philological and Comparative Study of the Hebrew Bible in Honor of Jo Ann Hackett (eds. Jeremy Hutton and Aaron D. Rubin; Ancient Near Eastern Monographs; SBL Press: Atlanta, 2015), 329-342.

  2. For more discussion of Jephthah’s vow, see David Marcus, Jephthah and His Vow (Texas Tech University Press, 1986).

  3. Another question, for which we don’t really have an answer in the biblical text, is what would be the practical reality of a woman who makes a vow, has YHWH fulfill his end of the bargain, and then her father or husband hears of her pledge? Would he truly be empowered to constrain her from giving the pledged gift to the deity in return? The example of Hannah and Elkanah comes to mind; after the child has been granted, if Elkanah hears of the vow only as Hannah is about to fulfill it by dedicating the child to YHWH, according to Numbers 30 it is within his rights nullify the pledge. But would it have been conceivable to do so after God had fulfilled his end of the bargain?

  4. Levine sees Numbers 30 as a later, Persian period addition designed to restrict the ability of women to pledge the belongings of their fathers and husbands (Numbers 21-36. Anchor Bible Commentary Series, NY: Doubleday, 2000), 435. See also T.W. Cartledge, Vows in the Hebrew Bible and the Ancient Near East (JSOTSup 147; Sheffield: Sheffield University Press, 1992); J. Berlinerblau, The Vow and the ‘Popular Religious Groups’ of Ancient Israel: A Philological and Sociological Inquiry (JSOTSup 210; Sheffield: Sheffield University Press, 1996).

  5. The oft-cited example of the daughters of Zelophehad in Numbers 27 does not necessarily show that women controlled property in ancient Israel, but that women could, in very limited circumstances, inherit property in trust for their sons.

  6. It also specifies, however, that she may only eat of the offering if she is without offspring. See the discussion of this in Sarah Shectman, “The Social Status of Priestly and Levite Women,” in Levites and Priests in History and Tradition, (eds. Mark Leuchter and Jeremy Hutton; Atlanta: SBL Press) 2011, 83-99.

  7. Another anomaly, pointed out by Rashbam, is that the verse does not actually follow any command by God; Moses seems to be speaking on his own authority.

  8. וטעם וידבר משה אל ראשי המטות – כי אין צורך ללמד לכל בני ישראל שהאב והבעל יכולין להפר נדרי ענוי נפש, ואולי צריך להעלים אלה החוקים מהם שלא ינהגו קלות ראש בנדרים, אבל לחכמי ישראל ראשי שבטיהם לימד המשפט:

  9. See for example: Lev 1:2; 4:2; 7:28; Lev 11:2; 12:2; 15:2; 17:2; 18:2; 19:2; 20:2; 22:18; 23:2, 9, 23, 33; 25:2; 27:2; Num 5:2, 6, 12; 6:2; 9:10; 15:2, 18, 38; 17:16; 28:2.

  10. E.g. Lev 6:2, 18; 8:31; 16:2ff; 21:1; 22:2; Num 6:23; 8:2; 18:1, 8, 26; 19:1.

  11. For some discussion of patriarchy in ancient Israel, especially as it relates to ritual matters, see Ada Taggar-Cohen, “Why Are There No Israelite Priestesses?” TheTorah (2016). Carol Meyers has been at the forefront of arguments against the use of the term “patriarchy” to characterize biblical Israel for the past three decades: see most recently, Carol Meyers, “Was Ancient Israel a Patriarchal Society?” Journal of Biblical Literature, 133.1 (2014): 8-27. For further discussion of the complicated nature of women’s status in ancient Israel, see The Bible Now by Richard Elliott Friedman and Shawna Dolansky (Oxford University Press, 2011), chapter 3.

  12. It is worth noting that the nazirite legislation in Num 6 makes no mention of the possibility of veto. Nevertheless, Susan Niditch (“Vowing Women,” 339) assumes that the nazirite vow falls under the same purview as general vows in Num 30, and so a woman’s right to become a nazirite is just as circumscribed as any other vow. This seems likely to me, since I don’t see why nazirite vows would be an exception to the rules in num 30, which would seem to cover any type of woman’s vow.