Why the Torah Prohibits Incest
Although incest taboos are found in the majority of cultures, medieval Jewish thinkers found this to be an insufficient explanation for the Torah’s prohibitions.
Published: September 27, 2017
|
Last Updated: September 7, 2026
Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 17-22 (Anchor Bible Series; New York: Doubleday, 2000), p. 1530.
See, e.g., Laws of Hammurabi 154-159 and Hittite Laws 189-190.
See discussion in Delbert R. Hillers, “Analyzing the Abominable: Our Understanding of Canaanite Religion,” Jewish Quarterly Review 75 (1985): 253-269.
For an argument that ancient Egypt had no incest taboos, see, Paul John Frandson,Incestuous and Close-kin Marriage in Ancient Egypt and Persia: An Examination of the Evidence (Carsten Niebuhr Institute of Ancient Near East Studies 34; Copenhagen: Museum Tusculanum Press, 2009).
While some Jewish thinkers understood that a חוק is a law that has no reason, Maimonides understood that a חוק is a law that has no apparent reason. Thus he feels no qualms about offering an explanation for a law felt to be a חוק, particularly in his Guide, a work that is meant for the intellectually advanced reader.
The JPS Torah Commentary: Leviticus (Philadelphia: JPS, 1989), p. 254.
Commentary to Lev 18:6. Translation by Charles Chavel, Commentary on the Torah by Ramban (New York: Shilo, 1976), 247.
E. Westermark, Three Essays on Sex and Marriage (London: Macmillan, 1934) p. 147, cited by Yonatan Grossman, Avraham: Sippuro Shel Masa (Tel Aviv: Yediot Ahronoth, 2014), 234-235.
Longer commentary to Exodus 2:1.
Commentary to Lev 18:6. Translation by Charles Chavel, Commentary on the Torah by Ramban (New York: Shilo, 1976), 248. As noted earlier, Nahmanides also believes there to be a kabbalistic reason for these laws.
As Grossman, ibid., points out, this theory, generally attributed to Freud, predates him. See James G. Frazier, Totemism and Exogamy: A Treatise on Certain Forms of Superstition and Society, volume 4 (London: Macmillan, 1910), 97-98.
Maimonides and Bekhor Shor, two contemporaries, offer the same explanation as each other a number of times. On the possibility that the writings of one of them may have influenced the other, see my “Eglah Arufah: A Ritual Response to an Unsolved Murder,”TheTorah.com (2017), fn. 11.
The words “illicit unions” are Pines’ translation of the word עריות in the Judeo-Arabic original of the Guide. עריות presumably refers here specifically to incestuous relations, the ones forbidden in Lev 18:6-18.
Although this is not Maimonides’ main concern here, this phrasing points to the possibility that incest taboos prevent sex abuse of vulnerable girls/women.
Maimonides Guide of the Perplexed (trans., Shlomo Pines; Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1964) 3:49, 606.
Commentary to 18:6.
In his commentary to Deut 31:16, ibn Ezra hints in cryptic language that the Torah’s incest laws applied only in the land of Israel. Thus the ostensibly forbidden marriages of Abraham and Sarah, Jacob and Leah and Rachel, and Amram and Yocheved, were not a problem since they all took place outside of Israel. See Abarbanel’s strong criticism (in his commentary to Lev 18) of ibn Ezra’s position.
Perhaps Maimonides learned this explanation from reading ibn Ezra, though they both may have simply been adapting Aristotle’s views to the passage. On the question of whether Maimonides’s works demonstrate acquaintance with ibn Ezra’s commentaries, see Isadore Twersky, “Did Rabbi Abraham ibn Ezra Influence Maimonides?” [Heb.], in Harris, Jay and Twersky, Isadore eds., Rabbi Abraham ibn Ezra: Studies in the Writings of a Twelfth-Century Jewish Polymath (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Center for Jewish Studies, 1993), Hebrew section pp. 21-48. For strident criticism of Maimonides’ attitude to sexuality, see Samuel David Luzzatto’s commentary to Exod 21:10.
Guide ibid., p. 608. Ibn Ezra also considers all sexual activity potentially harmful. See e.g. Yesod Mora Ve-sod Torah: An Annotated Critical Edition, second revised and enlarged edition, by Joseph Cohen and Uriel Simon (Ramat Gan: Bar Ilan University Press, 2007), p. 150: “משכב הנשים יכלה כחו ובשרו בקרוב הזמן—fornication with women saps a man’s strength and causes the premature degeneration of his body.”
Commentary to Lev 18:6. Translation by Charles Chavel, Commentary on the Torah by Ramban (New York: Shilo, 1976), p. 247.
Commentary on Leviticus 18:5 and see also his commentary on the following verses.
Precise dates for Nissim are not known.
Nissim of Marseilles commentary on Lev 18, in Maaseh Nissim, edited by Howard Kreisel (Jerusalem: Mekize Nirdamim, 2000), 382-383.
In the twentieth century, Claude Levi-Strauss also interpreted the societal benefits of incest laws similarly in his The Elementary Structures of Kinship, translated by J. H. Bell (Boston: Beacon Press, 1969). See, for example, p. 481: “The prohibition of incest is less a rule prohibiting marriage with the mother, sister or daughter, than a rule obliging the mother, sister or daughter to be given to others. It is the supreme rule of the gift…”